Large Normal 208 - Fireworks Festival [End]

[TwoInAMillion]

Grasping at straws much?

[Nero Cain]

how is that grasping at straws?

[TwoInAMillion]

Because there is nothing to think that I am helping scum, aside from you disagreeing with me because I am scum reading you.

[Transcend]

Holy

[Transcend]

Alright

[Transcend]

Time to die

[Transcend]

VOTE: Nauci

[I Am Innocent]

votecount 3.17

MathBlade (4) - Lucky2u, Smocaine, Viomi, Transcend

Viomi (3) - Whiskers, MathBlade, TwoInAMillion
Whiskers (2) - I Am Innocent, Rhah
Nauci (2) - Flairs, Nero Cain
Smocaine (1) - AxleGreaser
Flairs (1) - Nauci

Not voting (0) -

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Deadline is November 9, 21:10 GMT-7 or in (expired on 2017-11-09 21:10:00).

Viomi is V/LA indefinitely.

VOTE: Nauci

I didn't realize we were so close to deadline. I'm still back about 15 pages, but for sake of keeping this going, I'm going to change my vote to consolidate to another of my Top 3:

unvote whiskers
vote nauci

Will catch up now, but doubt much is going to change from me suspecting whiskers/nauci/beeboy

[AxleGreaser]

Seeking clarity (lots of it)

@ #4470 I thought Viomi was asking what Nero's scum reads were, not necessarily considering them?

#4470 << is a mathbalde post.

#4480 Is a Whiskers post talking about what I(Axle) found in viomi posts. If that is what you are referring too?

Then yes i left out what was so obvious to me, which was not only did Viomi ask Nero

[..nero post..]Fine.

Which do you(nero) think is more likely to be scum, Whiskers, Nauci, or Transcend?

but Viomi then acted on it

VOTE: Whiskers

with almost no extra thought.

The number mess up is nothing (stuff happens)

Were you unaware Viomi had then followed up of nero read recommendation and acted on it?
Thus not only necessarily considered them but sheeped them.

[Transcend]

Nauci

[I Am Innocent]

there's people i can only read by engaging with them on a personal level

THAT SHOULD BE LITERALLY EVERYBODY.

THIS ISN'T EPICMAFIA
THERE ISN'T A DISGUISER ROLE

YOU SHOULDN'T BE READING PEOPLE BASED ON META.

You should be reading them by engaging with them on a personal level, then considering whether their behaviour is suspicious and indicative of their alignment. Not "hey gee is this Mathblade? Hmm, yep, yep, looks like it's really Mathblade."
ya fuckin slur.

This is a crap post.

[AxleGreaser]

Same question to Axle, while I would actually support that wagon, it does not look likely

It does not look likely to me either. It is however my clear preference.
My earlier lynch order preference is still in play or I would have told you. AKA batter number 2 is Whiskers.

Viomi vs Math, is till pending.

[I Am Innocent]

I think the instinct is for guys to be easier on girls, not that they have different tells. A lot of people believe that girls are more intuitive and empathetic, and thus maybe better at reading people, so maybe they might have more value. Also the male/female online ratio probably magnifies this. But logically I think a lot of this is a fallacy more than helpful in winning games.

If I were to throw my hat in, I'd say it's more about aggression. For example,

Wait Transcend that wasn't sarcasm? I thought you were just making fun of me for correcting you.

Are you saying that men usually are more gung ho and women less confident?

There's actually a lot of studies about how women use less gung ho language: instead of statements women are more likely to say "I think" or "I feel" or "in my opinion" type stuff. Not that I'm using this as a case for my innocence or anything.

this more feminine phrasing could be considered scummy, a player not willing to commit to their opinion.

Trust me the internet trend is *not* to be nicer to women.

well, "nicer" isn't exactly right...

I was talking about mafiascum, not the internet in general. I would like to think that mafiascum is better behaved than the internet at large.

o ___o

If it were "better behaved" then it probably wouldn't be "nicer" to one gender over another.

That's kind of wholly sexist.

More crappy posting.

[Nero Cain]

vote Nauci, Axe.

[I Am Innocent]

One of Transcend/Flairs is mafia maybe.

Flairs is beeboy right? Not sure what to make of this cross voting thing by him and Nauci at this point.

[Transcend]

vote Nauci, Axe.

[MathBlade]

Work til late project dump sorry everyone.

[I Am Innocent]

What we could do is test the theory and flip Whiskers. That sounds really good. Remember Alisae locked horns with Whiskers. Could sort both of them. Either that or lynch outside of Math Whiskers and inside of Transcend Flairs Nauci.

Both are good ideas.

[I Am Innocent]

Ok rhah let's play ball

I'm not overly confident that math is scum. That's my lean right now.

We can spare them today but also spare smocaine because the build up of that lynch doesn't sit well with me and axle and nero are town imo.

I'm good with lynching Nauci or even whiskers

Pedit yee

Town^

[AxleGreaser]

vote Nauci, Axe.

I have not gone back and considered it in detail all at once. But while there are questions,
I am pretty sure I don't think Nauci is more likely to flip scum than whiskers my second preference.

so no.

[Rhah]

The Mathblade wagon is not town driven

[Nero Cain]

Math do you realize how annoying/paranoia-inducing it is when you prod dodge/apologize for not posting after a matter of mere hours?

[Nero Cain]

I think derp Math is plenty capable of being scum.

[I Am Innocent]

Town block, imo: Rhah, TIAM, Axle, Nero, Whiskers (yeah I know this one's gonna be hella controversial).

So Whiskers use to be in your top 5 scummiest players, when and why did that change?

[Nero Cain]

though Math is derp as both alignments so...other than Smocaine the Math wagon seems mostly town.