Mini 1749: Classic Rock Mafia: Game Over!

[Firebringer]

Yo guys, 20 pages so far?

Not bad, I guess I can start reading up.

[Firebringer]

Okay all of RCs vote counts are going to completely distract me, I read and then stop and play the videos and listen to music.

BAD MOD!

[Firebringer]

lol! FBBBBBBBBBBB *love*

[Firebringer]

Okay only 4 pages in and I got scum pings from Aeronaut.

This seems like how he was in the Flower Festival game I replaced into for him when he was scum.
Hey Aero we have any completed games together?

[Firebringer]

I am in fact an extremely Normal Person playing as part of this Normal Game.

This is a lie, no one is "normal"

[Firebringer]

I don't like Taly's vote. I don't like Dwlee's posts before replacing out. I don't like Mathilda delaying an unvote on MattP. Stop playing games, guys. We should lynch radja, Taly, or Firebringer.

I am having flash backs to the WC3 game...

[Firebringer]

I'll just say FB for convenience then. But I feel like I'm talking about Facebook.... o_o...

I will direct you to a link of facebook each time you say "FB"

[Firebringer]

I am drunk, whats going on everyone. Who wants to talk right now.

I still haven't caught up with the thread, but I want to try to sort some players out and figure shit out.

[Firebringer]

Hey FA, whats your opinion on Aeronaut?

[Firebringer]

No. Chop his head off.

No mercy.

Let's be extreme.

This is really not like you at all AI.

Meta wise, this seems scummy.

[Firebringer]

Happy drunk day!

MATTP!!!!! WHATS UP!!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?

I WILL FOLLOW YOU FOR TODAY! Or w/e.

Who is your primary scum read? Town read?

[Firebringer]

Whats your thoughts on Aeronaut?

[Firebringer]

I think he's fine, why?

I just got this vibe from first few pages taht I actually read that he was playing this exactly like the flower festival where he was scum.

[Firebringer]

I think dwlee was the scummiest slot but I know ds pretty well so I going to watch him carefully. Tbh I haven't looked at dier and his wagon at all since I been focused on what jumped out to me as scummy.

Can you explain why you are scum reading my slot?

[Firebringer]

Also, hey Garmr, whats up?

[Firebringer]

I can't post anything till tomorrow, my internet is out because my apartment flooded >.>

[Firebringer]

I'm skeptical that Frozen's viewpoint only comes from a Mafia player there. I don't want to lynch her.
I find Mathilda's reaction to her wagon slightly Town-motivated. I would prefer that she do a little more digging into which players are Mafia but I'm comforted by the fact that she wasn't too upset with the prospect of being lynched.
I still like my vote on Iraonavp but after that I'm having difficulty reading people as Mafia. I think that I should revisit some of the inactive players; Firebringer has been quiet and Dwlee didn't stand out as remarkably different from his previous games as Mafia, so that's another good place to look.
Davesaz had a good entrance and I continue to like that slot for an actual Miller.

I have been quiet because of real life stuff, anyways. Whats your thoughts on Aeronaut and IamInnocent?

[Firebringer]

5 scum reads, sorry. He's still considering FA as a chance for scum. Too many avenues left open for future lynches.

Or possibility that he just honestly sees that many players acting like scum?
I don't think scum play like that normally.

[Firebringer]

I knew that's what he was!

Can we just hammer and not wait out this replacement I want to move on with my life

No.

Also your new avatar sucks.

[Firebringer]

VOTE: Mathilda
Iron tommorow since won't get today

Bad Gamr, bad.

[Firebringer]

Also your new avatar sucks.

Youre a bully

I don't completely disagree with this statement.

[Firebringer]

I think your slots scum dazzle me

I don't have a strong read on you, wanna talk about it?

Cause I don't see why my slot is scum. I have yet to read my slots previous posts though.

[Firebringer]

Scum have more scum reads so they can push more. An easy way to spot town is find someone posting town reads, keeping the town reads as town and being consistent with those reads. Scum are more affluent in null or conditionally town players and tend to leave doors open for different wagons by having more scum reads. Perfect? No. But definitely something that happens consistently enough to be noticed.

