NY 169: The EPIC XD Mafia Game of Greatness (Game Over)

[Prophylaxis]

We have claimed masons and a 'no gun' result from a now proven Gunsmith

*chuckles*

We have a claimed Doc who also claims to have targeted someone other than Gunsmith last night.
Gunsmith died.
The claimed Doc has posted about cheese since then.
Some people seem to actually think we shouldn't lynch said claimed Doc today. They want to "use our time".
Mostly we are "using the time" to debate which, if any, of them are also scum.

If you read only the last 30 or so pages you can receive the bulk of this info with names and some interactions attached to it and be basically up to speed.

Then a few reads might be sexy.

Will do, though I'll probably just start from the beginning. Starting in the middle of the thread is always very disconcerting to me.

I'll be caught up by the end of the weekend, I think.

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

Mara, I read through your Norl-town case and I am not entirely convinced he can't fake those things as scum. I'll look through the things you mentioned while reading his scumgames to see what I find.

Norlkaz, I'd like to see your reasoning behind your reads (as much as you can provide). I think that will help a lot as far as making you more transparent or "towninate" if you are town.

[Generic]

Prophylaxis replaces Bert.

Hello Proph!

Looks like you get to play with the unrestricted version of me now


KBBQ, are you trying to earn town cred by the self vote or is there another reason for it with only one vote on you? Cos to me it comes across as extremely forced.

[KoreanBBQ]

KBBQ, are you trying to earn town cred by the self vote or is there another reason for it with only one vote on you? Cos to me it comes across as extremely forced.

My vote is me being annoyed and mocking Titus 'cause I mean, who in their right mind would think that was a vig claim? You can take your "that's forced" and "are you trying to earn town cred?" 'cause your accusations are so off base and ridiculous that its not even funny; in fact, they are rather sad. I wouldn't even mind dying that much 'cause between Titus, you and Hana...I'm going to have a fucking aneurysm. At least when I flip town you guys will know my reads are sincere and can lynch from my POE list 'cause that's where I think scum are.

[Casso the King of Seals]

@Everyone, who are the 3 most likely scum in this group?

Casso the King of Seals
pieguyn
BROseidon
Norlkaz
Ser Arthur Dayne
zMuffinMan
Titus

Is this your PoE list?

[Generic]

You want to throw a tantrum at the master of them?

Ok, let's break it down. I never read your comment how Titus is selling it. Titus replaced a scumread of mind in cephrir. I'm not voting for you. You earned town cred day 1 for a self vote. Suddenly one person uses ridiculously poor logic to vote for you. No one else follows onto that wagon. You cry and self vote.

Yeah. Forced.

Hanas town read on Titus I find hilarious as it is, because you can't possibly fake not knowing that on day 1 mcmaraca claimed scum must have day talk, can you?
In fact it was done in such an obvious way and hana felt such a need to highlight it it feels like two people going out of their way to pull a not so subtle gambit.
I gave you a lot of town cred hana for the defeatist attitude I can relate to from games like wingate where I felt the same way as town. And I don't want to believe someone would want up win a game of mafia so much they would stoop so low with a tactic like that.
So I can only put it down to you easily accepting things at face value, but I never had you down as so bloody naive.

[Prophylaxis]

Prophylaxis replaces Bert.

Hello Proph!

Looks like you get to play with the unrestricted version of me now

Finished through page 25 now, and I have some scum reads but it's really difficult to get reads when half the playerbase is literally spamming up the thread with inane one-liners. I'll repost my notes (hopefully with less griping) once I'm finished w/my read.

[zMuffinMan]

what zMuffin did was a fencesit. He took no strong positions and just said well it could be this and it could be that.

that's not at all what i said

For instance KoreanBBQ softclaims Vig (permission to kill)

considering that was most likely a nero post and nero uses the word kill for people he wants to lynch (you were in FEA where he wanted to "kill" me for a long time so you should really know this) i dunno how you got a vig softclaim from that

You still didn't get around to telling me how Nacho and I hadn't discussed you.

what is the point of this question? what does it achieve? you should really

know

why i thought this since i've already explained it.

