Open 595: Elemental Mafia (Town Wins!)

[BlueBloodedToffee]

OK.

So you can see the difference now, yeah?

[ConManMick]

Between you picking a player who survived and saying that that equates to you being town, and me doing the same thing?
Hmmm...
Well mine wasn't a legitimate provision of reasoning. Is that the difference?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Between me showing why I thought he was a PR and him still being alive

and

you not being able to do the same.

[TheReverend]

God conman just give toffee town cred for killing scum instead of a PR suspect, stop being difficult.

[ConManMick]

Ah yes. Farside, mention some condiments please.

I'm happy to say he's town. I haven't thought he was scum. I just think this is a less than solid point to base a town read on.
Let's do something productive. You said Farside or FA for scum. What's scummy and why?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Thanks Rev.

PEdit - I have presented both my cases for FA and Farside.

In fact, I have only just posted my thoughts on FA.

I have also only just requoted all my reasoning for Farside scum after someone requested it.

[farside22]

My kingdom for Dave to get him butt I here.
At least he'd may get what Im putting done.

[lane0168]

I'm with rev. Half the night kills would be nice.

VOTE: bbt

[lane0168]

I thought conman was scum. I'm stubborn that way.
Next.

And RMM? You tried super hard to avoid that Papi wagon.

Lane, why would Scum!Senator sit on a pointless wagon when his buddy is being ran up?

PEdit - I'm not SK. I would have killed you (Can say it's WIFOM, idc. I would have)

I could maybe, at a push see Senator (based on his play, not his voting)

I really do think Farside has the best chance of flipping scum.

Because people like you will think it's not scummt

[BlueBloodedToffee]

This game is taking a strange turn of events.

Kills get halved if we lynch scum, no?

Given that we have two flips and a very good chance of finding scum I'm very concerned that Lane/Rev are concerning themselves with finding the SK instead.

[TheReverend]

If people don't want to lynch toffee today, then please explain why.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Rev you've done well discrediting me as a townie.

You stand no chance lynching me though.

[lane0168]

I'm cool with farside. I forgot how quickly she went from having bella a scum suspect to defending her.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: farside

i don't think anyone is concerned with finding the sk. But if you happen to stumble upon the sk, the lynch them reduces the night kills in half

The flips clearly aren't revealing very much for people.

There is 1 scum, 1 sk. both have a kill. Both are not playing to town wincon. How is trying to find scum and sk concerning you.

I'm very concerned your so concerned that we want to lynch an sk.

There are exactly the same amount of scum as sk left. And both are not playing to town wincon. How are you not remotely concerned about sk, and further you are actually concerned about people that care about who the sk might be at this point.

[lane0168]

I'm cool with farside, bbt, or senator. Maybe there's another in there.
Pretty certain FA is town

[BlueBloodedToffee]

It's much, much harder to find the SK than scum.

We have scum associations and flips that we can use to sufficiently narrow down the pool.

If you're looking to 'half the kills' you should be looking for scum.

FWIW, Rev is the SK.

[lane0168]

Yeah fuck that. I change my own mind by reading my own post
VOTE: bbt

I think he's sk and lynching him is just as good as lynching scum

[lane0168]

Well you found papi, so I'll lynch rev next. I trust you

[BlueBloodedToffee]

SK could literally be anyone. How many players left, 12? 1/12 chance of finding SK.

We have narrowed down the pool in which to find scum (due to associations and wagons). Are you saying you don't have a better than 1/12 chance of finding scum? Hunting SK right now is bad play.

PEdit - That makes me happy. I can live with that.

[TheReverend]

It's much, much harder to find the SK than scum.

FWIW, Rev is the SK.

Hahaha! You should be a comedian.

I'm not the SK and I'll prove it when push comes to shove by self voting if my lynch is necessary.

You already made it clear you're not willing to go down quietly, even if it helps town to win.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Although, if you trust me, you should probably listen to me now instead of lynching me...

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Hahaha! You should be a comedian.

I'm not the SK and I'll prove it when push comes to shove by self voting if my lynch is necessary.

You already made it clear you're not willing to go down quietly, even if it helps town to win.

You're right, I won't. And that's not scummy no matter what light you shine on it. But keep trying.

I'm pretty sure you're SK.

[TheReverend]

Shush now, it'll be over soon.

You haven't once explained why you think I'm SK. I've explained why think you are.

Now cobble some shit togther in an attempt to get me lynched today instead of you. It's about your last hope.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Nah, I want to lynch scum.

You can wait.

I stated you were SK way back when you joined the game, remember?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Plotinus even quoted it recently.

[TheReverend]

340 - Reverend is very likely to be SK, and if not, he is scum. Most of the time, when people are hunting a SK it's because they are one or they're scum concerned with who can kill them.

Oh yeah I waved my finger around and you've locked on to that ever since.

Solid reasoning.