In post 211, Originalchris wrote: In post 165, Naomi-Tan wrote:
When I red that I thought it had nothing to do was RVS, though I was confused about the confirmed line of thought. Seems weird all this roleclaiming day 1, but the weirdest part is, why would Chris say kuror0 is confirmed, there has already been a neighbour claim, so it would seem weird to get a 4 person neigh, but 1 is saying confirmed, while the other is saying unconfirmed which looks REALLY strange.
Wait... what??????
This is the most confusing post I've ever read. What are you talking about????? When did I say kuror0 is confirmed, or anything about roleclaiming or neighbors or something?????
wtf????
In post 82, Originalchris wrote:VOTE: kuror0
Guy is confirmed, but hasn't posted yet, and I'll forget he exists otherwise.
Also,
@Droog: What made you decide there were only 9 players, let alone freak out about Riddleton being L-1 (he never was), yet not unvoting? Let's not pretend an RVS wagon adds pressure to anyone, so it wasn't like him being L-1 or L-2 (assuming there were 9 players instead of 13) would've made any difference. Wondering what your mindset was here.
My thoughts:
I hate lurkers. They ruin games, and I think it's a horrible playstyle for anyone that does it on purpose. Real life things happen, but if I can log into my phone and post while still working 60+ hours a week, so can everyone else. I also think lurking is alignment-indicative, since 99% of every game seems to have at least one scum that lurks and survives til the end game due to that. Just saying. Lurkers suck.
In the bolded bit.
Also on the subject of munkir, though it does read off as townish, I'd say argue that its kinda WIFOM partially if he has communication with scum team. Though as I said, I do see him as town.
In post 213, Originalchris wrote:@Naomi: What are you talking about in that post of yours? Where did you ever see me saying anything about confirming anypony, and where do you see anypony role claiming? Are you confusing games here, or what is going on there?
In post 86, droog wrote:kinda said this already
im neighbors with riddleton
i specifically voted him to suss a reaction out of him
see if he'd mention we were neighbors to the public or not
shot that plan to hell
Please pay attention.
In post 214, Originalchris wrote:
Are you serious right now? Are you trying to tell me what I can and cannot comment on? Also, does Naomi = Whomping Willow?????
Why are you and Naomi answering questions for each other? Naomi answered questions directed toward Droog and you. You answer questions or deflect questions asked about/to Naomi. SCUMMMMYYY.
I tend to like to answer questions to anyone, gives good reads later on, more information = More power
In post 218, droog wrote: In post 165, Naomi-Tan wrote:Finally, at the end of post; post 136 you went and voted for chris, but you only mentioned him once as a mid sorta comment, rather than at the end like a bold statement, could you perhaps expand on that point as I personally feel that he isn't really doing anything and looking like he is contributing without saying much, but your RVS statement doesn't speak to me much. so I'd like more.
however
something about this seems more like
scum explaining their town thought processes
than town having town thought processes
When someone does a big content post covering alot of people, Its normal for someone to leave at the end on a strong statement normally a attack and explantion on voting as your reason for voting someone after examining things should pretain to the main ammount of content of anypost and is normally sitted at the end beacuse... well I dunno just normal I guess, I don't know where im going with this right now, but im gonna roll with it and passive type and see where it goes. anyway, so with bigger posts looking at people you normally start with town reads, as they are not a main focus, he did so, and then move onto those people who are kinda mid tier, unsure, one way or another people, then close on them people yours suspicious about, the more evidence you got the more room that part takes up, so... I guess this could be put up to OCD, cause after writing this all out, I can see no reason why the layout would be partically scummy other than the fact you normally vote for people you have the largest feels from, but I guess there is no rule saying your largest feels can't be mid post. wow.. this is gone on way too long
TL:DR - I thought about it, just OCD giving fake tells.
In post 221, Originalchris wrote: In post 217, droog wrote:freakout entirely disproportionate
to the manout of pressure you received
What pressure? I'm looking for scum here, although with Naomi/Whomp/You it seems maybe I hit a jackpot. Naomi did say she thought there were 3 scum. I'm just connecting the dots
So as it stands, my scum list is as follows: Whomp, Naomi, Droog
Looks about right.
I also gave my reasoning behind why I thought there was 3 scum (13 players, 2 would be too little, maybe 4 in a powerful town game, but 3 is balanced.)
In post 223, Originalchris wrote: In post 220, droog wrote: In post 219, Originalchris wrote:Scummiest player by far.
Anti-town in beginning til coached by Droog
, became "super serious" with a bunch of fluff commenting on how people force the word "anyways" over saying the word "anyways" casually (SCUM TELL OF THE YEAR!), somehow disliked my first post of the game as being not-relevant (trying way too hard here to look like a serious scum hunter), and overall deflecting for Naomi now, who I'm still wondering if she made a scum slip or what exactly happened with that post of hers. It makes zero sense whatsoever in regards to this thread, although it was directed toward Whomp, who tried to deflect away from it after I pointed it out.
DO scum have day chat? This would explain quite a bit.
>if scum have daychat, willow is scummy
>if scum dont have daychat, willow is scummy
If scum have daychat, Naomi could be scummy
if scum don't have daychat, willow is still scummy
when willow is scummy, droog coaches and/or defends him
Why am I scummy if scum have daychat?
And time for my thoughts on O-Chris, So after starting slow he has gone on a full on defensive offence, attacking anyone who said anything about him, now looking at this as a scum action, the people he has attacked (me, Droog, Willow) are the 3 people who have drummed up the most discussion and have been talking about points the most, trying to work up information out of day one and get RVS over ASAP, now if your scum, attacking the people who are most towny (Imo) would be a bad idea, as they would have an easier time flipping the tables and attacking back. however, from a town point of view his actions make more sense, as he could be thinking that we are herding people to our tune. (In a situation where we are scum) however, personally speaking I view neither Droog nor Willow nor O-Chris as scum, at this point, So I'm not gonna vote for either.
I would love to see more posts from Riddleton and the other players who are not speaking much; Munkir, GGG, AWA and kuror0. Right now my biggest suspicion is on GGG, looking back on his posts, (bare in mind that I know im town) He put pressure on me on my introduction post, then moved off that after my explanation. After that he moves to defend willow back when willow was not contributing and pretty much trolling. Right now im attucally reading GGG defence of Willow as kinda scum buddie ish, as there was no reason to defend them when they wasn't contributing and the way he did it just didn't feel right.. other than those two things (attack on confirmed town me, (at least from my POV)) and then defending someone who wasn't contributing, they have given no input to discussion other than agreeing with points other people have made.
VOTE: GGG As they have no votes on them, I'm gonna put some heat there way, there lack of contribution and defence of someone, at the time, who had given nothing but votes with no contact, is out outrageous.
Pedit:
at this stage in the game, any reads are good, so though declaring it as an ealry read is good, it doesn't mean that your read will stay the same, take this post. at the start I thought Droog me and Willow was town, but by the end after looking at GGG I wasn't so sure on the latter, everything can change right now and without any REAL information to go on (confirmed infomation) we only really have suspicion gut and research to go off of.
Pedit 2:
Chris beat my Pedit one.
Pedit 3:
no not really, anyone can look up the information, and if your making a statement its your job to back it up, there is no court system that is fair that will not require evidence to convict for a reason...
