Mini Normal 2336 | Birds | Postgame

[petapan]

Vote Count 1.01

T3 (4):

Val89, T3, geraintm, Hu Tao

Rosenator (1):

DArby

GreedyBanger (1):

HighPrincessErinys

Not Voting (7):

Alyssa, GreedyBanger, IAMAKIWI, MickeyCop, rabbitrhino, Shinless, Rosenator

With 13 alive, it's 7 to eliminate.

Deadline for Day 1 is May 26 at 10:30 AM EDT.

Deadline Timer:

(expired on 2024-05-26 10:30:00)

[HighPrincessErinys]

hell yeah chickadee

[T3]

In post 19, Rosenator wrote:
By my count, that's only 4 votes? Elimination is 7?

She was joking.

it is extremely unclear to tell that through text, and popping in to vote T3 after Val89 revealed the bandwagon was a trap just seems like a foolish play rather than a separate ruse.

good to see people aren't just lurking, though

Val's vote on me wasn't a trap - it was also a joke. Sorry

[DArby]

Honestly day one votes aren’t much about actual plays or votes. None of this is really alignment indicative (AI). It’s how people respond to this that starts the reads.

[DArby]

@rosenator

[T3]

Rosenator is probably town

additionally since T3 opted to vote themselves instead of defending anything, i think they're vanilla of some kind. not necessarily town, but definitely not a power role

Newbie scum makes this post in the scum PT not the main thread

[Val89]

additionally since T3 opted to vote themselves instead of defending anything, i think they're vanilla of some kind. not necessarily town, but definitely not a power role

It's probably important to note that, in general, speculating on the existence of PRs or otherwise until there is a good reason is helpful to scum. I imagine that, regardless of actual alignment, T3 has enough experience not to do so, but if that discussion induces other perhaps less-experienced players to speculate also, that can give clues as who the PRs are (and who are not). We don't want that without good reason, because they risk getting shot at night. What you've said here probably does no damage, but going forward, it might help to be mindful of that.

Your enthusiasm is infectious, however. In fact, I am half expecting you to pick up at least one scumread for it before the end of the day

[T3]

VOTE: rabbitrhino

[T3]

thanks! i've been enjoying it so far, didn't expect this game to start until late May/early June but i also have no feel for the speed of the queue yet lmao

I was surprised at how fast this game filled too, but I'm not busy at all with school right now, so it's pretty good timing

[Shinless]

Hello everyone!

I am new, surprised some more experienced players have missed this, but

VOTE: IAMAKIWI

Literally admits to being a bird

[HighPrincessErinys]

What if rosenator is secretly a mafia master and we just don't know it? Like some real crouching tiger stuff.

[DArby]

Hello everyone!

I am new, surprised some more experienced players have missed this, but

VOTE: IAMAKIWI

Literally admits to being a bird

Do you have any opinions on the T3 vote train?

[Shinless]

Mmm not really, seemed it was over before it got going really . Maybe geraintm hopping on without saying anything may be slightly dodgy

You?

[Rosenator]

What if rosenator is secretly a mafia master and we just don't know it? Like some real crouching tiger stuff.

i assure you that i only have two thoughts and they're both fighting each other for third place

Honestly day one votes aren’t much about actual plays or votes. None of this is really alignment indicative (AI). It’s how people respond to this that starts the reads.

are reads not plays? i get that nobody has any info (except scum ofc) but i genuinely don't get why d1 is just "go nuts, vote nuts, whatever." if i think someone's scum i should say something, right?

[Rosenator]

additionally, if day 1 really isn't important, why is it longer than

any

other phase of the game? i'm pretty sure even the queue was shorter than 10 days

[Alyssa]

Oh god this popped off a lot faster than I was anticipating.

So catching up:
- T3's train is whatever.
- rose is weird. DArby picked up on the same thing from their first post that I felt in that it was a really weird way to hop onto a train (day 1 that it is). Rose's response to this post is to immediately unvote? Like I can feel someone new at the game might do this from either side, but it just feels weird.
- HighPrincessErinys (may I summarize this as HPE going forward?) and Shinless are both weird. HighPrincessErinys puts its vote on a random person and then proceeds to fluff. Fair for day 1 but I hope something comes from this watching. Shinless voted someone else and when he was prompted as to his thoughts on the T3 train said not really, then tried to make a small finger point to geraintm and then deflected the question back. I'm curious what makes his joke vote better than the other non-serious vote, and there's definitely more to be looked at. Not to mention that the train is still ongoing; three people (I think I counted correctly?) are still on it, after all.

