Timeshift Mafia III [Game Over]

[Land of Xanth]

I meant Comm to Sly

After unvoting Comm, he called James town, poked at me, and questioned Fuzzy before landing on Sly.

Still not buying your read.

-G

This stands as true.

-G

[CommKnight]

Let's do a check on all of his posts shall we?

First Post

Hi guys! I didn't realize that the game had started, I'm reading back now.

Introduction post, doesn't count for anything. Nothing of substance.

Second Post

Okay so I totally believe James obviously. I'm not convinced that it is Comm though.

Vote: Uzi

is where I'm at right now. It seemed like they were trying hard to make their James doubt seem Town.

Short 2-liner with a vote. Nothing really analyzed, which part of Uzi's posts seemed like they were trying too hard? Like which specific part? Seems like sheeping for the first line of easy reads.

Third Post

Yeah I think James and Comm are Town too. I agree with the people saying that.

Uzi still seems possible I guess, he hasn't done anything especially Town. I could also see it being Tywin for some reason, I'm not sure how to articulate why though.

Sheeps consensus that I'm town now, just basically "I agree". Then his post about Uzi, it's like he's projecting himself unto Uzi because this is his third post and nothing "especially Town" yet! Then casts shade on Tywin because you know, he can't explain why!

Fourth Post

Meh, it could be SlySly. I mean, he hasn't done anything particularly redeeming.

Most scum that I've played with would withdraw in this situation rather than doubling down, so I'm not scumreading him super hard, but it seems possible-ish. I dunno. I can definitely conceive of Town thinking the way that SlySly is, it isn't this super outlandish thing like some of you guys are making it out to be.

I think Xanth is Town and I'm for sure not Townreading Tywin, I'm going to keep my vote on Uzi though. His recent vote on Sly felt a little desperate and like he was just agreeing with what others had said to get off the hook.

Again, he calls someone else out as not doing anything really yet what has he done up to this point? More shading. Still going after Uzi as "desperate" but look at what he's doing. GRASPING AT STRAWS STILL. Yet again, "I agree".

Fifth Post

Meh, it could be SlySly. I mean, he hasn't done anything particularly redeeming.

Most scum that I've played with would withdraw in this situation rather than doubling down, so I'm not scumreading him super hard, but it seems possible-ish. I dunno. I can definitely conceive of Town thinking the way that SlySly is, it isn't this super outlandish thing like some of you guys are making it out to be.

Cautious scum found.

Not really.

100% usless post, expand on why you don't agree.

So out of 5 posts, first and fifth are fillers and he's done a crud job about doing anything townie as of yet but seems all too willing to call others out for not doing so much. Yet everyone he's called out has been more active and contributed much more to the conversation than he has.

So Tywin, what do you think of this analysis?

Fastposted a few times. Yep, Tywin is the towniest of the lot at the moment.

[Vifam]

I guess I just assumed the post happened earlier off memory my b

[PeregrineV]

@Tywin

- Except that your vote and rationale boils down to a OMGUS vote. Would rather see attempted discussion by you of either Xanth or SlySly early reads list.

Except this isn't true at all. Have you not read anything Sly or I have said? All I did was point out the facts, which show that he is insanely scummy. Why are you ignoring that? Do you TR sly for admitting he wants to policy lynch a cop claim that he believes is town? Do you TR him for not scum hunting at all, yet trying to discredit those that have? Or is it his shade throwing that are clearly misinformation or outright lies on what has actually happened in the game? You tell me, because you seem to have ignored everything said by him or me, and instead you just discredit my case/vote by calling it OMGUS.

If scum attack a townie, and in doing so, show that they're scum, is it OMGUS for that townie to vote the scum? What is your definition of 'scummy' if Sly looks town to you?

Your case was
1.

This guy admits to wanting to policy lynch a cop claim, admits to thinking it will flip town,

2.

Oh, and then he goes on to throw shade on me randomly by saying I don't read the game (which wouldn't be AI regardless), even though I have almost twice as many posts as him

Making it approximately half of it "Throwing shade on you", which is aka OMGUS.

But, I could be wrong, I am behind a page. Let me catch up and see if things changed.

[Land of Xanth]

I guess I just assumed the post happened earlier off memory my b

I could've bought that... if you hadn't

I think he already established he thoughts on James before the vote

I guess those other two things are legit but that's not really much

tried to move the goalposts by saying his read on James coming before his vote on Sly was a reason to dismiss it.

-G

[Vifam]

Nah I was just mistaken

[CommKnight]

Other inactives/flying below radar currently:

TheFuzzyLogic - 3 posts.
Zekromaster - 2 posts.
Narna - 0 posts.
Harp - 0 posts.

So 5 total out of 17 players have 5 or less posts!!! Anyone want to apply pressure? Prob?

