VOTE: themilkcartonkid
bet you rolled scum this time <3
![Laughing :lol:](./images/smilies/icon_lol2.gif)
~ the duck
<3 I like the hydra of Teeky & CheekyIn post 21, CheekyTeeky wrote:Booducks is a cool hydra.
In post 27, CheekyTeeky wrote:I think this is either TvS or SvS.In post 13, Lady Angel wrote:Lynch all liars?In post 6, Lady Angel wrote:Hello everyone. Who wants to come over for tea?
I dislike both their page 1 posting.
First I don't like Robert saying they'll vote someone until they post - it's a thinly veiled fake pressure vote. Then I don't like the immeadiate unvote after Lady calls him a liar. If he was pressure voting to get the game going why isn't he moving his vote elsewhere to get more people to post? The unvote in this instance is scummy.
Angel is less scummy but I dislike her asking "lynch all liars?" instead of commenting on whether being a liar is AI for Robert.
Original ping was probably just because the "first" type comments are a pet peeve of mine, but the scummy part was the cheeky vote and unvote.In post 61, skitter30 wrote:why darklight?
I think this comes from town but also I don't think it's a particularly great way to find scumIn post 71, Trivium wrote:Going that deep feels fake. If you're seriously developing a scumread off of people's RVS posts you're fooling yourself, if you're not you're scum. That's what you get out of rvs, people's indirect reactions to it that gets the game going, you don't analyse the content of the rvs posts themselves.In post 49, DuckDuckJab wrote:Trivium sweaty would you rather we dwell in rvs forever? You're voting someone for trying to advance the game. the queues for mafia and "circularly shitpost for two weeks at a time for no reason" are in different parts of the forum
Try again. If you think part of her post is scummy point it out and talk about why it's scummy (I'd be very curious about this). Don't shade her categorically for making a reachy read to get the game going because I don't see you trying.
~ the duck
What kind of answer are you expecting...? serious question lmaoIn post 57, themilkcartonkid wrote:I dont buy this... the town description mentions other wincons being impossible for us to win. This def some sort of scum or 3p. VOTE: almost50In post 54, Almost50 wrote:I believe I've mixed my games.. AGAIN. I thought this one was NIGHTLESS! *Sigh*In post 46, DuckDuckJab wrote:I thought getting nightkilled was your favorite thing?
I sure need to stop playing too many games and with too many accounts.
...why?In post 83, themilkcartonkid wrote:Why did he actually say there was no nk. I mean, hes not going to come right out and say it, but theres no way this isn't scum
What does this post even mean famIn post 130, Soviet Crocolisk wrote:Robert does seem defensive with his post but I feel it's rather honest. It's day one, so it can be pretty intimidating for newer players to vote when they know no one. I think this as either a town or scum read.
I'm going toVOTE: CHEEKYfor punching down.
I'm in the mood for itGamma Emerald wrote:Ducky why are you voting so much
Who's town?In post 133, Soviet Crocolisk wrote:No other scummy reads so far.
I feel like your vote on a easy low hanging fruit, and that's pretty scummy.
So you voted her to pressureIn post 146, Soviet Crocolisk wrote:Mm, that's fine. I think your thoroughly offended tone is genuine and I don't think that's sunny
Unvote:
NoIn post 152, Thor665 wrote:In post 120, Almost50 wrote:I know you're asking for accounts. You know 3 of my personal accounts already. Anything more may or may not be relevant to anything I may or may not have said. Thank you very much for being attentive.![]()
You're claiming you don't see Cheeky's 10 or so posts in response to Crocolisk's vote to be pressure related?
leaning town but only leaning atmIn post 172, skitter30 wrote:@tw how are you reading cheeky?
we have time, I'm not feeling normal in this game for some reasonIn post 172, skitter30 wrote:i'm not really feeling town!you yet; you feel kinda weird for you
Why are you okay with Robert here and what do you make of Cheeky+me voting him first?
Meant to quote this one tooIn post 177, joges wrote:Page 4
I suffer from good gut reads sometimes as well (I recall you correctly picking that I was softpocketing you in that one newbie game) but A50 is a nightmare to gutread, he reads more agendaey as town than scum. take that how you willIn post 181, themilkcartonkid wrote:yes on this, but I'm a sucker for big ISO posts. I still do not like A50's post at all. I have a crackpot theory that my first serious vote is always scum and it hasn't been wrong in the three whole games I've played!
