Large Normal 202 - Flavorful Mafia - Game Over!

[Firebringer]

Anyone who thinks scum would fake claim weak vigilante is kind of a idiot.

[aronagrundy]

VOTE: LQ
You are no longer town buddy.
There are two problems in that post you just made.
A. You're trying to push me as the SK or Newb!Scum. First off, my scumgame is decent mind you. Secondly, ONLY SCUM WANT TO PERSUE THIS AGENDA RIGHT NOW OF TRYING TO MAKE ME OUT TO BE THE SK OR SCUM
B. Even If I WAS the SK, the correct play here would be to buddy me and to let me kill atleast 1 scum before I die, not push me.
C. False Dichotomy. Why can't I be a real Weak Vigilante?

I feel like the logic behind A is kinda WIFOMy

[Alisae]

Oh yeah LQ you could even ask to leash me or bring it up.
But pushing my claim as fake is just scummy.

[Avagantimos]

Someone respond to 1249 please

Yes. Get pizza. I'll eat it with you and you can give me tips on how to shitpost so that town likes me more.

[Lil Uzi Vert]

Yeah you know what fuck that.
I claim Weak Vigilante.

Hey, this was our secret!

I also thought you softed being in a neighborhood with Fire too

omg kill me (not really plz)

VOTE: chickadee

Why do you keep avoiding my meta related questions?

I give up on catching up. I'm just going to read the 100+ pages y'all generate tonight after my job interview tomorrow.

I'm out for tonight.

UNVOTE:

You'll do great Chi, you got that offer for a reason!

[Lil Uzi Vert]

I didn't just vote Chickadee for the stupid vote though, I voted her because I thought her read on me was incoherent, her read on Fire seemed phony, and on looking back through her ISO she hasn't really done anything to make me say "Oh, that's town."

Why does her read on Fire seem fake?

[Alisae]

VOTE: LQ
You are no longer town buddy.
There are two problems in that post you just made.
A. You're trying to push me as the SK or Newb!Scum. First off, my scumgame is decent mind you. Secondly, ONLY SCUM WANT TO PERSUE THIS AGENDA RIGHT NOW OF TRYING TO MAKE ME OUT TO BE THE SK OR SCUM
B. Even If I WAS the SK, the correct play here would be to buddy me and to let me kill atleast 1 scum before I die, not push me.
C. False Dichotomy. Why can't I be a real Weak Vigilante?

I feel like the logic behind A is kinda WIFOMy

Nosferatu in NY198 tried to push me as the SK and I shot him the following night. He fliped scum.

[Transcend]

Anyone who thinks scum would fake claim weak vigilante is kind of a idiot.

2nd

LQ I know that Alisae was scummy and has a bizarre claim, but i know you respect me and I'm pretty sure Alisae is town here.

[aronagrundy]

I think it's fine that he's speculating about your alignment tbh. Like there's no way you're getting lynched today and you're easily confirmable. Like thinking about it another way, I don't see scum motivation in what he's doing

[aronagrundy]

Well fine as in not scum. I don't think it's a very productive conversation piece

[Eddie Cane]

I mean I speculate claims a lot as both alignments

my problem is weak vig is not a scum fake claim lol

[Lil Uzi Vert]

Scum will do anything that they think will get them town read so I can see where LQ is coming from. However, considering who we're dealing with and the way he claimed, Alisae is town.

[Alisae]

Grundy LQ could easily be scum trying to push me so he doesn't have to do anything else. Plus, where is there town motivation in trying to lynch a claimed vig?

[Transcend]

On the flip side i think LQ is town

I see no reason for him to question such a bizarre claim as scum.

Pedit: arona stop saying what i want to say

[aronagrundy]

never

[Firebringer]

Scum will do anything that they think will get them town read so I can see where LQ is coming from. However, considering who we're dealing with and the way he claimed, Alisae is town.

Yeah but theres no town or scum motivation to fake claim that you are a weak town vigilante at all.

If you want to fake claim vigilante there could be both scum and town motivation for doing so.
Scum could claim their shots are vigilante shots, this is high risk because if no other kills that makes them look suspicious.

If town claims it, and no shots they have to explain why theres no extra kills. Or retract.

A weak vigilante makes no sense as either alignment for a fake claim.
Because scum effectively aren't going to NK you as town, because if they shoot correctly they die anyways.
And if again they are the only ones doing kills its going to look suspicious.

[Transcend]

Pls

[Firebringer]

Alisae I disagree with you pretty heavily on LQ tbh.
I want to sheep you though, so I will follow but just saying, I really don' think he is scum:

VOTE: LQ

[Lil Uzi Vert]

Considering arona for today.

[aronagrundy]

Grundy LQ could easily be scum trying to push me so he doesn't have to do anything else. Plus, where is there town motivation in trying to lynch a claimed vig?

Different ways of looking at it I guess. LQ analyzes the shit out of anything anyway so it's part of what is motivating me to stick with him being town.

I do think there's a difference between discussion and trying to lynch you, though

[Transcend]

Considering arona for today.

Walk me through that

He's mirroring my thoughts and that's very hard to do as scum unless you're accountant

[Lil Uzi Vert]

Considering arona for today.

Walk me through that

He's mirroring my thoughts and that's very hard to do as scum unless you're accountant

Don't like how he's avoiding going in-depth talking about the meta he has on certain players or his push on Chi.

[LicketyQuickety]

VOTE: LQ
You are no longer town buddy.
There are two problems in that post you just made.
A. You're trying to push me as the SK or Newb!Scum. First off, my scumgame is decent mind you. Secondly, ONLY SCUM WANT TO PERSUE THIS AGENDA RIGHT NOW OF TRYING TO MAKE ME OUT TO BE THE SK OR SCUM
B. Even If I WAS the SK, the correct play here would be to buddy me and to let me kill atleast 1 scum before I die, not push me.
C. False Dichotomy. Why can't I be a real Weak Vigilante?

Good, this is what I live for (and what usually gets my lynched).

LOL, ok I am not Town:



Second of all, you should work on your math skills, they are rusty.



A. I have no idea how good you are as Mafia, because I have never seen you play as Mafia. And you are wrong. I am trying to sort your claim so it makes sense to me so I understand it so I can accept it. I can def see and angle where you are SK and can try a "Doc, protect me every night so that I can winzzzz." And I would question this claim whether I was Town or Scum. Read this game: viewtopic.php?f=2&t=70956 in it I argue that the person who CC's me is Scum, who wasn't because I was doing setup spec. I was lynched Day 1 and the guy who CCed me was Town as Well. So no, I would not just do this as Scum.

B. Don't argue what MY correct play to make is because you don't know what role I am. This is a weak argument anyways. I never buddy anyone even when I am Scum, so don't tell me I would buddy you if I was Town. I can't believe you just argued that I should buddy you if I am Town.

C. I have not said you claim was fake yet. I said I am trying to makes sense of it. If I can't understand it, it prolly comes from Scum, so that is what I am looking at. I made an argument how I don't understand how your role works. Yes I get a 1:1 trade is good, but I am still not convinced that this is what is going on.

[aronagrundy]

Honestly the reason for that is probably that meta is mostly just influencing my gut and vice versa, like I read someone's posts and they just feel the same as they did before and so I'm able to sort them

[aronagrundy]

that was to luv btw