In post 606, Obi-Wan Kenobi wrote:@Cakey, really, with multiple people calling my question scummy, you think RR will answer? More than likely, they will retreat into their "we never give reads" posture. Yet, people can be read based on the stances they take, even if early or premature.
I'm tempted to dump in an essay here, but I just want you to know I saw this and I resisted.
In post 727, McMenno wrote: In post 723, Obi-Wan Kenobi wrote: In post 722, Xkfyu wrote: In post 721, Yume wrote:It's what it says. It's up to you whether you believe it or not. *shrugs*
That would be a ridiculous thing for you to lie about.
Agreed, but maybe confused or a gambit? I think Mastina's town anyway so no rush. Yume is likely town as well. KTS is town because they are not going to fake innocent child as scum.
that's obviously a joke
so I think skybird is town, because having an automatic pt with steven universe, and thereby automatically knowing who they are seems pretty strong for scum, going to townlean her for that
VOTE: Reasonably Rational
I want to believe
Umm... we were Steven in the first SU game. Our big thing was that we could IC on day 5. On day 3 we had two people and ourselves thrown into a permanent alliance. (Mastin and Xtoxm). We then lynched a scum that day who had strongman on season finale and so we actually ended up using the same logic. We concluded that Varsoon would not have given scum knowledge of who we were so they could just turn around and murder us the next night without us having any reliable way to avoid it (there were two ways for us to avoid it: luck into lynching the strongman before first finale (this is what happened) or another town slot had to be both alive, allied with us, have a 1-shot per game ability available and USE it to commute us and them out of the game on the finale night). We were so certain that it made no sense to make an IC and then have it get killed 99% of the time before it could ever become IC that we concluded scum would not have been given access to our identity.
Now ... Varsoon does like to change things up as a mod so I wouldn't go so far as to say Skybird automatically must be scum ... but I sure as hell am not going to assume town after what happened in the original game.
Long story short: farside was being widely scum read but we put together a case for why they were almost certainly town. We were running a reaction test on them before we unvoted and moved on to plan we had stated. The plan we had stated called for us lynching Grapes (claimed miller) that day, someone else the next day and the final scum the day after.
Grapes, ignoring our really strong case for why farside must be town decided to hammer farside and end the day rather than take his lynch, which he knew he had to eat because of being and claiming miller. His action took us from guaranteed win to a last day where we had someone who had been kind of super trollish (think firebringer, only WAY worse) plus our two day 3 alliance people still alive.
Since we assumed scum would not have been gifted knowledge of who we were, that really strongly influenced our thinking and we ended up lynching the super-troll player, and Xtoxm was the last scum.
So yeah ... ummm. Please don't make unfounded assumptions. Please.
In post 839, Firebringer wrote: In post 831, mastin2 wrote: In post 695, Firebringer wrote:Does alliance in that context mean that Skybird can talk to the player who has role card of Steven Universe?
I am guessing that makes Skybird "Connie".
Really not a bad assumption.
As for the event triggering the -2 stress: an extension of me being a miller I suppose is that my event power instead of raising stress lowers it by two. That was my trigger. (I know, Varsoon said that in general, town events will raise stress and scum events will lower stress. But mine didn't. Dealwithit.) It was a pro-town power, I assure you, best used early rather than later especially given that I'm going to die early this game regardless.
VOTE: Not Chara.
In post 833, Yume wrote:Okay, now I've taken care of that neighborhood stuff. I am ready to sheep.
VOTE: Not Chara
The blind leading the blinder.
I warned you. You just went on my PL list for this game. Be an unwarranted asshole again and see what happens.
~D