Fire Emblem: Heroes of Mafia [Game Over]

[Cabd]

Votecount 1-30

ThinkBig (6): GuyInFreezer, Not Chara, Papa Zito, Desperado, Boonskiies, Superhans
Not Chara (3): , Vifam, PeregrineV, Vaxkiller
Vaxkiller (1): Aj The Epic
PeregrineV (1): Gammagoeey
Aj The Epic (3): Brian Skies, Dunnstral, Fro99er

With 15 players alive, it will take 8 votes to lynch/no lynch.
Not Voting (1): ThinkBig

Deadline for Day One is: (expired on 2017-02-24 18:53:43)

[Dunnstral]

I'd be ok with aj

Sneaking suspicion that tb is town but I wouldn't oppose his lynch

[Brian Skies]

I've only seen two mentions of Aj's slot in Chara's posting. The first was here where she said she thought our votes on the Malachite slot was weird. The second time was here where she indicated that she could see AJ as scum whiteknighting her.

AJ, on the other hand, has mentioned a strong townread or defended her on multiple occasions: 415, 427, 562, 584, 596, 601, 639, 641, 647, 849. 645 and 649 were deflections directly related to his townread on Chara. 708 was an attack on a player that voted Chara. 715 was a direct response to a question you posed to him about Chara. This means that 14/18 of his posts mentioned Chara or were related to his read on Chara in some way. None of his other posts indicate an interest in anything unrelated to her.

What about AJ's townread of Chara makes sense to you? Why do (did) you think there's a likely team between the two? And why does the bolded matter considering Chara has never stated a townread on AJ?

Lots of people who play mafia tend to townread people who "protect" them (see this site, for example). In 257, Chara, calls out the votes on the AJ slot. As one of the top items of interest when she replaced in. I can see AJtown seeing this as defending him, and thus make Chara a town read. I can see AJscum calling his scumbuddy or townChara a townread for doing it.

What is hard for me to see is why townChara makes many of the posts she did (682).

Why do I think they are a likely team? Because of Chara calling out the votes on AJ/Malachite. Why bother, unless she had a read on the slot?
And AJ does townread the slot for that. Which I think AJtown knows better.
And Chara suddenly says AJ could be scum(659), but is still voting ThinkBig (273).

And 841, where somehow their reads are matching up.

I find the entire bolded part a stretch. She called out two naked votes on a slot that barely managed to make an RVS vote, and failed at even doing that. She's right that the slot's behavior was mostly NAI. She also hasn't done much of anything with it other than pointing it out, so I don't know why you're so hung up on it.

Eh. 682 is okay.

If you think AJtown knows better, why not vote him?
Why does Chara have to vote AJ with an offhand remark when she's actually stated a scumread on the ThinkBig slot?

In 841, it's clear Chara made those reads first. So AJ could just be buddying up to her and her reads. Either way, if you think they could both be scum, why not vote AJ?

[Brian Skies]

I'm unopposed to the ThinkBig wagon, by the way. I just don't feel like it's more likely to flip in either direction. From what I've seen, the guy just seems busy and apparently celebrates every major holiday. Useless != scum. And just because he didn't self vote as town in the game he linked doesn't make him scum here. That's a fallacy and you guys were wagoning him right after he said he was going to celebrate his birthday (I'd be pretty irked too). Why someone needs 5 days to celebrate their birthday, though, is beyond me.

I just feel a lot more confident in an AJ lynch.

[Brian Skies]

Aj has also continued his pattern of attacking players who scumread him or scumread Chara. He has since added in mild setup speculation.

[Dunnstral]

I agree with 1103

[Vifam]

Me 2

[Vifam]

Except I think Chara is more likely to flip scum than anyone else atm

[Brian Skies]

Based on what?

[Aj The Epic]

Look at you all setting up lynches. It's so adorable. I wouldn't have to focus on defending Chara so much if you wouldn't insist they're scum. And saying "Aj is only focusing on those who vote Chara" is kinda disingenuous because that's at least half the fucking game at some point or another, considering people like Brian Skiies only states "Vote AJ" anymore.

[Vifam]

Based on what?

His overall play

[Aj The Epic]

Spoiler: A short list of a player being focused on one other player

I would lynch AJ before I would lynch Chara.

The reason I would vote AJ before Chara is because I can see AJ being scum whiteknighting Chara regardless of her alignment.

I would lynch AJ before I would lynch Chara.

Why's that? Like, what is the source of your townread on NotChara being stronger than your read on AJ?

My townread on Chara is not strong. I just think that if there's scum between the two, that it's possible that it's only AJ (or that AJ is not her partner). This is because AJ has spent most of his energy pushing suspicion on players voting his slot or chainsawing Chara.

The reason I would vote AJ before Chara is because I can see AJ being scum whiteknighting Chara regardless of her alignment.

why does that same logic not apply to NotChara?

257 came before 415

Because Chara's post is not a strong defense of the Malachite slot, and I don't believe it was ever intended to be. AJ, on the other hand, is clearly hard defending Chara.

VOTE: Aj The Epic

I thought ThinkBig was already hammered. Looks like the AJ wagon still has a chance.

If you think AJ is scum why can't we lynch Chara

What's your read on AJ?

Vote AJ pls. <33333

Aj has also continued his pattern of attacking players who scumread him or scumread Chara. He has since added in mild setup speculation.

[Brian Skies]

Look at you all setting up lynches. It's so adorable. I wouldn't have to focus on defending Chara so much if you wouldn't insist they're scum. And saying "Aj is only focusing on those who vote Chara" is kinda disingenuous because that's at least half the fucking game at some point or another, considering people like Brian Skiies only states "Vote AJ" anymore.

Well, I wouldn't be so focused on you if you learned a new trick. But since you apparently only know how to do three things, then yeah, you're scum.

The game is 40+ pages now. Surely you can do more than just attack people for their reads on you or Chara. I remember you entering the game with a comment about forced run-ups, but you never bothered to follow up on it. Did you even do it?

[Brian Skies]

Also, I have voted several different players, so your whole attack on me here is disingenuous at best.

[PeregrineV]

that game with the planets

Not sure what game is being referred to btw

Bunch of neighborhoods, we elected a boss each night, that was the only way we could use our powers.

I think I probably wasn't in a game like that

You were. We were. I'll dig for it later.

Are you talking about dragon age?

How is that "The game with the planets" man

Planets, nations, something where we all had neighborhoods.

[GuyInFreezer]

Useless != scum.

Good cos that's not why I'm voting him!

[Brian Skies]

Well, I was obviously not talking to you.

[GuyInFreezer]

OH MY GOD SOMEONE FIXED THE MAFBLACK SCUMDAY CAKE

I CAN DIE HAPPY NOW

[GuyInFreezer]

Well, I was obviously not talking to you.

One can never be so sure

[Papa Zito]

Am I gonna have to start throwing a hissy fit here or something.

[Brian Skies]

Probably.

[PeregrineV]

Are you asking why I'd rather lynch the otherwise unkillable roleblocker?

Except if scum can't kill him, they would be all over his lynch.

[Dunnstral]

I feel good about aj being scum looking at what Brian is saying and mentally comparing it to when I saw him as town

I don't put NC in that anywhere

[Gammagooey]

nah i got dis zito

VOTE: ThinkBig

frogfriend you're up

[Brian Skies]

Dammit Gamma. I got my hopes up.