Micro 672: Vanillish Mafia (Game Over!)

[Aristophanes]

<3 you guys!

VC 2.1

Spade_Ace

(2): Think Tank 151, KainTepes 155

Not Voting

(5): Aelin, Spade_Ace, Hiraki, Karnos 179, TheRealGin-N-Tonic 181

With 7 alive, it takes 4 votes to lynch

Mod Notes: You guys really are great!
Having lots of fun! Hope you are too!

[ThinkBig]

<3 you to! Best mod ever!

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

<3 You host confirmed me, what's not to love

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

GET BACK IN YOUR TANK

[Think Tank]

Meh, didn't feel like switching accounts to help grab the top of the page.

[Aristophanes]

<3 you to! Best mod ever!

<3 You host confirmed me, what's not to love

=D

I feel the love!

Also, the out of hydra posting is absolutely fine and forgiven in this case

[Think Tank]

Time to get back to the game!

~Think

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Think, what's your thoughts on Kain, Spade, Hiraki and Karnos?

[Think Tank]

I think the most likely team is karnos/spade/kaine.

Karnos

-His entrance to the game was rather scummy. He started with an RVS vote on himself when we were 82 posts in, well past RVS.
-He attempts to portray Spade as scum by arguing that he would have been QH by scum if he were town. While I tend to agree with this logic, this paints him as scum as well. Jin voted for Karnos and didn't unvote more than 12 hours after his initial vote. The scum team would have had plenty of time to coordinate a quick hammer during this period.

Spade

-His derp hammer on TF screamed scum. After we finished speaking about why we shouldn't hammer on page 5, he comes in and quick hammers.
-If he was town, then scum would most likely have QH him by now (see above).

Kaine

-Overall he is impossible to read and difficult to make a decision on. I don't like how he immediately sheep's my vote on Spade.

~Think

[Think Tank]

Hiraki

-I have a slight town read on him.

~TB

[Think Tank]

@Jin - I'm currently reviewing TF's analysis prior to getting hammered. Do you have any thoughts on his reads?

Spoiler: TF

Hiraki is town. Don't lynch him. Thinktank or karnos is probably the remaining townie.

I buy think tank as town.

Spade kain karnos it is. Enjoy.

Lynch karnos before kain.

First spade then karnos. Do it for town.

I just misrepresented your argument, but it still sucks, karnos.

You think I would be scared of a scum quickhammer? With spade already on hiraki? Don't make me laugh.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

I've eliminated ThinkTank from the scum pool for post 25 and post 87. I couldn't connect ThinkTank to anyone besides Hiraki and Tier and half of those ended up being town.


That leaves

1) Karnos, Kain, Spade
2) Karnos, Kain, Hiraki
3) Karnos, Spade, Hiraki
4) Kain, Spade, Hiraki

[Think Tank]

That leaves

1) Karnos, Kain, Spade
2) Karnos, Kain, Hiraki
3) Karnos, Spade, Hiraki
4) Kain, Spade, Hiraki

Karnos - 4x
Spade - 3x
Hiraki -3x
Kain - 3x

Based upon this, there are 4 ways in which karnos is scum, 3 ways in which the others are scum.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

I'm theoretically voting for Spade, 7 posts and it's literally a cringy ISO

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

So...

1) Karnos, Kain, Spade
2) Karnos, Spade, Hiraki
3) Kain, Spade Hiraki

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

1) Spade, Karnos, Kain
2) Spade, Karnos, Hiraki
3) Spade, Kain, Hiraki

repost because this looks so much neater

[Think Tank]

1) Spade, Karnos, Kain
2) Spade, Karnos, Hiraki
3) Spade, Kain, Hiraki

From this, Spade is conf!scum. If/when he does flip scum, who do you think we should focus on next?

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Karnos

ISO both Spade and Karnos

You'll notice they vote for Tier near the same time; they vote for Hiraki near the same time; Karnos attempts a preemptive bus but unvotes 10 minutes after finding out Spade is at L-1.

[Think Tank]

Taking spade out of the equation (assuming he is scum), we get this:

1) Karnos, Kain
2) Karnos, Hiraki
3) Kain, Hiraki

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

After I die, vote for Karnos if you're town.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

I'm ready to end the game.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

I'll wait for Aelin's thoughts tho

[Think Tank]

After I die, vote for Karnos if you're town.

Will do.

I'm ready to end the game.

As am I. I think we have solved the game.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

I hate Think Tank purely for the amount of WIFOM my mind gets from thinking every move he makes is scum. Kinda curious how I'd read Think if I didn't play a scum game with Pine

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

VOTE: Spade