on the Maki vs Ice argument: I don't quite understand anyone's perspective in it. Ice claiming bulletproof early is NAI any way you slice it, and Maki using it to scumread Ice is stretchy, but doesn't quite make sense for scum!Maki to make such a wild push that doesn't work. I'm slightly bothered by Alisae reading into bad logic, but not reading into motivation. Alisae is generally a slow starter if my perception is accurate, so this strong scumread on maki is quite offputting. I think some of Maki's reactions here are quite towny as she is trying to determine motivation in Ice's hard push on her as scum, and I also like Ice projecting a townread after the t-dome. Still, something a little offputting in everyone here. Gun to my head: both town.
Elizebereth: Two things I like from that slot: Calling me town when I told Mulch to tell Eli I'm town (this is awfully meta related for things I've done that I expect town!mulch to read into correctly, while scum!mulch might act with more cautious than to TMI spew a read), and voting Kaede immediately after this scummy Kaede post:
In post 23, Kaede Akamatsu wrote: In post 13, HardcoreMonkey wrote:I suggest the way mastina approached the neighborhood was scummy. she spoke about calling it a masonry and lock everyone town in it, which strikes me as oddly unsuspicious and the way she spoke about makes me feel she wasn't joking. I think there's a chance mastina was levelling with us to see what our reaction would be, but on it's face it's definitely not how town!anyone would approach neighborhood.
If this is true.
1) She was probably serious.
2) She's probably also town.
which brings me to kaede: I don't like that slot and don't think it's been townie. That post I quoted was the most AI thing Kaede said ITG, because she simply didn't have the necessary information for the strong townread on mastina. Other than that, I don't like the excessive amount of posts spent in the Maki;Ice argument and I feel she has given safe stances on it and didn't push anything herself other than asking Himiko a few times why she is getting townread based off her first post (which I do think is townie).
My stance on mastina hasn't changed, I think she is town and HEM thinks she is scum. I was expecting more from neighborhood chat but it's been quite dead.
Redflavor: didn't do anything this game. as low and hanging as any fruit could possibly be, but I think this response to me in p1 is awkward:
In post 15, RedFlavor wrote:Actually it was RVS but mastina wasn't very unsuspicious
My joke was putting no jokes
the 'mastina wasn't very unsuspicious' is very awkwardly phrased, as if redflavor was trying to say different, opposing things at once. I also don't like how redflavor popped in to say who was in neighborhood without saying anything else about the game. He is also generally a bit more trollish and free flowy than what I'm seeing here.
so those are some reads.