Dont worry dude, I’m not going to ruin your gameIn post 782, xRECKONERx wrote:Welp.
Unless you all want to wake up tomorrow to +25 pages, that probably needs to be lynched on policy (not to mention Majiffy's scumminess before)
Mulch, if your slot is actually town and we're mistaken on Majiffy, I *HIGHLY* recommend you not spam
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile"){kind=icon}
I mean this is probably one of the scummiest posts I've ever seen in my lifeIn post 155, Sir Bastion wrote:People I dont like
Bambiatte Baterbine -nothing rubs me wrong so quickly as a player answering for another player without reason. Its counter productive
LoveBird -oddly a lot of people are town reading them and I am not, null at best but really something feels off over the whole exchange over gif, he's both defending him and dismissing him
so
VOTE: Bombiatte Baterbine
People I like
Alisae: pushing makes me makes happy
Also I have 2 quick mod question
@MOD: Am I right that if town successfully lynch scum and it was a town person who hammered, they gain that scum's 1 shot ability? And secondly is the 1 shot ability made public on death so everybody knows what that ability is and who has it before we go into night?
In post 300, Kokichi Oma wrote:Yet you have me in your town pile? Thanks for admitting that reads list was made up.In post 234, xRECKONERx wrote:bambi i want to die for NAI reasons (i dont really like anime avatar players
VOTE: Reck
Like I said that was more of a "sheep my read after lynch" thing because I didn't expect you to believ eitIn post 793, xRECKONERx wrote:uhhh im not really convinced by "im town and this person made a case against me so they're scum for it"
BullshitIn post 546, Alisae wrote:I wanted to hold out on posting this for a bit, but I feel like I get shot tonight. So if there is a protective, please protect me, but otherwise I'm writing this.
I feel like the game is as easy as {Majiffy, Reck, and one of Lovebird/GiF}. Right now, {Majiffy, Reck, Lovebird} is what makes sense for me currently.
Majiffy is a read that has been explained multiple times in thread, I'm not going over that again on why he's scum. His recent posting doesn't really do much to change this. It DOES support my other reads.
Reck I am scumreading based on play AND it makes a lot of sense to be scum with Majiffy actually. I feel like his timing to vote Majiffy is extremely convienent for a bus. And the way he's pushing Majiffy just seems a lot like a bus to me because for the most part, it covers most if not all of the bussing checklist which is:
[X] Have the partner you are bussing distance from you particularly by fos'ing them (IE Majiffy scumreads Reck and Reck is hardpushing Majiffy. Not to mention a lot of how Majiffy is pushing Reck, makes me think that it is scum distancing from each other)
[X] Hard commitment to the push. (When you hardbus, you can't suddenly get off, you have to commit to the bus. And a lot of how Reck is pushing Majiffy comes across like a bus. This especially shows when it comes to his reaction to Majiffy's recent posting)
[X] The timing works as a bus and because of that, it nets Reck cred (Remember the Bambi wagon had just died down. Scum!Reck could have just continued to try to push Bambi, however when it comes to the late game, it wouldn't get him that far. BUT if he pushes Majiffy here, he can potentially try to get bus cred that will help him out for the late game)
Now when it comes to the Lovebird read, I feel like a lot of their reaction to the wagon feels like scum that got cold feet. They can't defend it, because it makes them look bad. They also don't want to bus it for some reason. Like, 528 comes off to me as not really knowing what to do. It also doesn't really come across as a defense that was naturally formed.
GiF is also mostly here because the doublevote seems towny but just don't townread him for that please?
Hi Alisae
For alisae it makes them scum. They are a super comptent town player that relies on meta and intricacies and genuineness to make reads. They also are much better than to think "fluff posting=scum"In post 809, GuyInFreezer wrote:So exactly what part of this makes anyone scum?In post 806, Mulch wrote:that you would make a day 1 case on someone for fluff posting
(town)
and be town
Can you explain why you think it's my scum meta? Because I've heard you almost time and time again say you don't know my scum metaIn post 812, Alisae wrote:dude first off its moreso I don't have the energy to 1v1 you.
secondly, yeah, ofc its impossible because for the most part, your read is based on "I need to do this" not "I'm trying to be right."