I don't know about that, but I think scum do like to opportunistic read players by the mood of the game.

[Firebringer]

Like your new avatar weird?

[Firebringer]

The scum radiation of Mathilda is starting to reach the boundaries of the universe.

Posts like this are really odd.

[Firebringer]

OK guys, I know I was wrong about Mathilda. But there was a majority of us voting her, so that makes us all responsible. Those that weren't on the wagon weren't exactly defending her either. The only explanation is that she just might have played in such a scummy way that it glitched all our scumdars. Let's get back to work and lynch scum today.

Why does this sound like you are preparing for a mislynch flip?

[Firebringer]

Sorry to hear about your apartment being flooded Firebringer, do you live in the UK? There's a lot of flooding going on here at the moment.

I live in America, I got my internet back up and running is the good news!
But it sounds like they are going to have to put me in a hotel or something as they start breaking down walls, because the water got in there >.>

Not looking forward to that.

[Firebringer]

you should try it

Try what?

[Firebringer]

Yeah, and you are filling Dwlee's scum slot, right?

Your point?

[Firebringer]

Apparently I can't read at 4 in the morning.
I am going to sleep.

[Firebringer]

oO FB claimed scum??

I am always scum FA, didn't you know?

[Firebringer]

He pushed someone and that someone definitely SLIPPED that he is scum! it doesn't matter what was AI's motives there. FB said He is Scum ! fortunately it was 4 am and his brain couldn't stop him from denying that he is scum !

FB who saw what is happening tried to troll and blaming the time!

Lets lynch the scum

Thats not what happened at all lol, but okay. Someone put a tin foil hat on FA.

[Firebringer]

Guys are we close to deadline or something. I have been semi neglecting this game, and I apologize for that.

[Firebringer]

Who are you going to vote for? You are currently still voting for me (inherited from Dwlee's slot). Are you going to keep it this way or what?

I don't know why thats still there >.>

I would like to get a train going on my number one scum read Aeronaut:
VOTE: Aeronaut

Lets do this guys, we got time.

[Firebringer]

VOTE: AlwaysInnocent

This is a very, very safe bet for scum along with dier.

Really with dier? Seems like a weird combo

[Firebringer]

I'm still suspicious of AJ and Frozen. But Dave needs a serious look into.

Frozen is the most towniest town in townsville.

[Firebringer]

Do you still think Aeronaut is scum? If not, who?

Yes, Aeronaut is scum, not sure on any other scum.

[Firebringer]

No. Bad fire.

Can you explain why Aero is town here?
I don't see it.

[Firebringer]

@ABR

I think Dave is scum guys.

Why? I was thinking that the Miller claim becomes more believable when a Cop has flipped.

@AJ

AlwaysInnocent is Town, he's just overconfident and misguided (a dangerous combination).

@AlwaysInnocent

You look overconfident and misguided to me (a dangerous combination). I would like you to reconsider your read on me.

VOTE: Firebringer

If Aero is Mafia then why not vote for him?

Good point:

VOTE: Aeronaut

[Firebringer]

So this is your scum game.

My scum game is like my town game.
BTW haven't you played with me when I was scum?

I swear, the micro with soren?

[Firebringer]

Yes, I remember it. I had you pinned by the hammer but you killed me. I replaced in, too...

I drifted in and out of Reckoner's game where you were scum and I pointed out the antagonistic similarities between the two games but died to that dumb vig. However, you have a lack of reads for scum outside this one but make a mistake to not vote? I think town-you leads the vote immediately whereas this seemed like testing the water on a somewhat unpopular read.

I haven't seen your tell-tale antagonistic qualities yet and that coupled with the fact that AI is far and away more significantly scum (and probably even getting some coaching right now) is going to save me from pushing a wagon there right now.

Yeah, one of my offsite buddies read that game, he was super impressed by you.
Good games.

Wait...I have tell tale on antagonism? Thats kind of depressing.

[Firebringer]

so like no one is interested in the fact I have day chat now with a potential scum power role ok then.

Thats cool Garmr.
How you doing mate!!?!?!?

