So hi, I'm Akane, and this game made me wish I'd never done a secret alt in the first place, but once I'd done it I felt like I needed to stick to my guns. (And now I'm just done with long-form forum mafia so it didn't even end up mattering, argh.) And I'm tired of not being able to talk about it as myself and not as an alt so here goes.
It would have been a lot less stressful on me in the end if I'd been able to respond to things clearly as myself. Things like "OH MY GOD YES YOU DO SO TOTALLY DO STUPID FAKECLAIMS" -- something Gamma was able to say when he replaced in, but not something I was able to say because I was mostly thinking of face-to-face games and didn't want to narrow down my identity that far (especially since I was being consistently read as "she" despite never putting a gender identity in my profile... <_<)
Things like not getting yelled at for being a secret alt, because come on, if I hadn't slipped up when arguing against Reck's claim, it might never have even become known.
Things like "OH MY GOD STOP YELLING TERRIBLE THINGS AT ME" because I knew Reck, even if he didn't "know" me. And on that note, knowing or not knowing someone really shouldn't make a difference in whether or not you are the bare minimum of civil to them, but I
really
don't want to get into it again, so I'm just gonna leave it at that.And especially,
especially
I wanted to respond to all the setup speculation featuring things like "Pie would do this!" or "Pie wouldn't do that." This post in particular made me laugh really hard because all those things are also true of me, except that I have
heard him suggest things and actually put things in a game
that would make for a "bonkers pants-on-head stupid ass" role, if not an entire setup. I think Pie mentioned this in the dead thread but he made a game off-site that had a role of town pinata. When killed, the person explodes into candy and every player gets one. The candies take up the place of a role action if you use them but don't actually do anything. I feel like that qualifies as pretty "pants-on-head," although to be fair I also helped design that role so I have to take credit for some of the stupidity. <_<so tl;dr I shouldn't have been afraid of being attacked for being me (I feel like I'm perceived as an easy-to-lynch player) and just not done a secret alt. Certain aspects of the game probably would have gone more smoothly.
PS: I want to gripe that a serial killer with one kill is, by definition, not a
serial
killer. It's not as drastically misleading as Reck's role name, but I still feel like I should have been called a "JOAT survivor" or something, because that's essentially what I was.