[KoreanBBQ]

That's bullshit.

VOTE: KoreanBBQ

If you really didn't understand, the confusion should have been the first thing you said. Second, the softclaim s innately obvious as only vigs and sks need permission to kill. Die scum.

Ha
Haha
Ahahahaha
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

oh lordy what the fufk did I just read

[KoreanBBQ]

Is she srsly pushing ne with that vig sofy?
Even after the VT claim st the end of D1 before the vig flip?
You either didn't read or you are full of shit!

[KoreanBBQ]

Oh this felt great
Hi

[KoreanBBQ]

You want to throw a tantrum at the master of them?

Ok, let's break it down. I never read your comment how Titus is selling it. Titus replaced a scumread of mind in cephrir. I'm not voting for you. You earned town cred day 1 for a self vote. Suddenly one person uses ridiculously poor logic to vote for you. No one else follows onto that wagon. You cry and self vote.

Yeah. Forced.

Hanas town read on Titus I find hilarious as it is, because you can't possibly fake not knowing that on day 1 mcmaraca claimed scum must have day talk, can you?
In fact it was done in such an obvious way and hana felt such a need to highlight it it feels like two people going out of their way to pull a not so subtle gambit.
I gave you a lot of town cred hana for the defeatist attitude I can relate to from games like wingate where I felt the same way as town. And I don't want to believe someone would want up win a game of mafia so much they would stoop so low with a tactic like that.
So I can only put it down to you easily accepting things at face value, but I never had you down as so bloody naive.

But is it scummy?

Proving points tend to look forced a lot of times though.

[KoreanBBQ]

Also why so many replavements

[geists]

Hi proph!

I've always wanted to play with you, I've enjoyed what I read on MTGS.

Although I'm definitely the background head in this hydra.

[KoreanBBQ]

Prophylaxis replaces Bert.

Hello Proph!

Looks like you get to play with the unrestricted version of me now


KBBQ, are you trying to earn town cred by the self vote or is there another reason for it with only one vote on you? Cos to me it comes across as extremely forced.

Nero proving point
We dont need to fake such thing when we already have a good amount of toencred dontcha think?

[KoreanBBQ]

Hi proph!

I've always wanted to play with you, I've enjoyed what I read on MTGS.

Although I'm definitely the background head in this hydra.

MTGS as in MeTal Gear Solid?

[KoreanBBQ]

Also if anyone is scumreading sakura at this point, her activity level is enough to prove her townness.

[geists]

Nah, Magic the Gathering Salvation.

Its quite a few scummers home site and my surrogate home after the demise of Px2.

[geists]

Nero have you done anything townie lately? I haven't read since day start.

[KoreanBBQ]

Do I look like nero to you?

[KoreanBBQ]

Scum without daytalk, and poor night summary is very possible even with a replace in fumbling.

But masons have daytalk and Cabd informed us of this because it makes it very very likely scum has daytalk too.

Playing devil's advocate, that shit is very easy to fake.

[KoreanBBQ]

Like, for an example, why did she decide to mention a lack of daytalk out of nowhere?

[KoreanBBQ]

Not all scum qts have strong summaries so yeah not a town tell. Scum without daytalk, and poor night summary is very possible even with a replace in fumbling. Don't use that as a towntell. If you do, when I am scum, I will burn you. I love burning outside tells like that.

Added to this, the showing of sudden "I abuse this as scum" sounds like a one giant wifom.

[KoreanBBQ]

Scum without daytalk, and poor night summary is very possible even with a replace in fumbling.

But masons have daytalk and Cabd informed us of this because it makes it very very likely scum has daytalk too.

Playing devil's advocate, that shit is very easy to fake.

I take this back.
It wasn't easy for her to fake it properly.
Whichever slot she replaced is prob scum.
Nero's just not coolheaded enough to be cool like me

[KoreanBBQ]

Replaced cephrir? Hmm
I was townreading that slot :/
Townread overruled!