Mini 1310: I Got My Eye On You Mafia (Game Over!)

[Voidedmafia]

Votecount 1.1:

DeltaWave - IceGuy, kondi2424, iStark
Glass - ActionDan
IceGuy - vijay2vasandani
Rylai Crestfall - Glass, Malthusis
vijay2vasandani - Rylai Crestfall
kondi2424 - Luckyjt

Not Voting: Mist Beauty, Lopsy, Otto von Clark

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch and to no-lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2012-04-05 15:06:38)

IStark is V/LA until March 20th

[vijay2vasandani]

FoS: Glass

Yucky GF tell is yucky.

[DeltaWave]

Sup.

iStark gained scumpoints for Post 19. Sounds like you're just looking for an easy out bro.

[malthusis]

@Rylai: Why do you think v2v is scum? Looking through the archive, I see a ton of times where you state a case on X, but then keep voting v2v because he's scummier. However, you haven't actually stated why you're voting him. Explain?

[Voidedmafia]

MB nor Otto von Clark have replied to me at all, thus they shall be replaced soon.

[Voidedmafia]

IceGuy, Kondi, ActionDan, Rylai, and Lucky (and myself) have been prodded.

Still waiting on the two replacements -_-

[IceGuy]

I didn't get a prod.

[kondi2424]

SOWWY

[Luckyjt]

Still getting used to the fact the site is back up. Sorry about not posting. It seems nothing much has happened though.

[Glass]

Hey, actiondan I got to the part you were talking about, now misrep buddy.

Otto is being crazy for thinking that vijay was actually trying to hammer, but his vote is in the right spot regardless.

You make it seem as though I said:
"Otto looks like scum, but I'll lay off him because hes voting the correct person"

Yucky GF tell is yucky.

That was kind of my point, how do you plan on getting everyone to agree to investigate the same person?

[vijay2vasandani]

^ yeah I was thinking that. We could just do a random dice roll here couldn't we? Idk how but I've seen it done before.

[vijay2vasandani]

For the sake of real randomness we could all do dice rolls and add them up. I really like the idea of all cops investigating one person.

[Glass]

I dislike the idea of a randomized selection just because it seems sub-optimal.

Iwas thinking of everyone listing their top town read and then everyone investigates whoever gets the most votes. But I am not sure about this, need to think a bit more on it.

Anyone agree/disagree that the cops should investigate the same person tonight?

[Lopsy]

I'm super relieved because we didn't lose all of the data for this thread.

In other words... I'm glad that this game of mafia wasn't voided.

/sunglasses

Nevertheless, unfortunately,

V/LA until Thursday

because I'm hosting an exchange student from Japan.

[Lopsy]

Before I go and play Ping-Pong with たかひろ, I just want to say: isn't all cops investigating the same person a severe waste of resources? (We lose less entropy, etc) I'm almost wary of IceGuy/v2v just for supporting it, but I may be overlooking some deeper motivation.

Until Thursday, I won't have time for analysis of anyone in particular. Sorry.

[vijay2vasandani]

The reasoning behind it is because of the theme it is rather likely that cops of differing sanities will be present. Hence to do away with this issue I believe it's a good idea.

[Voidedmafia]

In other words... I'm glad that this game of mafia wasn't voided.

/sunglasses

Hurrr.

In other news, BBmolla replaces Mist Beauty effective immediately. Still searching for a replacement for Otto von Clark.

EDIT: Also, ActionDan is being replaced due to not picking up his prod or responding in any way. Rylai and iStark are close to being replaced, as well, and I haven't heard from either of them yet.

[Rylai Crestfall]

Sorry, I haven't been following mafia that much since the crash and among other things, and I seriously don't want to just throw out a halfassed post. I'll go make a post first thing tomorrow.

[vijay2vasandani]

XD BB man, how's it going?

[Voidedmafia]

And iStark goes bye-bye. I'll put up a request when I wake up.

[ActionDan]

I r here.

I thought I would wait until everyone showed up.

Glass I never suggested you called Otto scum? I meant if you are ok with Otto's vote, why not be ok with Rylai's?

[Glass]

VOTE: actiondan

Yes, you did:

Similarly, I can't reconcile how you are ok with Otto since "his vote is in the right place" but are not willing to reach out and do the same for Rylai.

I meant if you are ok with Otto's vote, why not be ok with Rylai's?

That is not at all why I am (was) voting rylai...

Deltawave's claim is starting to sound bullshit. However, I am not willing to lynch him today. Why?
1) This is a closed set up. We have no idea what the set up is. Sure, there may be cops because of the theme, but I'm not gonna believe it without a claim or some flips. Same thing with a miller.
2) What if he flips town who doesn't know how to deal with a miller claim? Where do we go from his flip? His ISO is so bare, there's really nothing to go on that. We'd basically be in the same position on D2 because of lack of connections from our lynch target.
3) He claimed miller. He's basically set up for a policy lynch before Lylo. I do not that want day to be D1.
4) I saw someone else do this kind of weird miller claim in another game.

God. Another scummy person. So you don't want to lynch someone who you think is lying about being miller because...
1. He miggghhttt be miller
2. We wouldn't have anything to go on for D2. BS. We have the same amount of info as if anyone else was lynched, looking over what dead people said isnt very productive, its better to look at how people attacked the dead-town and the wagon. Also, people have (or at least should have) suspicions regardless of the flip.
3. You dont want to policy lynch someone d1? You want to policy lynch them later? wtf?
4. There was a miller claim in another game.

This is the main reason I am (was) voting for him. There were a few minor other scummy things though.

But regarding actiondan: his whiteknighting of rylai is ridiculous, and since they know each other I think it is more likely that actiondan is scum and trying to buddy up to rylai than anything else. His chainsaw defense ultimatum doesn't help his case either.

[Glass]

In other news, BBmolla replaces Mist Beauty effective immediately.

newage 2.0?

[Voidedmafia]

Before anyone says anything, ActionDan isn't yet back in the game. I need to check on a couple things first before I do anything officially.

[Luckyjt]

Alright it still seems like we dont have much to work on from anything new since the crash. I have yet to download the files since I was hoping more people would be conversing here but I am wrong, so i will have to get the files and then look to see what I can work with.