This slot should not have scumreads.
I'm not sure why he's been jumped on for voting for an unannouced L-1 vote, that seems perfectly reasonable to me and I can follow what he's thinking. And he's definitely not flailing at all when he's defending it, what he's saying makes sense.
I think scum have a pressure to say things day 1 and it takes guts and some townyness to stick to your principles and not post things day 1 unless you feel the need to as they alluded to in 132. Also, the way they said they are a defensive player makes me want to believe them, and I do. The fact that this is their first game in 5 years is annoying, though, beacuse it means I can't research their past games. Their vote on Stitch is perfect, and they had the same thought as me that the way Stitch went about voting them was fake and forced. I don't understand the fact that Stitch thinks they are flailing, and "pointing Steph in another direction" is high quality bullshit. And the fact Seph pointed out they could do it for UC Voyager too is very correct.
I like the tone, it's very defensive and more importantly
Town are much more likely to call people jerks. Just a part of the game. Getting into emotionall arguements this early is a reason to town-read them.
342 alone should convince people he's town, it's one of the single most towny individual posts in the game.
The anger over pro-town and over the gamestate is towny as well.
Overall: Strong town