Like that's something thats kind of written all over your posts?
You can go find that post. I'm not going to argue against it, but that doesn't change my read.
ilu penguin I knew you would save me <3In post 819, PenguinPower wrote:Oh, look, it's Mulch. Hi, Mulch.
Mulch is town.
I'll read through the other 300 posts or so later, but Xenoblade just got a new game+ mode so...yeah.
How often are your reads correct? Honest question. This is going to sound really bad but I tend to have generally above average reads? As disliked as I am.In post 837, Kokichi Oma wrote:I don't think I'm buying Alisae as scum here.In post 798, Mulch wrote:I'm town, I'm at 80%+ that Alisae is scum at this point
Yes, and I've spectated a lot of your games m8 :pIn post 839, Kokichi Oma wrote:Have we even played together? And I don't see what "Bad!Town" is about my posts? Point some out? Because no one else has even mentioned it.In post 800, Mulch wrote:Also their classic bad!town reactions are classic town kokichi.
In post 844, xRECKONERx wrote:I kind of believe this but I want to know more.In post 825, Alisae wrote:Mulch isn't town and he can make people magically townread him because he's good at scum.
I don't think I care anymore, my moral to try to fight him is kinda destroyed anyways.
Don't explain things away as "magic"
Mate I've specifically tailored my play this game to explain my reasons and not spam post and do everything almost single handedly per your requestIn post 845, xRECKONERx wrote:or maybe my ego isn't letting me stop scumreading jiffy
As scum, sure. I'm a dynamic scum player. But people that have played with me enough can pretty easily spot it? I would say that's my biggest weakness of my scum game right now, that I'm easily meta-able- and one of the only things that can prevent me from being mislynched as town. I don't think I could fool Penguinpower as scum. I actually don't.In post 849, Alisae wrote:You can also tailor your posting to get people to TR you.
What were you pushingIn post 858, Alisae wrote:Like
Fuck off with the "ali is pushing Majiffy for fluff posting" shit
Part of why I scumread your own play is because thats a complete misrepresentation of the push and makes me think you're trying to spin the narative that I'm pushing fluff posting and thats scummy. Like I'm not pushing Majiffy for fluff posting and if you read my posts you would see that. The fact that you're ignoring that completely makes me think you're making this push to try to break town cohesion.
What's your problemIn post 866, GuyInFreezer wrote:I don't want to interrupt or anything but...How can you ask this with a straight faceIn post 865, Mulch wrote:Ali why did you attempt to read me this game when you said you would never attempt to read me?
No lolIn post 867, GuyInFreezer wrote:Like you're being extremely stiff about how one plays and assuming that people will always play the exactly same way every time is a wrong mindset to have.
(btw I'm not taking any sides. Just observing.)
What don't you understand about this being a fundamental principle of their town play over 5+ games with me in themIn post 870, GuyInFreezer wrote:I guess my problem is that you're actually believing what Alisae said about "I'm never gonna read you on day 1 ever?"
Yes???In post 871, GuyInFreezer wrote:Like, if you so firmly believe that, then try putting it backwards.
Would scum-Alisae attempt to read you Day 1 knowing what you said?
I don't really get what you are askingIn post 874, GuyInFreezer wrote:Given how you're emphasizing about "Alisae can't read me," I'm sure you reminded Alisae a lot of time enough for e to not forget.
Never mind the moving goalpost (Questioning your asking "why are you attempting to read me" somehow turned into this "public policy" thing), while I get the point of what you're arguing (using this "scum meta" that apparently Alisae has no clue of), asking "why are you attempting to read me" is... questionable?
You can talk to me without voting AriIn post 897, Lovebird wrote:Mulch unvote ari, I want to talk to you.
