Open 329: Mayo Clinic D3: Town WINS!

[Quilford]

VC now please, mod

[Quilford]

I lulzed pretty hard at that flavour

Divided on this issue tbqh

[Quilford]

A scum is a scum is a scum.

VOTE: neil1113

[Quilford]

A scum is a scum is a scum.

VOTE: neil1113

So you'd rather just eliminate me here, instead of using me for the benefit of the town? And that's pro-town playing in your opinion?

I don't see how you're any benefit.


Izak's probably also scum guys. (p4)

[Quilford]

I'm a doc.

[Quilford]

Let's lynch actual mafia today, actually:

VOTE: izakthegoomba

[Quilford]

izak's odd hyperbole and extensive theory discussion, as well as fluffing throughout the game makes me think he's scum

[Quilford]

whisper's plan is pretty good actually

if I understand it correctly we could end up with scum at the end of the night -- or we could end up with a guarantee of one confirmed innocent between two people

the plan also works if neil is the mafia doctor

VOTE: neil1113

[Quilford]

it works best if he's the mafia doctor

it works equally well if he's goon or sk

either way HE'S SCUM SO WE SHOULD BE LYNCHING HIM >:(

[Quilford]

1.

Glowball

2.

Mega*

Quilford

3.

pinkfloyd

GreyICE

4. PiggyGal15

5. izakthegoomba

6.

BBmolla

7. VitaminR

8.

Thomith

9. Maruchan

10.

Quaroath

11. neil1113

(will be dead)

12. whispersilk

Vigs are underlined.

Everyone should protect the player directly above them on the playerlist, excluding people who have been italicised WHO SHOULD PROTECT THE PLAYER THREE SPACES ABOVE THEM (12 is above 1).

If you still can't understand that:
#6 and #10 are vigilantes.
#1 protects #9
#2 protects #1
#3 protects #2
#4 protects #3
#5 protects #4
#7 protects #6
#8 protects #5
#9 protects #8
#12 protects #10.

Vigs shoot out of the pool of #1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 8, 9. Thus these seven people should be the people we all consider to be most scummy.

[Quilford]

Guys we need to come to a consensus on who we think the TWO TOWNIEST NON-VIG PLAYERS are.

[Quilford]

I personally wouldn't be surprised if Izak and Thomith were scum but whateverrrrr

[Quilford]

I think that's a bad plan.

[Quilford]

I think that's a bad plan.

wouldn't it be town motivated to point out why so we can fix it before we go into night?

It was a mistake in my maths; carry on.

But I don't like your use of 'town motivated'.

[Quilford]

Follow these night 1 actions if neil was the Serial Killer:

Spoiler:

Vigilantes:

Quoaroth:

Randomly pick a doctor from docs #1-4 and target them for your kill.

BBmolla:

Randomly pick a player from docs #5-7 OR Quoaroth and target them for your kill.

Your targets must be completely random for this plan to work. Do not be tempted to pick the obv target. BB, do not be scared to target Quoaroth. If he dies, we have confirmed scum.

#1 Izak
#2 PiggyGal
#3 VitaminR
#4 Maruchan

#5 Thomith
#6 greyIce
#7 Quilford

Vigilante Doctors:

whispersilk

must protect

BBmolla

glowball

must protect

Quoaroth

Doctors:

#1 Izak:

must protect

PiggyGal

#2 PiggyGal:

must protect

VitaminR

#3 VitaminR:

must protect

Maruchan

#4 Maruchan:

must protect

Thomith

#5 Thomith:

must protect

greyIce

#6 greyIce:

must protect

Quilford

#7 Quilford:

must protect

Izak

If any of the doctors on the train are killed, then the player(s) that was supposed to be protecting them is confirmed scum and should be lynched. If two scum are found on night 1, then one is to be lynched, and the other is to be left unprotected on night 2, and BOTH vigs target him. Should that happen, then vigs are to remain protected, and all docs on the train protect each other. A new train will have to be made accounting for the 2 vigged players (I say "players" because there is always the chance that one of them could be a goon), and if any of them should be killed night 2, then obviously the person who was supposed to be protecting them is scum too and should be lynched day 2. Unlikely the last scum would out themselves like that, but you never know. Weirder things have happened.

If no docs are killed during night 1, then both docs that were protecting the targets are confirmed docs and should be put on vig protect duty for night 2. Either myself or glowball will likely be dead, so whichever one of us is not dead is removed from vig protect duty and slotted into the doc train.

Scum hunting can proceed during day 2, but if there are confirmed docs from night 1

THEY MUST NOT BE LYNCHED

. Lynch targets must come from the doc train only. If someone is going to be lynched then the doc train will need to be re-ordered to take that into account and posted before night 2 falls so that everyone knows who they are protecting and the vigs know who to target. The doc train will need to be split again so that there is a pool for BBmolla to choose from, and a pool for Q to choose from.

From night 2 onwards: Both vigs must include the other vig in their pool when targeting someone. This is very important. The confirmed docs can be tested this way. If one of them is the scum doc, and he/she chances protecting a goon on the train, then he/she will be caught.

