In post 158, beastcharizard wrote:Can you explain your reads please? Kat has said like 2 things and Metal has said like 1 thing yet one is slight scum and the other needs moar? Neither have posted content so i am curious how you got those reads. I agree with the jbomber scum read only because they played the new card and their reads don't make much sense to me. How is Hopkirk town exactly?
Katarina LeBlanc declared herself town. That rubs me the wrong way and starts her off in the hole. Metal Sonic's presence has been pretty negligible at my reads point.
Hopkirk is town because I'm not seeing no scum motivation to his posts. He's like a foreign subway map. The wording he uses is confusing, but if you stare at it enough you can figure out the tracks make some logical sense.
--That said, his
Post 174 downgraded the town-read quite a bit.
Ugh. Oh, it's you. Hidden in a hydra. You're one of the ones I've given up trying to convince that his "signature move" is just idiotic nonsense.
In post 164, Antihero wrote:@kk
i'm guessing your scumread on beast, monkeyman and i stem from your read on hopkirk and bob?
the one i'm really interested in is beast, please expound on that one
Mostly yeah. I see beastcharizard's attacks on Hopkirk as pretty floppy and opportunistic. He makes three anti-Hopkirk posts (mostly based on feelings, no actual questioning or probing), then asks what Hopkirk's read on him is (
Post 149). I'm not reading that as a town sequence of posting.
In post 166, Antihero wrote:amendment: expound on your monkeyman one too, i think that one's interesting as well.
I'm waffling on his read a bit. But I really didn't like the Day 1 FOS in
Post 102 on a guy with 3 (of 10) votes. It reeks of too much caution.
In post 168, Twisted Advice wrote:The jester claim was simply a dull joke. I liked the fact that he pulled suspicion on [Bicephalous Bob].
...
Kublai Khan:
See above for GreyICE versus Bob
Calling it a "suspicion" is a strong stretch. His vote (
Post 51) looks to be a straight OMGUS from Bicephalous Bob calling him scummy. Exactly what about it did you like?
Also, I'm really hating the "2 different answers to every question" routine (also the roleplaying). Either find some level of agreement between the two of you before posting, or one of you just stop posting, or each of you get your own frigging role and play mafia like normal people. "I thought this and he thought that" is not a helpful answer to anything, it's just blahblahblah. I care about WHY not WHO.
In post 168, Twisted Advice wrote:Now let us discuss your reads list: namely that it conflicts will essentially every read of mine.
Explain how both Bob and Hopkirk are both town. I could see the argument that one might be scum and the other may be oblivious of this and be playing along, but I find it incredibly naive to believe them both town.
In addition, please explain how you have scum reads on Katarina, charizard, Monkeyman, and Antihero, as well as GreyICE and jbomber. In fact if you could explain all of your reads, that would be most appreciated.
Too much work. We are not even close to being on the same wavelength. Let's see if we can see eye-to-eye on GreyICE v Bicephalous Bob before we argue on everything else.
In post 169, Twisted Advice wrote:I thought that one Greyice post was town not because scum couldn't have written it, but because it would not be in their best interests to write it.
Eh, I disagree because I know how much experience GreyICE has. If he's scum and hasn't maneuvered himself into a good lie to keep himself alive past Day 4, he'll gladly die in a manner that helps his scummate(s) survive.
He plays the long-game and a day 1 throwaway post like that is not going to haunt him in the slightest.
In post 252, Turkish Van wrote:Where's PereV at all in this list as you seem to not have put his name in a list. I don't agree with the quick scumread on BC, can you explain that for me? Also how is Bob a townread?
Hmm.. I erased him off "slight scum" and forgot to put him down somewhere. Consider him a "need further study". beastcharizard read explained earlier.
Bicephalous Bob is a townread because I haven't read a decent case on him. Got one?
--
notscience gets an F for reading comprehension on that last bit.