Right now I think a VOTE: Shinless is probably the best place to put my vote for now.

[Shinless]

additionally, if day 1 really isn't important, why is it longer than

any

other phase of the game? i'm pretty sure even the queue was shorter than 10 days

I guess cos we don't start with any info so it takes longer to get anywhere. Does seem a long time though

[Shinless]

Oh god this popped off a lot faster than I was anticipating.

So catching up:
- T3's train is whatever.
- rose is weird. DArby picked up on the same thing from their first post that I felt in that it was a really weird way to hop onto a train (day 1 that it is). Rose's response to this post is to immediately unvote? Like I can feel someone new at the game might do this from either side, but it just feels weird.
- HighPrincessErinys (may I summarize this as HPE going forward?) and Shinless are both weird. HighPrincessErinys puts its vote on a random person and then proceeds to fluff. Fair for day 1 but I hope something comes from this watching. Shinless voted someone else and when he was prompted as to his thoughts on the T3 train said not really, then tried to make a small finger point to geraintm and then deflected the question back. I'm curious what makes his joke vote better than the other non-serious vote, and there's definitely more to be looked at. Not to mention that the train is still ongoing; three people (I think I counted correctly?) are still on it, after all.

Right now I think a VOTE: Shinless is probably the best place to put my vote for now.

Answered the question honestly, though there wasn't heaps to say
Is it weird to ask the question back?

[geraintm]

Mmm not really, seemed it was over before it got going really . Maybe geraintm hopping on without saying anything may be slightly dodgy

You?

I clearly said something!

[Shinless]

Oh god this popped off a lot faster than I was anticipating.

So catching up:
-

T3's train is whatever.

- rose is weird. DArby picked up on the same thing from their first post that I felt in that it was a really weird way to hop onto a train (day 1 that it is). Rose's response to this post is to immediately unvote? Like I can feel someone new at the game might do this from either side, but it just feels weird.
- HighPrincessErinys (may I summarize this as HPE going forward?) and Shinless are both weird. HighPrincessErinys puts its vote on a random person and then proceeds to fluff. Fair for day 1 but I hope something comes from this watching. Shinless voted someone else and when he was prompted as to his thoughts on the T3 train said not really, then tried to make a small finger point to geraintm and then deflected the question back. I'm curious what makes his joke vote better than the other non-serious vote, and there's definitely more to be looked at.

Not to mention that the train is still ongoing; three people (I think I counted correctly?) are still on it, after all.

Right now I think a VOTE: Shinless is probably the best place to put my vote for now.

Seems like a contradiction

[Shinless]

Oh god this popped off a lot faster than I was anticipating.

So catching up:
-

T3's train is whatever.

- rose is weird. DArby picked up on the same thing from their first post that I felt in that it was a really weird way to hop onto a train (day 1 that it is). Rose's response to this post is to immediately unvote? Like I can feel someone new at the game might do this from either side, but it just feels weird.
- HighPrincessErinys (may I summarize this as HPE going forward?) and Shinless are both weird. HighPrincessErinys puts its vote on a random person and then proceeds to fluff. Fair for day 1 but I hope something comes from this watching. Shinless voted someone else and when he was prompted as to his thoughts on the T3 train said not really, then tried to make a small finger point to geraintm and then deflected the question back. I'm curious what makes his joke vote better than the other non-serious vote, and there's definitely more to be looked at.

Not to mention that the train is still ongoing; three people (I think I counted correctly?) are still on it, after all.

Right now I think a VOTE: Shinless is probably the best place to put my vote for now.

Seems like a contradiction

[Alyssa]

Seems like a contradiction

In what way?

[Shinless]

By saying t3 train is whatever, I assume you meant like "not significant", but later saying the train is significant and still happening (as a counter to my dismissing it)

[Alyssa]

the train is significant and still happening

1. These two things aren't the same thing.
2. Never said T3's train is significant. What could be relevant later on is people's reactions to the train. The actual train itself is whatever.

[Rosenator]

- rose is weird. DArby picked up on the same thing from their first post that I felt in that it was a really weird way to hop onto a train (day 1 that it is). Rose's response to this post is to immediately unvote? Like I can feel someone new at the game might do this from either side, but it just feels weird.

it was a "whoops, learning as i go" thing; you'll probably see some more "weird" behavior from me as the game goes on. not much i can do if you just think i have a strange vibe