I already went about it and I explained it more than I really should be doing in a mafia game but I think their pushes as BS and their style is more like their scum style. But I already went into detail in it earlier so you can read my thoughtsIn post 902, pirate mollie wrote:you are gonna have to walk me through @alisae cos he is my strongest townread rn
Meta is the best tool for getting reads. Almost every single thing a person does is dependent on how they play as town as scum. For example, UC Voyager lurks as town, and scum, but...say...In post 908, xRECKONERx wrote:This is all meta, so, it's really not having any effect on me.In post 850, Mulch wrote:Alisae as town is much more jokey. i've never seen them try and form a town core as town before but I'm sure they've done it. But not in any game I've played with them. They joke and make reads based on meta and subtle things. Like, things that are noticeable and make me go "alisae is town." I can usually lock them as town. As scum they do an aggresive playful pocketing that's similar to this game for sure. They are noticeably trying to gain towncred more as scum. Beyond that they are very smart as town, smart enough not to push on me day 1 for "fluff posting" - or my predecessor. And they definitely do NOT try to read me when they are town. Countless games they've said they can't read me and that they would never try to read me day 1. The fact that they are saying that this is my scum meta, let alone scumreading me, LET ALONE every single other part of their play that points to their scum meta, is near a scumclaim in itself.
I appreciate you switching up your style. It means I can actually read your posts. But, when your posts are mostly "but...meta!" I don't really care that much.
The crux of your push onto Alisae seems to be that they were pushing your slot for being too fluffy? And like, I did that, too. And several others picked up on it. So I don't know why Alisae doing it is so unbelievable?
I'm pretty null on him. I for some reason imagine him having a little more bite as town, but it's possible I'm wrong on that. I don't think their is necesarily something scummy from his posts but nothing has blown me away to be towny either.In post 920, Lovebird wrote:Just getting kind of a weird feeling, about you and my reads.In post 914, Mulch wrote: What reads do you want to talk about? I agree with your Alisae one obviously (although i'm not going to lie Alisae's response to me I think has been a teensy weensy bit towny)
What's your read on reck? You didn't include him in your reads list.
[Thinking emote here]In post 925, Aristophanes wrote:GAH!In post 923, Alisae wrote:Ari your the top wagon
I'll do this soon. Wagon is probably because I haven't done shit and like, I at least pop in as scum. I have not even done that so...
Ari *In post 927, Mulch wrote:[Thinking emote here]In post 925, Aristophanes wrote:GAH!In post 923, Alisae wrote:Ari your the top wagon
I'll do this soon. Wagon is probably because I haven't done shit and like, I at least pop in as scum. I have not even done that so...
Hi ara!
No it's not
I can'tIn post 942, Aristophanes wrote:Also, I have less posts than you and you've been here like, what, 2 days?
You can find it I'm sure! I have faith!
And why is that scummy?In post 949, Kokichi Oma wrote:Yes it is, context aside. It's pushing the narrative that Alisae should forgo the claim because it's already there, instead of trying to talk more about her Ari read in general. Then the second part is just a cover up for that. It would be more natural if it were 2 different posts, but this feels faked.In post 944, Mulch wrote:No it's not
I guess I can see this thought even though it's kinda weirdIn post 961, Lovebird wrote:It's just always notable when someone enters with your exact same reads. You having largely my same scumreads but voting kind of peripherally is also notable.
Consider being less badIn post 966, Kokichi Oma wrote:If you haven't noticed, if I think something is fake I think it's scummy.In post 955, Mulch wrote:And why is that scummy?In post 949, Kokichi Oma wrote:Yes it is, context aside. It's pushing the narrative that Alisae should forgo the claim because it's already there, instead of trying to talk more about her Ari read in general. Then the second part is just a cover up for that. It would be more natural if it were 2 different posts, but this feels faked.In post 944, Mulch wrote:No it's not
No offense but have you ever looked at your reads in gamesIn post 971, Kokichi Oma wrote:Am I bad because you don't agree with me? If so, why aren't you calling everyone else bad?
