Large Normal 205: Sibling's Love and Quarrel [Endgame]

[Nosferatu]

Let me lynch vedith, you'll have a wrong townread, and then I'll have a fair basis with which to denigrate your reads

[Nosferatu]

Kill two birds with one stone eh?

[Zachstralkita]

Let me lynch vedith, you'll have a wrong townread, and then I'll have a fair basis with which to denigrate your reads

This proposition would maybe appeal to me if Chickadee had a tangible reason for locking one scum in Vedith/Zach... I'd like to know what it is.


I think she just had the good old fashioned scumread on me. Cause I'm super.

[Zachstralkita]

I just don't get that.. is your stance that Vedith's play is unreadable or something? Cause I'm going to consider that ludicrous.

[Chickadee]

It's not going to make sense. It's mostly based in gut that one of my strongest town reads is scum. I've been sheeping my strongest town reads all game to mislynches. I had Trans in that list, but he's flipped town, so now I'm 99.9% sure either you or Vedith is scum.

And I feel like maybe would have killed me by now? Maybe.

[Creature]

No one wants to replace kraska?

[Chickadee]

No one wants to replace kraska?

Do you blame them?

Look at this game.

[Nosferatu]

Let me lynch vedith, you'll have a wrong townread, and then I'll have a fair basis with which to denigrate your reads

This proposition would maybe appeal to me if Chickadee had a tangible reason for locking one scum in Vedith/Zach... I'd like to know what it is.
I think she just had the good old fashioned scumread on me. Cause I'm super.

I don't see how chick thinking one of zach or vedith is scum has any relation to your townread on Vedith being wrong but w/e

I just don't get that.. is your stance that Vedith's play is unreadable or something? Cause I'm going to consider that ludicrous.

I'm not saying it's unreadable, I'm sure someone out there can find a method to the madness, but I cannot identify his alignment simply based on what he's done this game or pretty much any game for that matter, and I'd like to know what actions he's taken that allow for you to do so.

[Zachstralkita]

It's not going to make sense. It's mostly based in gut that one of my strongest town reads is scum. I've been sheeping my strongest town reads all game to mislynches. I had Trans in that list, but he's flipped town, so now I'm 99.9% sure either you or Vedith is scum.

And I feel like maybe would have killed me by now? Maybe.

Oh. Is that all you meant?

There's not a name for this but it should be some sort of fallacy one because the only basis for it is paranoia. And if I'm one of your "strongest town reads" then you must have only sheeped me on JJH cause.. I was on Narna and LQ was a heavy tr of mine but I'm pretty sure he got ran up and I was gone when it happened.

Trans was obvious town for a good chunk of this game.


Having scum in (Zach/Vedith) only makes sense with this logic train that you're using though and nothing else.


The thing is it's desperate. Say you lynch me then I green. Then because one of VedithZach had to be scum, you lynch Vedith and he greens. What happens the next day? Oh no next day because endgame.


Cause you think it's a good idea to put stock in gut this late. js. You just said your read to me is gut so not play based? Then you said you read my posts 2nd most? Am I just entertainment value? LMAOO

[Nosferatu]

No one wants to replace kraska?

replacing into a game where town is already d5 with only a traitor flip is a fool's errand. You'd have to have a crazy messiah complex or be already following this game to actually replace in.

[Zachstralkita]

No one wants to replace kraska?

replacing into a game where town is already d5 with only a traitor flip is a fool's errand. You'd have to have a crazy messiah complex or be already following this game to actually replace in.

after kraska replaced out creature was like yea I'm gonna give her 24 hours to make a case for her being town before I vote there

like she didn't replace out or something.. i just don't see what purpose it served when he can be actually using his vote.. idk I feel like you knew this already tho




How much mislynches do we have? Two?




Okay well town makes a choice cause this is stupid beyond belief. You either lynch k77 today(I'm not counting on a replacement to do anything with this) and sheep me tomorrow OR you sheep me right now and we don't lynch kraska's slot beyond this point. That's my ultimatum.

I've been saying sheep mee....eeeeeeeeeee.eeeeeeeeeeee eeeeeeeeee


Nos is obvscum for trying to mislynch the role cop LOL without addressing his claim? Unless I never saw the case.

*insert Steel is scum here*

And I don't want to hear the "scum wouldn't do " arguments this game is complete fuckery.

Amended as of right now.

