Mini 1849 : DotA Mafia [R2 - SD] Game Over?!!

[Dunnstral]

That's what I picked in the last dota mafia as mafia to win with. Lina.

[Dunnstral]

How is that terrible

[Dunnstral]

Not sure if the extra votes were disabled in lylo when I played it

[JaeReed]

UNVOTE:
Do you think nat is town jae

Don't know, don't care. I'll look at associations over the night phase after Titus flips mafia, which she will. I am completely confident that Titus is mafia and after that we can work things out from there with associatives. The way I see it the partner can either be you or nat. I don't want 2 scum going into the next phase, so we lynch the one I am confident is actually mafia then argue it out tomorrow, ok?

[xSoniaNevermindx]

rwtwwe
yes boss
VOTE: Titus
Did you read me vs LLD

[Titus]

Nahdia, I am windranger. Why u lie?

[Titus]

UNVOTE:
Do you think nat is town jae

Don't know, don't care. I'll look at associations over the night phase after Titus flips mafia, which she will. I am completely confident that Titus is mafia and after that we can work things out from there with associatives. The way I see it the partner can either be you or nat. I don't want 2 scum going into the next phase, so we lynch the one I am confident is actually mafia then argue it out tomorrow, ok?

I wanna mislynch Titus.

[Nahdia]

With Radical Rat's hero/ability picks, you really would think I'm scum. It's a

terrible

pick for town and a pretty good pick for scum.

How is that terrible

There's no strong utility for town. Multi-voting is inherently anti-town and the only situation where it's actually a integral part of a town is when you've got both 3rd parties and mafia which threaten to band together. The psuedo-motion detector role is 1) very low power and 2) again, multivoting is inherently anti-town. The delayed rolestopper is just.... well, it's an unreliable scattershot roleblock. You can't roleblock one person in particular to test things, at very best you target someone who dies which then you know it roleblocks a scum the next night, but that's nullified if you, you know, actually do your fucking job right and lynch mafia

during the day

not to mention you might be randomly roleblocking town at the same time. Wanton chaos and weird scattershot roleblocks aren't

ideal

for mafia but at the very least you can still play around it yourselves since you know what's up, and you can still intentionally cause a delayed roleblock on someone who is telegraphing their abilities, something that's fucking weird and pointless as town because if you want to roleblock someone one night down the line, why would you not just fucking want to LYNCH THEM during the day instead??

Decent role for scum, t e r r i b l e role for town.

[Nahdia]

Nahdia, I am windranger. Why u lie?

Oh, sorry, I thought you were asking my role. I could find your role but I'm not going to bother.

[xSoniaNevermindx]

Wait a sec...I don't think RR ever said he was Lina

[Nahdia]

He did.

[Nahdia]

I am

so

sorry everyone.

I got a bit caught up in other things and completely forgot about Mafia. To my knowledge, I was not prodded though.

At any rate, I'm Lina. I used Dragon Slave on LLD last night, but that clearly didn't go through.

[xSoniaNevermindx]

Dang I thought Nat slipped

[Nahdia]

How would that even be a slip regardless of if RR said it?

[Titus]

Hey Sonia, what would you do if I randomly hugged you?

[xSoniaNevermindx]

Try to find where you're hiding the knife

[Titus]

Ok, I was beginning tonget concerned you were just jumping to whatever anyone was saying.

[Nahdia]

the scumteam might actually be Dunnstral & Titus lmao

[JaeReed]

rwtwwe
yes boss
VOTE: Titus
Did you read me vs LLD

A bit of it. I have to clean for tomorrow since we're having people over in about an hour, and again tomorrow (keep in mind I'm like a day ahead of you), so reading up fully is second to that, but I am trying to keep up with things. LLD's reaction wasn't particularly telling for her there, but I think you look less like a partner because of it.

[Titus]

Was this slot just a preordained mislynch since LLD subbed out?

[JaeReed]

the scumteam might actually be Dunnstral & Titus lmao

It's not an impossibility, but I'm still weirded out by the fact that A) you gave a tr on math for defending lld (I think?) and B) sick I think wanted to lynch lld? also C) you're not trying to read me at all and I know you should be perfectly capable of calling me town or mafia just from knowing me outside of mafia and knowing what I'm absolutely not capable of doing to someone without believing in it wholeheartedly.

The last time you didn't try at all to read me you were scum. What the hell am I meant to think given that?

[Dunnstral]

the scumteam might actually be Dunnstral & Titus lmao

Then me unvoting creature was ???

Also, I like how me voting you made me go from top townread to scum with somebody else.

[Nahdia]

the scumteam might actually be Dunnstral & Titus lmao

It's not an impossibility, but I'm still weirded out by the fact that A) you gave a tr on math for defending lld (I think?) and B) sick I think wanted to lynch lld? also C) you're not trying to read me at all and I know you should be perfectly capable of calling me town or mafia just from knowing me outside of mafia and knowing what I'm absolutely not capable of doing to someone without believing in it wholeheartedly.

The last time you didn't try at all to read me you were scum. What the hell am I meant to think given that?

Groan.

I'll just be plain with this, because not explaining is going to be worse than explaining even though explaining is setting myself up for a problem similar to the one I was trying to avoid in the first place. So here you go:



I don't try to read friends who I think are going to take my reads on them personally. Ever. As any alignment.

There, I said it.

[Nahdia]

I mean, don't get me wrong, I

try

, but I'm super averse to making it any kind of focal point for my own content.

[Titus]

Ok, which one of you fuckers is afraid of getting two votes on them tomorrow?