[Firebringer]

Ok, I was unsure about Dwlee because I felt more like he was just a new player but Firebringer is p bad today/yesterday.

Your face is bad.

Also I have a case on you. Its called gut.
Way to try to discredit my feels though.

Won't work on me. This is definitely your scum game bro.

[Firebringer]

So is Firebringer trolling or like is this shit real?

I don't troll.

I just don't care enough to post a case on you. I am hoping others will read your ISO and come to same conclusion.

[Firebringer]

Alright, fine, we can play this way.

Can you tell me about other scum reads you have? Or town reads?

Always Innocent strikes me as very different this game than other games, gives me a scum feel.

Diefire and Frozen are my strongest town reads.

Rest have not given me strong reads either way.

[Firebringer]

VOTE: Dierfire

VOTE: Dierfire

I'll take it, I guess.

Bad votes are bad.

[Firebringer]

they aren't bad at all, because this will take a scum down.

>.>

Come on Aj talk to me. Why is Die scum?

[Firebringer]

Well at this point of the game I'm lost I can see two sides starting to form and I don't know which side has the most scum on it.

Probably the one voting one Die.

[Firebringer]

And by this, I mean that policy lynching should almost never happen, unless that player is literally being so stupid that the town can't move forward otherwise.

Which makes FB lynch tempting, but he's just kind of off by himself being stubborn, so idc really

Hold on, you saying I am town for this?
Its not a policy lynch if you scum read me dude.

This is scummy shit.

[Firebringer]

VOTE: Firebringer

I'm sorry but you are scum this time.

Would also like to mention that when dwlee replaced out he signed up for another game. Which makes me believe it was a tactical replace out.

I also really don't trust aj the epic for some reason.

I honestly think you are misguided here Garmr, and think you probably are town, I don't really care what dwlee did before in this game. Talk to me.

Get a read from me.

Do you think I am truly scum?

[Firebringer]

No, I'm saying that I don't know that it's alignment indicative.

Although you are providing almost nothing of value to this game.

Thats bullshit, I have been giving thoughts since I replaced in, if anything its you who hasn't given much to this game.

When I first read first few pages of game i got a scum taste, and since then you haven't done anything to change my mind. You don't seem to be hunting scum at all.

[Firebringer]

From you alone I don't get a scum read but dwlee man was extremely scummy I can't shake the scum off.

If you think I am scum push me. You will come to see you are wrong either way.

[Firebringer]

You haven't done anything to erase the scummy that Dwlee left is what we're saying.

Seems like a lazy read to me.
Then again, I still haven't read the whole game, so w/e

[Firebringer]

FB

don't deny that your scum in this game Its kind of obvious!

What? I still haven't heard your case on me FA, besides my "slip" seriously, you are my strongest town read and its annoying for you to be scumreading me for these stupid reasons.

[Firebringer]

What are your current reads FB ? can you categorize them for me?

Right now you and die are up there as far as town.
ABR looks opportunistic as hell with his vote. He notices a wagon forming on me and decides this is the time to jump on?

Yeah, thats scummy.

[Firebringer]

Does it still look opportunistic after you read his earlier vote on you? He was the second vote on your wagon, then he removed his vote (by placing it on me) after two others joined, and now it's back on (the fifth vote now that Garmr joined).

Thats why it is opportunistic. He saw momentum on you, so he switched to you, then saw that going my way, went my way.

He will vote wherever he sees a mislynch happening. Almost as bad as Aeronaut.

[Firebringer]

But in all serious ness page top is a illusion

The page top is just an illusion......Am I real Garmr?

Is this site real?

OMG I AM FREAKING OUT!!!

[Firebringer]

Yea, but you just keep saying this vague-ass shit. Like ABR said, all you're doing is saying "you guy are bad!" instead of like, "here's my reasoning for stuff! Here's a logical thought process!"

And all your doing is saying my reasoning is bad.

So I guess we both are flawed mate.

[Firebringer]

No, I'm not saying you're reasoning is bad, I'm saying you're pushing me without giving any reasoning whatsoever. You know that saying "Oh I think Aero is scummy because he gives me scum vibes", you clearly aren't trying to push a real case on anything. It's just you being busy.