Let me lynch vedith, you'll have a wrong townread, and then I'll have a fair basis with which to denigrate your reads

This proposition would maybe appeal to me if Chickadee had a tangible reason for locking one scum in Vedith/Zach... I'd like to know what it is.
I think she just had the good old fashioned scumread on me. Cause I'm super.

I don't see how chick thinking one of zach or vedith is scum has any relation to your townread on Vedith being wrong but w/e

I deadass thought it was more than a gut read..

I'm not saying it's unreadable, I'm sure someone out there can find a method to the madness, but I cannot identify his alignment simply based on what he's done this game or pretty much any game for that matter, and I'd like to know what actions he's taken that allow for you to do so.

I guess I should have said it overtly. I am the method. I like to think I can read town!Vedith

[Creature]

So is kraska gonna be modkilled?

[Nosferatu]

I'm not saying it's unreadable, I'm sure someone out there can find a method to the madness, but I cannot identify his alignment simply based on what he's done this game or pretty much any game for that matter, and I'd like to know what actions he's taken that allow for you to do so.

I guess I should have said it overtly. I am the method. I like to think I can read town!Vedith

So is your townread on vedith gut then?

[Nosferatu]

So is kraska gonna be modkilled?

I doubt it

[MariaR]

VOTE: nos

Stop voting those

[Mulch]

Unnoficial VOTE COUNT 5 . 63

• Kraska77
  --- 4 ( Mulch, Carcalilly, Creature, Nosferatu )
  L- 2
  
  
  Vedith
  ----- 2 ( Chickadee, Kraska77 )
  L- 4
  
  
  Nosferatu
  -- 3 ( Zachstralkita, Steel, MariaR )
  L- 3
  
  
  Steel
  ------ 1 ( MariaR )
  L- 5
  
  
  Zachstralkita
  -- 1 ( Chicadee )
  L- 5
  
  
  
  
  Not Voting
  - 1 ( Vedith )

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to Lynch
Deadline is in (expired on 2017-08-15 17:30:00)

[Nosferatu]

you know, I would totally accept scum!mulch busing this hard tbh

[Siblings Quarrel]

VOTE COUNT 5 . 63

• Kraska77
  ------ 4 ( Mulch, Carcalilly, Creature, Nosferatu )
  L- 2
  
  
  Nosferatu
  ----- 3 ( Zachstralkita, Steel, MariaR )
  L- 3
  
  
  Vedith
  -------- 1 ( Kraska77 )
  L- 5
  
  
  Zachstralkita
  - 1 ( Chickadee )
  L- 5
  
  
  
  
  
  Not Voting
  ---- 1 ( Vedith )

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to Lynch
Deadline is in (expired on 2017-08-15 17:30:00)

[Zachstralkita]

I'm not saying it's unreadable, I'm sure someone out there can find a method to the madness, but I cannot identify his alignment simply based on what he's done this game or pretty much any game for that matter, and I'd like to know what actions he's taken that allow for you to do so.

I guess I should have said it overtly. I am the method. I like to think I can read town!Vedith

So is your townread on vedith gut then?

no

[Nosferatu]

so wtf is the holdup on why you think he's town

[Zachstralkita]

literally most of his play in this game. Most of the scenarios that make him "scummy" to you indicate otherwise to me

[Zachstralkita]

Or you said that you couldn't get a read off of his actions or something?


did u say that...

[Nosferatu]

literally most of his play in this game. Most of the scenarios that make him "scummy" to you indicate otherwise to me

i need details bud

[Vedith]

Spends the last 2 days pushing scum - Gets called a shit poster.

[Zachstralkita]

literally most of his play in this game. Most of the scenarios that make him "scummy" to you indicate otherwise to me

i need details bud

uhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Your setup spec is bullshit cause it doesn't factor in any of the context surrounding Vedith's claim or his play or his stances

context like what?

the kraska debacle?
the transcend issue?

the distinctly NAI play from vedith he displays literally every game?

his multitude of stances on Steel and Kraska being scum? The one he's sat on for like ever?

These things mean something and I read all of that and got Vedith!town and are definitely usable except striked is not true.


Or we disagree. let's say it's that. the last one is not really noncommital though. but I have no clue why he's sitting at unvote

Spends the last 2 days pushing scum - Gets called a shit poster.

We're talking about your whole play style there's definitely shitposting included