Doing a reread of the thread.
Page 1:
I want to burn the shit out of Grey and Riley. For Grey,
12 was a scummy post. An unnecessary question IMO. Looks like overdone participation. For Riley Cake, I do not think that she needed to say what she said in
22 and
23 was a bad, stretchy, opportunistic vote on Hans.
Page 2:
I like LUV's engagement in
26 with Riley. I didn't find anything wrong with Hans' intro either. Nothing that blew my socks off, just a normal intro.
Riley's
33 isn't something I exactly buy. "Teasing" someone about a bad intro doesn't really add up.
Disagree with, but don't scumread Hans'
35.
36 was a decent post by Grey.
Like
38 quite a bit.
I don't like Riley's
45 which looks like brushing off decent points made against her.
47 reads like Riley Cake is upset that Superhans doesn't townread her. Town shouldn't care about self-perception. They should care about solving the game. Scum are the ones that don't wanna get caught, so they're much more aware of self perception.
Page 3: Liking Grey, and Hans for town. Their exchanges were pretty good.
Page 4:
77 is a bad question IMO. I really don't want you to be mafia this game Riley, but I'm really feeling it.
79 is something I disagree with, but it's a very towny observation so town points for Uzi again.
90 is bad.
Hans throughout this entire page looks fairly towny.
Page 5:
Agree heavily with Uzi Vert that Hans is probably town. I definitely see a thought process from Uzi Vert. However, this is multiball, so scum/wolves can genuinely scumhunt as they have another faction to deal with. But I like his progression independent of his alignment and I'm inclined to call him town.
108 basically explains the exact same thought I had in my mind about those exchanges.
The "beetlejuicing" so to speak from Spade_Ace looks pretty damning. Sometimes, that's just a coincidence though.
Riley's
122 was actually not too bad. Boosting that vote up earns her slight town points.
Page 6:
Spade_Ace seems to not really care that he's getting wagoned. Which is either really good scum acting or genuine town behavior.
Lucca's initial reads in his intro in
128 and
129 feel off and I want those better explained.
131 was weird with Superhans answering a question not aimed towards him. But the rest of his play looks towny. And very hard to fake.
133 is bad. I don't like the backpedaling when interrogated. Still uses "his gut" to paint him as scum. Bad bad bad.
139 is stretchy. Spade's reaction to being voted was fine IMO.
144 was a good post. Interested to see how lucca responds.
Contrary to how I was voting and what LQ said about Spade in
147, I think Spade is probably town here.
READS AT THIS POINT
{Hans}
{Uzi Vert}
{Grey, Spade}
{Fred, momo, Pim}
-GAP-
{lucca, Riley Cake}