Yeah, I gave you reasoning. Your acting as of late has made me question my original thoughts on you.....

I don't know, your entrance and up until day 2, was basically giving me red flags.

UNVOTE: Aeronaut

[Firebringer]

Fire, what are your thoughts on Dier?

Ridiculously bad, and the fact so many people want to push him says to me based on the mood of the game scum are trying to get him lynched.

[Firebringer]

VOTE: I am Innocent[/vote]

This is where we should be voting.

[Firebringer]

VOTE: I am Innocent

So you townread Aero, I didn't think I heard you make any read on him.

[Firebringer]

That's because you are too lazy to read anything.

I get insulted all the time, I have build up a tolerance for people shitting on me.

Come back with original material.

[Firebringer]

@Firebringer

VOTE: I am Innocent

I don't think that this player is in this game.

VOTE: Always Innocent

Ehh, his name is close to that.

[Firebringer]

I would like to point out that one more vote is required to lynch Firebringer.

I don't think we should hammer yet since it's early in the day.

I think someone say intent and hammer.

[Firebringer]

Why do you think that?

several reasons.

[Firebringer]

Are you perhaps frustrated at how you, an obviously town-aligned player, has been strung up so quickly and efficiently?
Are you perhaps eager to put the game behind you after you are brutally and unjustly mislynched?
Are you perhaps wanting to prove wrong all those arrogant fools who once doubted that you were town-aligned?

Why did you write the same question three times in a row?

Yes to all the above.

[Firebringer]

Iron I hate your posting style, stop being a robot and act like a human so I can get a read on you.

[Firebringer]

Iron I hate your posting style, stop being a robot and act like a human so I can get a read on you.

Yeah, okay, nice to know. All you're saying is just that you don't like my playstyle, like, cool story, I hate yours too.

Really getting sick of this bullshit but fine. Let's play it your way since you're throwing a tantrum.

I'm so frustrated at everyone! Why is everyone not seeing things from my perspective, they're all ignorant fools. I can't play with people like this, it's not possible.

/replace out

Sorry mod, I just can't handle the stupidity in this thread.

Actually wait, I just said that in a moment of frustration, I'm feeling better now, don't worry.

/replace in

Yeah, now you are acting like a asshole.
Good work, you are one more step to becoming a real human being that I can relate too.

I like how you take subtle jabs at me in this post, very well done.

I approve.

[Firebringer]

Yeah, okay, nice to know. All you're saying is just that you don't like my playstyle, like, cool story, I hate yours too.

Really getting sick of this bullshit but fine. Let's play it your way since you're throwing a tantrum.

I'm so frustrated at everyone! Why is everyone not seeing things from my perspective, they're all ignorant fools. I can't play with people like this, it's not possible.

Frustration is part of being human.
Anger is part of being human.
Annoyed is part of being human.

Be sincere, don't take the emotion out of your posts, because thats how I scum hunt and you don't enable me to hunt.

I try to see if people are sincere with their emotions in a game, because I can be emotional and much of this game is about getting inside of a players mind.

When you act like a complete robot, its just a game of "If x is true than y" that isn't mafia to me. That is just logic, and the game of mafia isn't all logic.

[Firebringer]

Don't hammer Firebringer yet. What the fuck are you doing?

We have 10+ days! Hammering now is anti-town.

Way to point out the obvious.

[Firebringer]

yeah

which is so real that if FB flip red I can't hold myself from voting you ...

This post is terrible

[Firebringer]

If mod allows me time I would like to post a final reads list.
Can't right now since phone posting.

By the way, where was the intent FA that was terrible.

[Firebringer]

basically you were intended since you reached L1 and It was obvious ...

Well I am a Even night cop.

Town is completely screwed.

[Firebringer]

Well I'm the 1 shot bullet proof body guard. Looks like I have no targets to protect so yeh.

If your srs they going to attack you and tomorrow is LYLO

[Firebringer]

Frozen Angel carrying hard. Nice job.

Still think that buss on me by both of you was bad >.>