THE POSSIBILITY THAT THE VIGS WILL TARGET EACH OTHER RANDOMLY MUST BE VIABLE. VIGS: DO NOT BE SCARED TO TARGET ONE ANOTHER INSTEAD OF SOMEONE ON THE DOC TRAIN.

The same nightly actions should be taken on night 3/4, with alterations being made to the doc train as necessary depending on deaths/lynches.

If after night 2 no goons are found, then there will be 4 confirmed docs: the two protecting the vigs, and the two from night 2. The 2 from night 2 should separate from the main doc train and protect each other, but the vigs should still be able to target them during the night in case one of them is the scum doc and he/she gets some funny idea about not protecting the doc he is supposed to be protecting.

Once both goons are found: All remaining docs cease protecting each other, and split into two groups and each group of docs all protect one vig. The vigs then shoot 2 docs each night depending on who they suspect is the scum doc. Rinse and repeat until the scum doc is found.

Link to original plan post is here.

Follow these night 1 actions if neil was NOT the Serial Killer:

Spoiler:

Vigilantes:

BBmolla:

Randomly pick either VitaminR or Izak and target them for your kill.

Quoaroth:

Randomly pick a doctor from the list below and target them for your kill.

glowball
Maruchan
PiggyGal
Quilford
Thomith
greyIce

Your targets must be completely random for this plan to work. Do not be tempted to pick the obv target.

Doctors:

Izak:

must protect

BBmolla

VitaminR:

must protect

BBmolla

whispersilk:

must protect

Quoaroth

glowball:

must protect

Quoaroth

Maruchan:

must randomly protect either

whispersilk OR glowball

PiggyGal:

must protect

Maruchan

Quilford:

must protect

PiggyGal

Thomith:

must protect

Quilford

greyIce:

must protect

Thomith

Possible outcomes and what they indicate:

• BB's kill is successful = targets flipped town doc, goon, or scum doc
  
• BB's kill is unsuccessful = target is most likely SK and should be lynched the following day
  
• Quoaroth targets someone on the train and that kill is unsuccessful = suggests that his target was protected by a real doctor, but also could indicate that his target is the SK. Result is useless and should be ignored.
  
• Quoaroth targets someone on the train and that kill is successful (target flipped town) = the doc that was supposed to be protecting his target is either a goon or SK and they should be lynched the next day or vigged if there is another target to be lynched.
  
• Quoaroth targets someone on the train and that kill is successful (target flipped goon) = the doc that was supposed to be protecting his target is either the other goon or SK and they should be lynched the next day or vigged if there is another target to be lynched.
  
• Quoaroth targets someone on the train and that kill is successful (target flipped mafia doc) = the doc that was supposed to be protecting his target is either a goon or SK and they should be lynched the next day or vigged if there is another target to be lynched.
  
• If the last doc on the train (unprotected) is not killed during the night = possible indication they are scum and they should replace into BB's pool.
  
• If the un-targeted doc in BB's pool is not killed during the night = possible indication they are scum and they should remain in BB's pool.
  
  The plan should be repeated on night 2, with the next doc up on the train replacing into BB's pool. If there are targets to be vigged at night (scum/SK results from N1) then both vigs should be double protected and should target them.
  
  This plan might have to be modified depending on what happens during the night.

This plan is what we are doing.

Someone hammer neil, kthx

[Quilford]

Scum need a roleblocker, definitely.

[Quilford]

Follow these night 2 actions:

Spoiler:

Vigilantes:

Quoaroth:

Randomly pick a doctor from docs #1-2 OR BBmolla and target them for your kill.

BBmolla:

Randomly pick a player from docs #3-4 OR Quoaroth and target them for your kill.

Your targets

must be completely random

for this plan to work. Do not be tempted to pick the obv target. BB, Quaroath, do not be scared to target each other. If you die, we have confirmed scum.

#1 Izak
#2 Maruchan

#3 Thomith
#4 glowball

Vigilante Doctors:

GreyICE

must protect

BBmolla

Quilford

must protect

Quoaroth

Doctors:

#1 Izak:

must protect

Maruchan

#2 Maruchan:

must protect

Izak

#3 Thomith:

must protect

glowball

#4 glowball:

must protect

Thomith

Any problems?

[Quilford]

Hoopla, I think adding a factional strongman and/or roleblocking ability fix this.

[Quilford]

Uh, Toasty?

Night actions, please.

[Quilford]

I think Goon and 2x RB is best.

[Quilford]

Only if they claim.

[Quilford]

make all 3 scum doctors, but make it so that if scum is protected by scum doctor and town doctor they lose all protections (even if multiple town doctors on them).

I endorse this product and/or service.

How was the scum doc killed N2?

[Quilford]

Quilford technically disappeared for about two days of the events in the hospital. Its rumored he's attempting to start the hospital up again--well, if he ever gets around to waking up.

So apparently I star in Inception?

[Quilford]

Man, that is a fail.