Team Mafia 2018: Mafiosi Revolution (Over)

[Ginngie]

Gork is good at mafia so

[Ginngie]

Also I think I'm starting to lean fire scum

[Ginngie]

Flash wagon on kagami sounds fun but I’ll pass

Feels hella uncharacteristic regarding Fire and his very being

[Cheetory6]

I'm bad at mafia but I'm one step ahead of you c:

[implosion]

When Mulch is gone I will take his place.

this post would be better if it had been written in iambic pentameter.

I lean more strongly toward Kmd-town right now. Will justify/respond to Patrick tonight.

Would like to see Transcend link a Mulch game where he does something like this as promised.

[Patrick]

I read the post where you voted him. Doesn't mean it makes sense: if you think Transcend is scum, pushing the guy he's voting seems unnatural to me unless you also have a strong scum read on them, which is not what I'm getting from your posts.

It also felt like you were trying to get a rise out of Mulch rather than calm him down

[Patrick]

and Mulch having the tendency to not actually vote his top scum reads, it's pretty much useless.

Mulch is voting for Transcend.

[Patrick]

Would like to see Transcend link a Mulch game where he does something like this as promised.

FWIW, I skimmed the game cabd linked to earlier and it looked like Mulch was doing something similar in that one. Not especially keen on reading a bunch of other games as I'm quite prepared to believe he's done it as both alignments.

I think my read on Kmd might have been wrong. Would much rather

Vote: Ginngie

[Ginngie]

the vote wont last long trust me

He's also one of the biggest advocates of his own lynch


Actually it's kinda interesting that he's never voted himself lmao

[Cheetory6]

I'd like to think if I were scum I wouldn't even give people the opportunity to view me as "underwhelming"

I would be pushing at least something hard and asking more questions to make myself look more productive

Okay gonna rewrite response to this that I already wrote at work :')

So, I guess my biggest issue here is that I feel like you're underthinking or understating how you could approach the game here. You've stated that you're overly busy right now, do you not feel like that would affect how present you would be in the game as scum?

There's also that this game has a lot of players that are familiar with you/your scumgame. It kind of strikes me as generally probable that you could intentionally play underwhelming during the earlygame when there's such a big presence in the game and then ramp up to a strong lategame once you've cleared out some of the bigger threats.

I guess I'm just curious at this point more than anything?

To me it reads like you're showing off how critically you're thinking about the game and addressing the fact that you disagree with a teammate in a way similar to hydra dissonance coming from scum

It's an awkward post for sure, I'm just not entirely sure that townKMD doesn't make awkward posts sometimes?

In my head I have this image of scumKMD from previous experiences and he doesn't feel as wooden here as what I'm expecting from scumHim.
Does it potentially strike you as plausible that townHim overshares things to try to be transparent?

this post would be better if it had been written in iambic pentameter.

Maybe next time.

[Cabd]

Would like to see Transcend link a Mulch game where he does something like this as promised.

FWIW, I skimmed the game cabd linked to earlier and it looked like Mulch was doing something similar in that one.

Did you have any other thoughts about it?

[Cheetory6]

Cabd if you have time can you do an ISOdive on Firebringer and give some more detailed thoughts on him?

[Patrick]

Not really. It gave me the impression he gets extremely riled up as town and is good at replicating it when scum. Replicating not quite the right word, I think he does get riled up as scum, but is good at using it.

What difference am I missing?

[Kmd4390]

Cheet what do you mean by wooden?

[Chara]

the game i referenced with scum Mulch had a blowup like this. and it's NAI. my last game with town Mulch also had some issues that lead to multiple replace-outs. Transcend trying to pretend this is scummy is bad.
and Mulch, he isn't purposely trying to set you off. take a break from the thread for a while, you won't be mislynched.

[Chara]

by the way, i'll be busy tonight, but i'll check in if anyone wants my opinion on something specific. if not, see you all tomorrow.

[Cheetory6]

Kind of emotionless/without a genuine drive.

Transcend trying to pretend this is scummy is bad.

I feel like townTranscend can say this too though, in that he would generally be more concerned with just trying to get someone he thinks is scum lynched, even if he's not really thinking/fact checking himself.

[Patrick]

Cheet, CDB would like to know what you meant by your 1096, with permission to explain as if we're 5 year olds asking.

[Chara]

Cheet: i know town Transcend can behave that way, but it seems to be that he's doing a lot of thinking here. it doesn't look like a thoughtless tunnel.

[Cheetory6]

When Mulch is gone I will take his place.

The joke is that I was saying that when Mulch is dead, I would start posting 10 times per minute and fight with Transcend.

Cheet: i know town Transcend can behave that way, but it seems to be that he's doing a lot of thinking here. it doesn't look like a thoughtless tunnel.

I think the execution of the tunnel is going to be sloppy, even if at one point Transcend was pushing it on genuinely thought out reasoning.
I would probably be more concerned if Transcend wasn't playing sloppy in the push at this point?

[Chara]

do you think he's playing sloppily right now? granted i am not really caught up, but that isn't how it looked.

[Cheetory6]

At the very least the push got a lot lazier?

[Aristophanes]

Aristophanes hates playing scum and there are lots of people here who can confidently read him. It's possible he took scum. It's also possible that he might be punching himself in the face right now. I don't really think he'd do either to himself here.

So you're also saying people can confidently read him?
Are you one of those people?
I assume it has to be based on tone alone, simply because he has done very little in the terms of scumhunting.
Not judging the player - yet again, only respect for my "elders" - but what is his value to town if he doesn't scumhunt or post much, and is only obv.town to those who are part of a circle who can toneread him confidently based on something like 6 posts?

Genuinely, honestly interested.

Cheet has known me since forever. He can probably read me best of anyone! Also, yeah, I'm never choosing a scum role for team mafia. I also don't intend to punch myself in the face

Also, did you just call me old? XD

Also also, I have read up to page 10 (the mulch and fb show) and a few recent pages. I am not lurking, just catching up!

[Aristophanes]

Oh god 45 now...

[Patrick]

That's pretty comfortably middle aged.