Uhh I think I might need to hear some less angleshooty reads from you because I'm not townreading a single syllable of this reasoning and your original vote was creepyIn post 182, Thor665 wrote:He did an interesting slip that might be alingment relevant.
He declared it was an innocent error due to another game he's in.
We can't discuss ongoing games.
We can ask for accounts.
I can do my own research about ongoing games with certain info without needing to discuss them.
He's aware of this and is being oddly cagey in his responses to me - I suspect because he's aware.
Sheep me?
Good vote.
I'll second thisIn post 187, skitter30 wrote:eh, i like to imagine i can fake posts like that as scum
Also towny
If you wanna talk more about this hmu, that was my partner's rvs ping (I had an absolutely different rvs ping and we agreed to discuss you at more length later).In post 200, DarkLightA wrote:...which is on page 1-2. This doesn't even need commenting. If DDJ is this good at creating things out of nothing he should consider taking up a career as a magician. And then on top of that he uses a pet peeve to justify a scum case?
This is probably a pretty good point and I'm happy to admit I inadvertently lean scum on Thor most of the time because we have vastly different playstyles (main diff was Gunner Mafia which I'm pretty sure you were there for too? where he was just this tidal wave of towny common sense)In post 202, CheekyTeeky wrote:Thor
Can you throw me a couple of quotes which made you feel this way?In post 203, Robert2424 wrote:Cheeky seem too...go with the flow.
Why new town before new scum? Genuinely curiousIn post 208, themilkcartonkid wrote:I like this as a bad vote by new townIn post 203, Robert2424 wrote:lol, sensitive.
I personally love reading thors posts in thors movie voice. I don't know if I'd be paranoid with him being scum though. or maybe I'm naive with Thor.
Cheeky seem too...go with the flow. Course she may normally be like this.
Vote Cheeky
@Dark, why are you so certain A50 is town?
@cheeky, what lynch do you think Thor wants then?
Whooo wtfIn post 211, CheekyTeeky wrote:{Gamma Emerald, joges}
{Trivium, Thor, Milk}
{Skitter, A50, Lady, Robert}
{}
{DLA or DDJ, Soviet}
Fair. Towncase Joges for me? I'm gonna use the scum word..... heIn post 243, CheekyTeeky wrote:Lol I think Thor gets like that with his fellow man friends. Like I noticed Toranaga brought that out of him. Also that playerlist was OP af.In post 230, DuckDuckJab wrote:where he was just this tidal wave of towny common sense
Talk to me about something more exciting? :3In post 237, DarkLightA wrote:Didn't actually realize yall were a hydra until I hunted down the BuJaber Cheeky mentioned. Whoops!In post 229, DuckDuckJab wrote:If you wanna talk more about this hmu, that was my partner's rvs ping (I had an absolutely different rvs ping and we agreed to discuss you at more length later).In post 200, DarkLightA wrote:...which is on page 1-2. This doesn't even need commenting. If DDJ is this good at creating things out of nothing he should consider taking up a career as a magician. And then on top of that he uses a pet peeve to justify a scum case?
But yeah needless to say I'm not super interested in this read. Crocolisk I'm also keen to come back to a liiiiiittle later
You're probably the wrong person to answer to it then, but my thoughts about the post still stand.
I investigated him n0 and he is aligned with "having a good time"In post 249, Robert2424 wrote:I'm not sure its much of a recovery, I think he's really screwing around more then anything. I can't really take any of his posts seriously.
I haven't decided if I agree with this or not yet but I like your angle I thinkIn post 251, CheekyTeeky wrote:I don't see this kind of observation coming from scum.In post 177, joges wrote:I do not like how long it took for you to vote. I feel this first post is you having an issue with A50's post. But you didn't vote until someone else did. Why were you afraid to start this wagon?
This whole conversation is just like angleshooting which is resolved by A50 answering the question if he chooses to which also he's welcome not toIn post 98, Thor665 wrote:What are your current active accounts?In post 54, Almost50 wrote:I sure need to stop playing too many games and with too many accounts.
VOTE: Almost50
I saw your response, so I won't ask. But I strongly disagree that cheeky is going with the flow here and I'm baffled that you ever thought so.In post 203, Robert2424 wrote:lol, sensitive.
I personally love reading thors posts in thors movie voice. I don't know if I'd be paranoid with him being scum though. or maybe I'm naive with Thor.
Cheeky seem too...go with the flow. Course she may normally be like this.
Vote Cheeky
@Dark, why are you so certain A50 is town?
@cheeky, what lynch do you think Thor wants then?
