Mini #76, Black and White

[Wacky]

I should start trusting those instincts.

And good job MeMe! Next time, don't hyphenate. It's .. well.. weird.

Happy New Year!

[No Idea]

Yay, my first win ever!!!

The funny thing is that on night one, MeMe

asked

me to vote for her because she was sure that people would get suspicious of her if she'll survive the night, and she that it would be best if I'll say it first. Actually, I still don't understand why is it crap logic...

Wacky, you really do have amazing instincts. And what was that invisible typo thing all about?

And MeMe, you really impressed me during the whole game, especially day 4. Very well played!

Good game! Thanks a lot, mod.

[Wacky]

Well, I was typing out the list and made a Freudian typo. And thought it was funny.

Instincts are useless if I didn't trust them, and I didn't. Which was bad. So I'll be trusting them now.

"Actually, I still don't understand why is it crap logic... "

Well, it isn't, exactly. Only if this argument was true MeMe would never live past Day 1, and would probably get annoyed. I'm pretty sure that we do NOT want to see MeMe annoyed.

Seriously though, if we accepted the argument, then the mafia could pretty easily not kill her and use this argument for a free lynch.

[The Mystery Celly]

That was pretty tricky with Meme, what with lynching Blackhawk and all. Did you have that planned out ahead of time, it seemed like Blackhawk would have let something slip if it hadn't been. I was really surprised Meme was able to mislead the town so much without anyone noticing, really great play. Everybody just seemed to follow her on votes without ever noticing that she had started lynches on like 3 innocents in a row. I had mafia pegged as No Idea and Isaac after Day One, but No Idea and Meme towards the end.

[Kerplunk]

I found it a bit weird to lynch someone because he had a bit different wording in his PM. But hey, we got to lynch someone right? And it

seemed

that the whole town agreed on this. And MeMe was on the wagon, MeMe is never wrong...

Oh and did I mention that this was one of the funnest games I've played. Nice one, PolarBoy! Thanks.

This one will make the mafia learningbooks in 'How to mislead the town effectively', I bet.

[Gammie]

*cries*

Ahhh, I thought MeMe was innocent if she went through all that trouble to write all that up

Yeah, definately gotta make this "How to Confuse Town from Day 1"

Note to Self: Just because MeMe wants to "help the town" doesn't mean she's not mafia

[blackhawk]

YESSS!!!! my first mfia win(even though i was )
i had no idea that MeMe was going to peg me day one, she caught me offgaurd which probably worked better than had she told me the plan after day 1 i got this PM oh well i deleted it but it said
"Great Performance out there"
and i was like "what? ohh"

[MeMe]

That was pretty tricky with Meme, what with lynching Blackhawk and all. Did you have that planned out ahead of time, it seemed like Blackhawk would have let something slip if it hadn't been.

Like No Idea said, our original plan was to sacrifice

me

, but when our "MeMe should've been killed night 1" trap backfired, we kind of shifted to blackhawk on the fly. I think blackhawk deserves lots of credit for getting more and more "upset" and voting for me -- I thought he did an awesome job.

That last night was so hard -- NI and I weren't sure that killing Wacky was the best plan. The only thing we

were

sure of was that Isaac would be our lynch focus on the last day; his "three of five" mistake was just too wonderful to waste. I actually whooped aloud when I saw it!

Thanks so much for an awesomely fun game, PB!

[Carmine]

Heh, congrats mafia. To be honest, I'm glad that MeMe turned out to be eeeevil, it makes me feel better about the world of mafiascum. That said, yeah, sorry for playing into their hands so easily, town - it was a learning experience for me, at least

Thanks PolarBoy. Are you suprised at the result?

[blackhawk]

wasnt this game bet on? in the place your bets thread?

[PolarBoy]

Well I did open it up more or less, but nobody sent me their suspicions, except Wacky, and he was right on the money, so I guess he wins. Congrats Wacky.

I hope everyone also learned a valuable lesson from all of this. That being "Don't out-guess the mod" or at least "Don't out-guess PolarBoy".

MeMe, I must say I'm impressed at how you did. I'm going to be very careful if you survive night one next time we play together.

[Stewie]

I posted what I expected to happen, and it happened: mafia win. It was interesting to read.

[MeMe]

last post