[ssbm_Kyouko]

Hmm that's a nice post Comm
VOTE: Skelda

[Land of Xanth]

Other inactives/flying below radar currently:

TheFuzzyLogic - 3 posts.
Zekromaster - 2 posts.
Narna - 0 posts.
Harp - 0 posts.

So 5 total out of 17 players have 5 or less posts!!! Anyone want to apply pressure? Prob?

Votes on inactive slots are worse than unused votes because they give the appearance of trying to be productive when the fact of the matter is those votes are wasted because the players in those slots are not being pressured by them.

-G

[CommKnight]

@Xanth, you 100% skipped over my post about Skelda because you were too worried about vifam's one-liner replies. The 0 post people should be probed and Zekro and Fuzzy are active but they need to be called out. While Skelda's posts so far have been reeking scum-marine.

[Vifam]

I can't believe I get vilified for posting in 1 liners @_______@

[Land of Xanth]

@Xanth, you 100% skipped over my post about Skelda because you were too worried about vifam's one-liner replies. The 0 post people should be probed and Zekro and Fuzzy are active but they need to be called out. While Skelda's posts so far have been reeking scum-marine.

I don't really care about your little crusade. He was a scumread of mine long before you started crowing about it.

-G

[PeregrineV]

I'd dayvig Fuzzy Logic.

Why?

I am the town 1x lynch bait

Save us a lynch.

I took that as sarcasm. You know I need a jump start sometimes. Help a brother out. What am I missing? Is town 1x lynch bait a real thing or am I just unaware of Fuzzy's meta?

Someone asks who to shoot when half the players haven't checked in yet?

The real answer is everyone who hasn't check in yet. But, in case they wanted a semi-real answer, then Fuzzy Logic, for his single RVS post that also slightly supports James' whole claiming strategy.

[Land of Xanth]

Someone asks who to shoot when half the players haven't checked in yet?

A third, wasn't it?

Still, I think that's lovely reason to call b/s on the question entirely.

-G

[Land of Xanth]

Comm you seem to be trying really hard to get our attention.
Why?
-Ali

[SlySly]

Someone asks who to shoot when half the players haven't checked in yet?

The real answer is everyone who hasn't check in yet. But, in case they wanted a semi-real answer, then Fuzzy Logic, for his single RVS post that also slightly supports James' whole claiming strategy.

Thank you. I understand now.

[Harp]

hi fam

[Land of Xanth]

Hi Harp.
Talk to me about the videa game.

-Ali

[Tywin Lannister]

In my experience, someone that gets booted by a mod and not mod killed end up flipping scum, since mod killing them D1 hurts game balance.

KAIN TEPES posted a cipher claim, ciphers are against the rules (encrypted text) so he was force replaced. Not getting modkilled is NAI

Tell that to Sly for TRing the slot for it then? I just gave my own experience, which was to show that the opposite can be true of the Kain slot as well.

[Tywin Lannister]

Kain (your top TR for an unknown reason)

Again, not reading.

KainTepes - didn't read his crumb, but don't think scum be stupid enough to crumb something to get them kicked out of game

No, I read it, and it's not a reason to TR the slot. Just like Kyouko said, it's NAI. So again, it's an unknown reason.

[Tywin Lannister]

KainTepes - didn't read his crumb, but don't think scum be stupid enough to crumb something to get them kicked out of game

[/quote]

A lot of the conversation between him today feels like he's really on everyone case, that's not really a problem but I don't really feel like he's truly digesting anything. He's kind of gone from tunnel to tunnel when transitioning from Comm to Knight and he hasn't really commented on many other players between then. The lack of pause strikes me as weird since he seems like a more detailed type of player

I don't really know what this means, but fair enough. It's a reason. I just got home from work, so I'm fully catching up now. I post throughout the day when I have time/breaks/lunch, but it isn't enough time to be responding to every player/post that aren't directed toward me, and I still can't get to all of them.

[D3f3nd3r]

Replacement for KainTepes has been found, he'll be in once I get him his Role PM later tonight.

[Tywin Lannister]

Sly quote wasn't meant to be in that, but I'm on phone.

[Tywin Lannister]

@peregrin: okay so calling half my case on Sly OMGUS is still different than saying everything I said boils down to OMGUS. That's not true, because I don't vote someone I don't think is scum, and the definition of OMGUS in MS's own wiki is: OMGUS stands for "Oh My God, You Suck (for voting for me)!". it is sometimes used as a shorthand to indicate that you are voting for someone primarily because they voted for you.

1. Sly isn't voting me
2. I've clearly stated why I SR him. It just so happens that his misreps, shading, and flat out lies were against me.

So again: why do you ignore the actual case and everything both he and I have said, and instead try to discredit my CASE/SR using a buzzword that doesn't fit? Do you TR Sly, and if so, why? If not, why are you defending him? He seems pretty capable of handling himself here.

[Tywin Lannister]

Hmm that's a nice post Comm
VOTE: Skelda

Care to elaborate what you like/agree with about comm's post? Any thoughts to add? Why such low effort from you?