Star Wars Rogue One [GAME OVER]

[Titus]

actually....Molla full claims his previous role or eats rope/lead depending on which he finds tastier.

I support this.

I do not think its outside the realms of possibility that Molla fakeclaims that his buddy targets him. Its tinfoily and jazz but you could say the same for a still living investigation role. Titus and/or Mastin are my preferred lynches thus far.

vote:Titus

Dude, your shade hat is in full force. You are not directly counterclaiming Molla, as you're pushing my lynch instead. If my memory serves, Molla also claimed his result before the guilty.

This looks like a roundabout way of just attacking anyone who suspected Infinity and is really worse given that I was right on Klingon.

VOTE: Nero

VOTE: Titus

No this isn't chainsawing, this vote from Titus is just atrocious. Her play around Klingon still makes sense as scum.

Now, why would you want to rope me and Rolefish BBMolla? Scum vanillaizing themselves isn't even moonlogicky enough for me.

Because if Molla is scum he could easily be lying about being vanillized?

And he'd lie before the guilty?

[Heartless]

No this isn't chainsawing, this vote from Titus is just atrocious. Her play around Klingon still makes sense as scum.

explain plz?

i don't quite follow

[Drunken Piper]

The problem is that no one has really done anything scummy

[Heartless]

a couple questions for aj:

1. what do you think is inadequate about the way the rogue crew currently is?

Already looked for associations. I didn't see anything other than Luv was probs town, as was infinity. There's very little in the ISO that's useful anymore given who's died. That's my opinion so feel free to look, but I just didn't see anything.

2. that's really it? how about mastin? how about the however many ppl on the failed d1 wagon? how about titus? nothing out of that?

[SirCakez]

actually....Molla full claims his previous role or eats rope/lead depending on which he finds tastier.

I support this.

I do not think its outside the realms of possibility that Molla fakeclaims that his buddy targets him. Its tinfoily and jazz but you could say the same for a still living investigation role. Titus and/or Mastin are my preferred lynches thus far.

vote:Titus

Dude, your shade hat is in full force. You are not directly counterclaiming Molla, as you're pushing my lynch instead. If my memory serves, Molla also claimed his result before the guilty.

This looks like a roundabout way of just attacking anyone who suspected Infinity and is really worse given that I was right on Klingon.

VOTE: Nero

VOTE: Titus

No this isn't chainsawing, this vote from Titus is just atrocious. Her play around Klingon still makes sense as scum.

Now, why would you want to rope me and Rolefish BBMolla? Scum vanillaizing themselves isn't even moonlogicky enough for me.

Because if Molla is scum he could easily be lying about being vanillized?

And he'd lie before the guilty?

What guilty?

No this isn't chainsawing, this vote from Titus is just atrocious. Her play around Klingon still makes sense as scum.

explain plz?

i don't quite follow

Which part?

[Heartless]

the part where you were saying her play around klingon makes sense as scum

[Aj The Epic]

I don't know enough about the crew to say regardless. We don't know what you all have talked about or what roles you get, or even how they're distributed. If you're referring to my vote, I'm just more sure Infinity is town.

With mastin, I noticed it. However my issue is I can't tell if she actually sniped pine out super hard or if it's scum theatre. That's why I said I can't figure it out. Same with Titus, but more so because I'm not unsure the primary objective of that was to tie Pine to Infinity and get on his good graces by some awkward white knight.

[Heartless]

/sigh

aj, i gotta say...

i'm looking through pinetonic iso and i'm finding it very hard to believe you would just find what i already mentioned (about LUV) and say you came up empty.

i'm finding stuff for:
>cakez
>titus
>twie
>mastin
>nero

....

fdsajklf;jas;ldfkealwpoiiiii8hahfdajsfiew;lds;ajfe;iwj;fcasdkljfkl;jafsd

[Heartless]

I don't know enough about the crew to say regardless. We don't know what you all have talked about or what roles you get, or even how they're distributed. If you're referring to my vote, I'm just more sure Infinity is town.

in terms of mechanics, unless you flat out want one of us (heartless+infinity+piper) kicked out of the crew there's really no point in voting a new rogue leader in

[Heartless]

With mastin, I noticed it. However my issue is I can't tell if she actually sniped pine out super hard or if it's scum theatre.

well...

tonic's approach to mastin was mostly discrediting (any of his posts on that page) while pine's was a hybrid of discrediting and appeasement

do EITHER of those sound like the way scum would treat a scumbuddy to you?

