Mini 1907: Oddrole Mafia IV (Game over)

[Chickadee]

If you think that podo was the only goo, and that the goo is eliminated now, then how does that change his sticking up for snarky yesterday? Podo would have had to not be goo at that point, because he had information about snarky. Goo have no information. He's the only goo we've seen die, therefor there must still be goo.

EBWOP
Autocorrect really does not like podo's name. Changes it every time.

[Almost50]

Good catch, Chicka.

VOTE: Creature

I think THIS is the goo guy. His play D2 is super strange.

So this is literally the "you better not die as town" game.

This was the first thing he posted in response to the opening post by the mod.

Then we talk and lay ideas and some vote/unvote people, and all he has to say is:

It must suck to be town and die when there's a black goo around.

He even was the one who had the answer to my question to the mod:

Black Goo (cult; super-rare; 4+ players): Whenever a player targets you with an action, they will join your cult as another black goo.

And he followed that up with the proposition:

I think we could make the Black Goos claim (if they have more than one) and we all target them.

This sequence of posts lead me to believe Creature is actually promoting the cult. He is neglecting everything else.

I could lynch this, or we could all agree NOT to target him tonight and try to lynch Mafia instead. What do you think?

[Creature]

I won't bother black goo hunting for today.

[Creature]

Well, we could lynch mafia instead, they're nearly taking majority.

[Almost50]

I won't bother black goo hunting for today.

Yet you haven't said a single thing outside the Goo subject.

[Almost50]

You know what?

UNVOTE:

I've just realized Goo!Creature will HAVE to side by Town. He can't convert Scum, so his ONLY chance is to get Town to target him to spread and have a majority.

[Almost50]

Town: Desperado, Chickadee, TheBrie
Goo: Creature

Lynch pool: Massive, Snarky, GL, Java

Does anyone thing GL+Massive could be scum together and ended up voting Chicka on their own by the end of D1? If yes, then one of Snarky/Java is scum. If no, then both Snarky & Java are scum. Take your pick.

[Javajoe24]

Did you miss my soft claim A50? I had a question for my three main town reads including yourself I would like an answer to

[Javajoe24]

Also, what makes you put chickadee in the town pool?

[Almost50]

Did you miss my soft claim A50? I had a question for my three main town reads including yourself I would like an answer to

Oh. I forgot. It's not a conclusive Town Role, but I don't see the scum!motive behind the claim.

OK.. that leaves me with massive, GL & SS.

And no.. I don't think you should out who got the BP. That would only help Scum plan their NK.

[Almost50]

As for Chicka, I TR'd her from D1 and I don't see anything scummy in her ISO. If you have something precise to point out I'd be obliged.

[Chickadee]

A50, you accuse Creature of focusing a lot on the good, but you also seem to be talking a lot about the goo today. Focusing on the good does us no good, and I find it really anti-town to keep focusing on it. We have no leads and we'll just be running in circles trying to find it.

I agree Creature's play D2 has been weird though.


Town: Brie and snarky. That much I know for sure right now.

[Almost50]

@Chicka: Who would you be willing to lynch between GL & massive?

[Almost50]

In fact, forget I mentioned their names. Who would you be willing to lynch? Period.

[eagerSnake]

VC 2.03

Chickadee (2) [L-3]: Desperado, GuiltyLion

Not Voting (7): TheBrie, SnarkySnowman, Creature, Almost50, Javajoe24, Chickadee, Chickadee

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Day 2 deadline in (expired on 2017-06-03 16:50:45).

[Almost50]

And while agree trying to "find" the goo -if existent- is anti-town at this point, developing a strategy to counter it is not. At least I'm not promoting the idea of deliberately targeting it and giving up on my Town win con.

[TheBrie]

If creature is goo, then we still have no reason for Podo defending Snarky. If anyone is goo, it's got to be Snarky.

Creature certainly hasn't been useful though and his play has been a little odd. He's not making it into my town pool.

Massive never seemed very scummy. Before his slightly odd vote on Chickadee I'd gotten and odd vibe form him, but on examination couldn't find anything to found it on.

Chick, I'm really uncertain about. I'm not putting her as town.

Guilty gave me a towny impression, but I'm certain enough to stick to it.

[TheBrie]

@Chick, what's your opinion of Desperado as CPR Trainer and A50 as Trainee?
Based on that Desp is def town in my mind and A50 is likely town.
I'm accepting Java's claim of a tracking role as town confirmation.

[Chickadee]

And while agree trying to "find" the goo -if existent- is anti-town at this point, developing a strategy to counter it is not. At least I'm not promoting the idea of deliberately targeting it and giving up on my Town win con.

You were the one to suggest it though.

@Chick, what's your opinion of Desperado as CPR Trainer and A50 as Trainee?
Based on that Desp is def town in my mind and A50 is likely town.
I'm accepting Java's claim of a tracking role as town confirmation.

I feel fine saying Desperado as CPR instructor is town.

I don't know about A50. He's seemed to give off town vibes, but there are little things starting to ping me about him. Like how he's calling out creature for goo talk, but doing it a lot himself. It feels a lot like he's trying to steer town away from scum hunting. He's also defending me when no one else is. Could be because he's scum, and therefor knows I'm town, and would get town points when I flip. That gets a bit WIFOM though, so I won't put much stock in that.


I would say right now A50 is probably at the top of my lynch pool.

I mostly just have a few people that are in my NEVER LYNCH!! pool. [brie, snarky, Desperado]

[TheBrie]

Well, A50 is in my certainly don't lynch today pool. Snarky isn't but I'm okay with not lynching him today.

@Creature, bsides you comments about the goo, what do you think of everyone today?

[Chickadee]

Curious why Snarky isn't in your don't lynch pool.

[TheBrie]

I don't have any good proof that Snarky is town. If he's not scum he's likely goo. So he's certainly not the best lynch, but not the worst either.

What do you think of Creature, Chick?

[Chickadee]

I've been conflicted about creature. I'm inclined to lean town on Creature though, because he's been invested. He's been posting. That's good for town!creature.

He's also been really really weird. But that not out of the ordinary for him.

[TheBrie]

If I decided to believe Chick and take Creature and Snarky both as town, while simultaneously hanging onto A50 as town, I'm left with Guilty and Massive as scum. I was leaning town on Guilty and I'm pretty null on Massive. Since there's three scum, there's at lewst one problem there.

I'm thinking A50 is town because there's little scum motive in clearing Desperado as town. Though if he were scum, he might be afraid of being outed as scum if he didn't. Because Desp could have confirmed with someone else.

[GuiltyLion]

prodge, will catchup and post content tomorrow