In post 59, Nachomamma8 wrote:my actiondan read is gut based on how he's approached the game thus far and normally wouldn't even be a feeling that hit the thread, but the thread's start wasn't exactly the most exciting.
I actually think we're seeing the same thing here, I just thought his first post by itself was way too early to call him town for it. either way, I don't have any problem with what he's done so far.
In post 61, Nachomamma8 wrote:this thought processed is fleshed out pretty decently for earlygame, and is a good plan
it makes him less likely to be recruiter
i don't really think anyone in this playerlist would recruit him
I disagree with this, though. part of my plan to recruit you if I wound up rolling scum here involved having to bullshit reasons why I would likely recruit another person or why I wouldn't recruit you in order to get out of it - or if it'd be worth it to truthfully claim I'd recruit you bc of WIFOM - since you'd obviously fall under a lot of scrutiny from it and anyone who knows my play well enough would probably be able to guess I'd recruit you. I would expect other people would plan out how they'd handle it in a similar way.
essentially, I don't think it's a good idea to read anyone based on who they'd recruit or how many ppl would recruit them. Dan's attitude is a better reason to town read him.
don't see this either. there's really nothing I'd expect him to go out of his way to do given it's post fucking 12. what did you think was safe about it?
In post 76, pieguyn wrote:essentially, I don't think it's a good idea to read anyone based on who they'd recruit or how many ppl would recruit them. Dan's attitude is a better reason to town read him.
If you are scum, you have an optimal path that you will take and ultimately you will take it. Anything else that you bullshit is going to be weaker than what your actual reasoning was. Reasoning that makes sense to me and seems genuine enough is worth an early townread from me.
In post 77, pieguyn wrote:don't see this either. there's really nothing I'd expect him to go out of his way to do given it's post fucking 12. what did you think was safe about it?
Actually, before I answer this:
Alchemist, why pie or Metal Sonic?
"Playing with Nacho is like playing with a religious conservative." ~UncertainKitten
-- Fate, Vanilla Townie, was brutally stabbed by a throwing sword in endgame.
In post 76, pieguyn wrote:essentially, I don't think it's a good idea to read anyone based on who they'd recruit or how many ppl would recruit them. Dan's attitude is a better reason to town read him.
If you are scum, you have an optimal path that you will take and ultimately you will take it. Anything else that you bullshit is going to be weaker than what your actual reasoning was. Reasoning that makes sense to me and seems genuine enough is worth an early townread from me.
In post 77, pieguyn wrote:don't see this either. there's really nothing I'd expect him to go out of his way to do given it's post fucking 12. what did you think was safe about it?
Actually, before I answer this:
Alchemist, why pie or Metal Sonic?
I've been scum with Pie before and I think we could have possibly had a good synergy as scum. MS because he joined this game because of me.
I thought it was safe because I figured me, you, Sonic were going to be on most people's recruit shortlists, and I assumed his reasoning would be something along the lines of play ability, but I'm now informed that assumption wasn't correct.
"Playing with Nacho is like playing with a religious conservative." ~UncertainKitten
-- Fate, Vanilla Townie, was brutally stabbed by a throwing sword in endgame.
metal always talks about how he wants to be scum with me again
but then i guess he could be scum if he was recruited
and i'm not about to let him get away with another game of this shit
"The brains in its two heads appear to communicate emotions to each other with a telepathic power."
in team mafia he did the same whole "post a lot in sequence bc hahaha this spam and trolling is typical ms and i dont want to lose this game by mislynching him bc thats way too easy to do" (it's no)
"The brains in its two heads appear to communicate emotions to each other with a telepathic power."