[Aj The Epic]

Absolutely. That's a VERY EASY play, especially compared to having to dig up cases on each other.

[Nero Cain]

So AJ, why aren't you voting Titus?

[Heartless]

non sequitur

[Heartless]

are you saying that pine and tonic would've been too lazy to make a case and call mastin scum or....

...

what?

[Heartless]

VOTE: aj

[Nero Cain]

:/

[SirCakez]

the part where you were saying her play around klingon makes sense as scum

Attempting to pocket Klingon by backing off of her was what it looks like now.

Pine's behavior around mastina means she's probtown, agreed.

[Aj The Epic]

are you saying that pine and tonic would've been too lazy to make a case and call mastin scum or....

...

what?

No. It IS easier but there's a reason I'd expect this first that's a bit of a different direction. Mainly, doing attacks like this doesn't exactly encourage case building or reviews through ISOs. It's also not necessarily drawing them into the limelight. It's almost a defensive measure where you take it in case one dies. Full on cases may make better 'scum theatre' overall, but it almost guarantees the incrimination of one or both playing. My thought is 'does this look like Mastin/Pine leaving distance between themselves?' Does mastin actually catch Pine like this or does she have prior knowledge? Because I don't see what I expect in town v scum: a long, drawn out fight with one on a complete defensive and losing to compelling evidence.

[Heartless]

it clicked for me:

> the only time pinetonic saw fit to mention a read on aj was in this post where he lazily just kind of toyed around with a quasi-scumread. Post 162 NEITHER pine nor tonic himself saw fit to follow up

> aj's content itself has been disappointing. even though there's a flipped scum and that scum has... 117 posts all he's done is regurgitate what i said the rest of his thoughts is just a quagmire of jfkl;dsajfkl;mewlkfj;lkajf

> aj's critics either end up dead (desp) or with a crowbar to the knee (bbmolla)

aj is scum

[Heartless]

the part where you were saying her play around klingon makes sense as scum

Attempting to pocket Klingon by backing off of her was what it looks like now.

Pine's behavior around mastina means she's probtown, agreed.

yes, pocketing someone who's about to die

flawless scum strategy

[Heartless]

Because I don't see what I expect in town v scum: a long, drawn out fight with one on a complete defensive and losing to compelling evidence.

...

what?

are you reading the same game i am? mastin planted her vote on pine and didn't move

[Nero Cain]

I'm not as sold on Mastina as you, Infinity and Heartless. Mastins reasoning for wanting to lynch Pine was scare-non existent. All I remember is her saying to trust her. Given that Pine's role basically confirmed him as scum it would make plenty of sense as a bus.

[Heartless]

are you saying that pine and tonic would've been too lazy to make a case and call mastin scum or....

...

what?

No. It IS easier but there's a reason I'd expect this first that's a bit of a different direction. Mainly, doing attacks like this doesn't exactly encourage case building or reviews through ISOs. It's also not necessarily drawing them into the limelight. It's almost a defensive measure where you take it in case one dies. Full on cases may make better 'scum theatre' overall, but it almost guarantees the incrimination of one or both playing. My thought is 'does this look like Mastin/Pine leaving distance between themselves?' Does mastin actually catch Pine like this or does she have prior knowledge? Because I don't see what I expect in town v scum: a long, drawn out fight with one on a complete defensive and losing to compelling evidence.

this...

is so counterintuitive

summary of what i'm seeing here:

mastin/pine fight ----????????-----> aj's grey fart cloud

nothing is plausibly filling the ??????????????? there's skepticism/not being played for a sucker and then there's.... this. not buying it.

[Nero Cain]

yes, pocketing someone who's about to die

flawless scum strategy

yes, scum NEVER defend town for town cred.

[Aj The Epic]

You realize, Heartless, that I completely ignored it immediately because it could go EITHER WAY.

Your reasons suck. All there is to it. A.) I've told you my day 1s are bad. B.) have you not realized it's fucking obvious desp dies as one of the rogue leader people? Do you really think I'd go after him first? And the last thing I'm going to do is vanilla someone not in the rogue leader group as that shit is essentially clearing someone.

You're convinced Mastina's town and this is guiding your entire read.