Well, yes and no. George is also one of the "not technically confirmed" players. Do I think you're scum here? No. God no. But it just *is* in extra shot that we're needlessly throwing out.
I will straight up disregard all reason if you have a PR dream again. You can come back and be like, “I dreamt that Locke is a N2 Bulletproof Multitasking Cop and Self-Targeting Doctor,” and I will go, “Okay, Locke kill it is then.”
If george is NK: 4v1-
Madoka:
Madoka reports check, clears one suspect
Madoka reports check, finds red on a player-> auto win
Madoka reports no check (rb), monkey is most likely confirmed via set up spec.
Monkey:
Monkey reports check, clears one suspect
Monkey reports check, finds PT access -> autowin
Monkey reports rb, madoka is most likely confirmed via set up.
Now the reason why we lynch here is that if one of the invest roles dies, the following setup is here:
2 confirmed townies: Datisi and George
1 claim PR role: Madoka/Monkey.
2 suspects: 2 of me/shiki/Luca.
Multitasking rb does not matter as they have to burn the rn on george to kill one of the invest roles. The remaining invest should have a check on one of those two people. Meaning that we auto win
We basically should win unless scum has some why to throw off town, or town has some false positives in the pool secretly like Miller's (but since from what I read Miller's must know they are millers in a normal set up, I doubt that is the case.)
there is literally zero possible way in a Normal game that any scum would appear innocent to a PT cop (unless traitor, but there cannot be a traitor in a 9p) or to a Neapolitan
I will straight up disregard all reason if you have a PR dream again. You can come back and be like, “I dreamt that Locke is a N2 Bulletproof Multitasking Cop and Self-Targeting Doctor,” and I will go, “Okay, Locke kill it is then.”
In post 1032, Datisi wrote:there is literally zero possible way in a Normal game that any scum would appear innocent to a PT cop (unless traitor, but there cannot be a traitor in a 9p) or to a Neapolitan
I was talking about town having false positives like a Miller. Not scum having ways to hide alignment
Ah sorry i can't read. I'm the "Miller". I report positive to both. But ye players cannot have roles hidden from them so yes.
I will straight up disregard all reason if you have a PR dream again. You can come back and be like, “I dreamt that Locke is a N2 Bulletproof Multitasking Cop and Self-Targeting Doctor,” and I will go, “Okay, Locke kill it is then.”
In post 578, humaneatingmonkey wrote:also, you've called him null/town all game but you were willing to hammer 3 hours before deadline? if bugs is town, you're definitely scum.
Posts like this, I thought were probably beyond his scum range. But now it’s pretty clear he’s scum all things considered.
i think monkey is just applying his own logic to hiraki here, which is the same thing he was doing with madoka when talking about if madoka were fake claiming.
In post 1007, humaneatingmonkey wrote:if i'm scum, i'm doing a bad job making things easy for myself. i killed Hiraki, the person whose most vocally suspicious of me — who some people already read to be scum. i claim an investigative role, when i already have the information that there's another one.
there is a user on this site named flavor leaf who is frequently saying things like if 'i were scum here, i would not have killed hiraki because he was pushing george and monkey'. the obligatory response to this from at least one player is 'wifom'.
monkey is suggesting we lynch me and investigate holden instead of lynching holden and investigating me seemingly because he wants me to die before he loses, the same reason i think he killed hiraki. for some players this game is filled with little victories instead of focusing on winning as a team.
Sadly I'm under a eldritch blood pinkie pact that prevents me from explictly agreeing with scum!monkey reads.
Whoever we lynch here doesn't matter. I push me simply because I already forsee a similar situation to newbie 1944 (into the jungle something one) where I as town was kept alive until the end due in part of the threads scum read on me despite multiple townies changing their minds.
