Large Normal 208 - Fireworks Festival [End]

[pienyan]

votecount 3.5

Whiskers (3) - I Am Innocent, Viomi, Rhah
Lucky2u (3) - gerryoat, MathBlade, TwoInAMillion
gerryoat (3) - AxleGreaser, Nero Cain, Nauci

MathBlade (2) - Lucky2u, Whiskers

Not voting (2) - Shiro, beeboy

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Deadline is November 9, 21:10 GMT-7 or in (expired on 2017-11-09 21:10:00).

Viomi is V/LA indefinitely.

[pienyan]

Smocaine replaces gerryoat!

[Whiskers]

It's mafia's job to lynch town not town's job to lynch town. Who here would wagon Nauci btw?

maybe, but I think it's important to step on Math's balls until he makes a case.
same goes for Shiro, who is 100% active lurking.

same goes for beeboy.
Where is beeboy?

although I guess he

actually

has a V/LA.

@Bee: where do you stand on Mathblade, Nauci, and Whiskers?

[preedit]
I'll just go ahead and wait for mod to post votecount...

[Nero Cain]

All I know is I really appreciate the amount of effort axle goes through

and leaned town on

k y?

[AxleGreaser]

@Axel
I think the point is that Gerry was being a shitty player, and he is a

shitty player as town

: therefore, it's

not-telling

here.

As I had to read both this game and skim a slab of Large normal 206 in order to make this read.

Q

Is Gerry expected to tunnel Nero like a trojan again or is there some contextual difference?

A

No. This game is different. (see spoiler below)

Q

Is gerry just always a

shitty player as town

or is it a choice? See 3891 For quotes from kidney mafia.

A

Which fairly robustly shows that Gerry chose to play the way he did in this game. Then he chose not to tell us the reason for that and instead replace out.

Spoiler: where that skim of Large normal 206 happened

if you have a rational factual basis for it i am all ears.

but other than possible salt from (large normal 206)
world record mafia 1 2 3 (+quite bit more)

I dont understand your claims about meta at all.
and frankly Gerry being drunk with powa on having hammered scum
viewtopic.php?p=9570754#p9570754
after earlier being at L-2
viewtopic.php?p=9558730#p9558730
that game makes fair bit of sense.

expecting in anyway that that is the meta you expect here is weird.

and bad.

So ta but I will be the judge of what i find

not-telling

.

We'll reread his slot by his replacement, when it comes in. For now, maybe you should vote the person you think Gerry was bussing?

and while you wanting to be voted is cute? and a bit weird...

What i actually said 3922 was.

Felt just as plausible as a weak assed bus vote.

OR

as a lynch one more towny he wont be held accountable for vote.

So no my read on Gerry is independent of whether it was him bussing whiskers or him trying to hitch another consequence free ride on town lynch. just like he had been doing all game.
If my suspicion of him depended on you flipping scum and that being bussing then of course you would have to flip first. But it doesn't.

and now, as per 3922, Id like to know how that looks >obv town< to IaI

[Nauci]

I've leaned scum on Gerry and leaned town on him and I don't really know either way because it seems like this shit posting is just his style.

But I'm okay with lynching it because I thought Axles case was pretty good.

I think Nero is town for how hard he's working to build cases and push people when so many of us have gone apathetic af

I'm not sure if I am ready to give iai the same check though

Oh right this is what I kept forgetting

VOTE: gerryoat

Thanks for the scum claim.

Note how he lurks during the height of the whisker wagon, one who he has “leaned scum” and “leaned town” on only to pop in when the Gerry wagon got going. Gerry who he has also leaned scum and leaned town on.

Whiskers and nauci are so obv scummates

Gerry is obv town

Math and unlucky are both possibly town too.

Town please start voting better

Will you scum or town read him when I flip town?

[Nauci]

Nope. Rolefishing is rolefishing.

Is it rolefishing when he's hard claimed masons and we're asking for a counterclaim?

[TwoInAMillion]

Nope. Rolefishing is rolefishing.

Is it rolefishing when he's hard claimed masons and we're asking for a counterclaim?

Yep.

[Nero Cain]

they are

probably

just neighbors doing a stupid mason gambit but the whole "they are scum together" is a slight possibility. Though Rhah claiming mason so Cabd wouldn't shoot TIAM is risky so like 3/4ths of me leans no.


but I mean, seriously? This whole "I'm not gonna full claim" doesn't seem like its doing anything good.

[Smocaine]

Someone hit me with why Lucky isn't the best lynch of all time, right now.

[Nero Cain]

he's town.

[Nero Cain]

And if you thought he was the best lynch why are you not voting there?

[TwoInAMillion]

he is, as long as gerry's vote carries over.

[Smocaine]

I haven't read anything, so I trust Gerry's read for now.

[Nero Cain]

Well I don't

[TwoInAMillion]

All you need to know is that the scum team is Lucky, Viami, Nauci, and Nero. Maybe one other person. We lynch those guys in that order and we have a town win.

[Nero Cain]

that list is beyond stupid but it's not like I'd expect anything less from you.

[TwoInAMillion]

I love you too.

[TwoInAMillion]

Apparently I don't have the street cred that some players have so people are going to try to use that to scum's advantage to avoid the correct lynch. But don't fall for it.

[Smocaine]

gerryoat, MathBlade, and TwoInAMillion need to view Gerry's actions through the lens that he is town. I'm sure they'll connect the dots.

[MathBlade]

gerryoat, MathBlade, and TwoInAMillion need to view Gerry's actions through the lens that he is town. I'm sure they'll connect the dots.

I'm more concerned that you said yourself need to look at your own actions like you're town. Like you replaced gerryoat.

So then why would you need a different lens?

VOTE: gerryoat

(I still think lucky is scum btw as well just this needs pursuing)

[MathBlade]

VOTE: Smocaine

For emphasis

[Whiskers]

What i actually said 3922 was.

Felt just as plausible as a weak assed bus vote.

OR

as a lynch one more towny he wont be held accountable for vote.

So no my read on Gerry is independent of whether it was him bussing whiskers or him trying to hitch another consequence free ride on town lynch. just like he had been doing all game.
If my suspicion of him depended on you flipping scum and that being bussing then of course you would have to flip first. But it doesn't.

and now, as per 3922, Id like to know how that looks >obv town< to IaI

Yeah, but the reason you even scumread him was because he sheeped your vote onto

me.

Do you no longer scumread me? If that's the case, why? And if you

do

still scumread me, why is Gerry more likely scum? Why would you attack him for allegedly playing to his town meta, then replacing out?

Your read of him doesn't depend on me being scum, but you've never stopped scumreading me. There's no reason for you not to use his "consequence free ride" motivation to lynch me, your scumread.

I think your viewpoint is all fucked up:
So far from what you've said, you must think Gerry and I are scum, and he's bussing me? But like, if that were the case, you'd be just as happy to vote/lynch me today (or yesterday, when this started), and then use my scumflip to incriminate Gerry, right?

[Smocaine]

Alisae page one looks unnatural.

[Whiskers]

I haven't read anything, so I trust Gerry's read for now.

Gerry was lurking hella hard, he posted once in a blue moon with a one-line post, and never anything of content.
He did not give a shit about this game.

Lucky isn't scum because he came in and made a big catchup-post case. He's been largely active within the thread since then.

That doesn't make him not-scum, but it puts him in a slightly more pro-town position than your slot.

Does that adequately inform you?