We are not. But what gave you the idea?In post 207, CheekyTeeky wrote:BuJaber, you scum bro?
This is a very specific read and it feels like TMI to me.In post 208, themilkcartonkid wrote:I like this as a bad vote by new townIn post 203, Robert2424 wrote:lol, sensitive.
I personally love reading thors posts in thors movie voice. I don't know if I'd be paranoid with him being scum though. or maybe I'm naive with Thor.
Cheeky seem too...go with the flow. Course she may normally be like this.
Vote Cheeky
@Dark, why are you so certain A50 is town?
@cheeky, what lynch do you think Thor wants then?
I don't know.. it's purely objective and is easy to notice. What makes it town-exclusive?In post 251, CheekyTeeky wrote:I don't see this kind of observation coming from scum.In post 177, joges wrote:I do not like how long it took for you to vote. I feel this first post is you having an issue with A50's post. But you didn't vote until someone else did. Why were you afraid to start this wagon?
This was me btw.In post 274, DuckDuckJab wrote:@skitter:
I can see your point regarding the unvote when you add it to the other posts he made with the apparent carefree attitude. It read differently to me on its own. As for the carefree thing it may not be a town thing depending on meta/personality. I'll need more time to learn about him. Are you saying it out of experience or is it your first game with him also?
Also this isn't AI for you but I've always wanted to ask why you say things like "you don't seem like town you" without elaborating to people. Don't you think it might give scum!them a chance to change it up?
Bolded indicates that the "first" thing was not in fact scummy in my eyes. It just made me look into you whereas I may have not paid that much attention to you.In post 67, DuckDuckJab wrote:Original ping was probably just because the "first" type comments are a pet peeve of mine,In post 61, skitter30 wrote:why darklight?but the scummy part was the cheeky vote and unvote.
It doesn't seem like an RVS vote because of the timing, so why unvote just becuase cheeky said she's innocent.
And if it was in fact an RVS vote, the unvote makes less sense... did he suddenly get scared?
-BuJ
In post 275, DuckDuckJab wrote:We are not. But what gave you the idea?In post 207, CheekyTeeky wrote:BuJaber, you scum bro?
I don't know.. it's purely objective and is easy to notice. What makes it town-exclusive?In post 251, CheekyTeeky wrote:I don't see this kind of observation coming from scum.In post 177, joges wrote:I do not like how long it took for you to vote. I feel this first post is you having an issue with A50's post. But you didn't vote until someone else did. Why were you afraid to start this wagon?
This felt like a very weird read to me, especially with milk now happy to park his vote on robert. It feels like TMI. Add in the inconsistency of him voting who he called new town. So I'm a little concerned by the milk townreads as they seem premature and misguided to me.In post 208, themilkcartonkid wrote:I like this as a bad vote by new townIn post 203, Robert2424 wrote:lol, sensitive.
I personally love reading thors posts in thors movie voice. I don't know if I'd be paranoid with him being scum though. or maybe I'm naive with Thor.
Cheeky seem too...go with the flow. Course she may normally be like this.
Vote Cheeky
@Dark, why are you so certain A50 is town?
@cheeky, what lynch do you think Thor wants then?
I kinda instinctively dislike anyone stating a conversation between three players which is still completely unresolved looks like t/t/t. Does anyone have a confident read on Triv because I remember strongly disliking something by them and I can't remember if it was alignmenty or notIn post 277, Trivium wrote:thor/duck/a50 looks pretty t/t/t to me. Vote's staying on robert.
Eh this roughly makes sense I think we're just very different peopleIn post 281, Thor665 wrote:Sure
heyIn post 287, skitter30 wrote:hey
hwaht.In post 291, Trivium wrote:Thanks jingle, this is exactly the kind of moderation that keeps me coming back to this site.
Anyways, I would usually be more speculative as town but because there appear to be strange things going on with winconditions I feel I'd rather come back through here when I have more information, so I've really just skimmed through a lot of this, especially the thor/duck/a50 interaction because I don't think the stuff a50 has done or talked about has been alignment indicative at all, and I feel the duck/thor interaction is t/t in my gut. I like my vote on robert; little justification for cheeky vote, questions I don't think lead anywhere, just not really buying the whole going with the flow argument in general. Feels reachy in an intentional sort of way to me.
But why why and whyIn post 320, Lady Angel wrote:Skitter's hard town for me, Cheeky and Trivium also seem towny. I'm still not sure how to sort Almost, the frustration here feels genuine.