We do not progress any further until we see what happens doing the actions of night 2 and flips/results day 3
In post 1038, Luca Blight wrote:Shiki, do you think we should play it safe (Datisi’s strategy) or go for the perfect win?
i am okay with either. to me right now monkey is the most likely scum, holden is a rather distant second, and madoka is the horse in the race who is currently eating hay in the stable. with either plan, there are no outs for holden or monkey. any wariness i have towards datisi's plan is due to my unsuredness with regards to madoka. this isn't to say what datisi and madoka both have said doesn't make sense to me, however, so i'm good to go with it. from my perspective lynch holden check luca is auto but everyone would have to accept town me for this to work.
each time you question datisi's plans i try to figure out if it is you as scum trying to get around ever being investigated. i think it is not because the bus from the beginning of the game strategy would imply it was rather thought through and agreeing to the first plan and finding the holes for yourself (since for it to work we must agree you are town) would be a more reliable way for scum you to go about doing this.
now you might ask, hasn't holden been awfully towny today? well yes, but his only out since the claims has been to play possum and hope town skips the step of actually lynching or checking him.
In post 1038, Luca Blight wrote:Shiki, do you think we should play it safe (Datisi’s strategy) or go for the perfect win?
i'm sorry for trying ok
I will straight up disregard all reason if you have a PR dream again. You can come back and be like, “I dreamt that Locke is a N2 Bulletproof Multitasking Cop and Self-Targeting Doctor,” and I will go, “Okay, Locke kill it is then.”
We go with what we been discussing. It's not much of a swag victory tbh, and the only way scum gets a major out is if we lynch monkey and he flips town.
Madoka will check Shiki, Monkey will check Luca, I get lynched. No need to trust anyone besides george (who would be dead) and Datisi who is clear by set up pretty much. Aka, out of the four remaining players, two should be cleared either automatically or through reasonable deduction
actually yeah that seems like a better plan. George on Madoka. Madoka -> shiki, Monkey -> Luca.
alternatively swapping holden and shiki around would *in theory* give same results. though i'm saying this more out of an interest to see a shiki scumcase from monkey.
I will straight up disregard all reason if you have a PR dream again. You can come back and be like, “I dreamt that Locke is a N2 Bulletproof Multitasking Cop and Self-Targeting Doctor,” and I will go, “Okay, Locke kill it is then.”
In theory yes, in practice it gives scum an easier ML if they have some way to divert the invest checks.
Shiki summed it up best that my slot has a lot or WIFOM around it (asking to be lynched, the town case on bugs, etc). If the rest of yall wants to switch out me with somebody fine I guess, but I think by removing me it forces scum in that situation to reach more in scum reading the other person.
I guess if madoka or monkey is scum, they always can fake claim a red check as the cornerstone of their case though lylo
In post 919, shiki wrote:who can die in the night that makes madoka checking me and monkey checking luca or vice versa not auto?
In post 1043, HoldenGolden wrote:Madoka will check Shiki, Monkey will check Luca, I get lynched. No need to trust anyone besides george (who would be dead) and Datisi who is clear by set up pretty much. Aka, out of the four remaining players, two should be cleared either automatically or through reasonable deduction
actually yeah that seems like a better plan. George on Madoka. Madoka -> shiki, Monkey -> Luca.
alternatively swapping holden and shiki around would *in theory* give same results. though i'm saying this more out of an interest to see a shiki scumcase from monkey.
it's just that i'm trying to think through all the possible d3 scenarios, in case i die, and that includes No Result claims.
like, if Madoka were to die and Monkey claims No Result. that would mean that either george is a multitasking roleblocker, or luca is an ascetic mutitasking roleblocker. which i am aware both sound highkey batshit insane.
i'm just afraid of losing this game after doing so well day 1.
I will straight up disregard all reason if you have a PR dream again. You can come back and be like, “I dreamt that Locke is a N2 Bulletproof Multitasking Cop and Self-Targeting Doctor,” and I will go, “Okay, Locke kill it is then.”
In post 1048, Datisi wrote:like, if Madoka were to die and Monkey claims No Result. that would mean that either george is a multitasking roleblocker, or luca is an ascetic mutitasking roleblocker. which i am aware both sound highkey batshit insane.
