NY 151: Playground Mafia (Game Over-Mafia Win!)

[FakeGod]

mandatory UNVOTE:

man..... 30 pages?

[FakeGod]

man..... 30 pages?

I thought you would have known this when you decided to replace in, which leaves this being a fabricated reaction as the only option I can see.

I signed myself up for replacements awhile ago.

Didn't know this game would progress this quickly.

[FakeGod]

Eh, last I checked, this game was like in 7 pages or something.

[FakeGod]

I'm going through the thread at the moment, and I won't be able to finish it today.

At first read, two things that stand out most to me are rack wagon, and drmyshotgun play so far.

Honestly, I cringed at almost every drmyshotgun post I have read so far.

[FakeGod]

At first read, two things that stand out most to me are rack wagon, and drmyshotgun play so far.

Honestly, I cringed at almost every drmyshotgun post I have read so far.

Taking this as a compliment.

......I don't understand why you claimed.

Perhaps you could explain?

[FakeGod]

Still catching up...

Someone please explain to me how drmyshotgun's claim gave him instant towncred.

It seems to me that random claim of his was scum_drmy's attempt at some easy newb-town cred.

VOTE: drmyshotgun

[FakeGod]

Fine.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: rack

[FakeGod]

Few thoughts:

I still don't believe in drmy's claim. There's nothing I see in his posts day 1 or 2 that confirms him as town in any way.

I actually don't think Nero's 1014 was a scumslip. I could see myself writing up a case on my d1 scum read, and if nothing changed during the night in regards to my scum read, then I would post it up.

I have not made my mind up on pine case yet. I will do so soon.

[FakeGod]

Well, they did have discussion. The QT was basically a discussion and I just summarized the parts for you guys. Interesting that you see my post as possible "fake", Junpei. Why would I be faking things like this?
Does that mean you don't believe my status?

Well you claimed Universal Backup turned mason, so you have no choice but to fake the QT.

You would have claimed Universal Backup turned mason because you claimed Universal backup and a mason died.

You would have claimed Universal Backup because scum don't kill Universal Backups right off the bat and you could know it is multiscum or just feared SK.

THANK YOU. At least one person in this game doesn't think drmyshotgun's confirmed town for no good reason.

[FakeGod]

@Mod: I am traveling. V/LA for 2 days

[FakeGod]

Vote Count 2-2

(as of Post 1368)

mastin2 (4)

- Pine, Junpei, DeasVail, Code_X

Pine (3)

- Maxous, drmyshotgun, scooby

Junpei (3)

- HezLucky, Lady Lambdadelta, mastin2

Nero Cain (2)

- The Mini-Librarian, Kublai Khan

The Mini-Librarian(1)

- Nero Cain

Firestarter (1)

- redFF

DeasVail (1)

- Psyche

Not Voting (6)

- Benmage, Firestarter, GreyICE, FakeGod, drmyshottyizsik, Macros

With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch

Deadline:

Thursday, May 11, 2012 3pm CST

Got back.

Looking at the current top three wagons, I see that mastin was voted first by the other top two wagons.

This could suggest that scum_pine/scum_Junpei could be trying to deflect votes on to an easier target.

[FakeGod]

@FakeGod: You have 4 posts in all of Day 2. I want to see your reads on everyone.

My apologies. For some reason, this game is hardest to follow among my current games, and I seem to keep getting distracted by my other games and keep falling back on this one.

I will try to comply to your request at the earliest opportunity.

[FakeGod]

what the

That Pine wagon wasn't there before.... I will go read.

Also, it seemed that mastin wagon seems meta-based.

[FakeGod]

My thoughts:

1. Psyche Merry or Pippin
2. Kublai Khan Boromir
3. scooby Angry Smeagol
4. FakeGod poor me
5. OhGodMyLife Theoden
6. The Mini-Librarian Denethor
8. DeasVail Legolas
9. kdowns Samwise
10. Code_X Merry or Pippin
11. Benmage either Gandalf the grey or Saruman
12. Pine Gollum
13. drmyshottyizsik Bilbo Baggins
14. HezLucky Merry or Pippin
15. drmyshotgun Frodo Baggins
16. Nero Cain Faramir or Sauron
17. redFF Eomer or Uruk-hai captain
19. mastin2 Either Elrond or Balrog
20. Lady Lambdadelta Galadriel
21. Junpei Either Aragorn or Ringwraith
22. Maxous Gimli
24. StrangerCoug Either Gandalf the white or Treebeard

I would vote pine over Junpei.

[FakeGod]

dude, Frodo is one of the sketchiest characters in LoTR. I don't trust you.

And do you realize how close we are to lynch? I'm not going to vote until Pine's replacement gets a chance to post.

[FakeGod]

Frodo would've failed and stolen the ring for himself. Therefore, he's evil.

damn it guys, I actually spent a fair amount of time writing this list. It's fairly self-explanatory.

[FakeGod]

Had to work through the night to finish a lab report.

Need sleep, I'll catch up later.

[FakeGod]

Sorry I didn't post in awhile. I am incredibly sick at the moment.

However, this is long overdue.

VOTE: Seacore

[FakeGod]

Junpei is town.

Pretty sure this guy is scum.

VOTE: Nero Cain

[FakeGod]

@Mod: V/LA. I will be back day after tomorrow. I will be gone shooting a movie for my group's final presentation.

[FakeGod]

@Junpei: asdfjkln;as;dlkfjas;ldkfja;slkfjsal;dkfj1asdfjl;kjla;sdfk;l

Also, Junpei replacing out might make him a bad sport, but not a scum. Since when did replacing out become a scum tell?

[FakeGod]

FakeGod-

What's been preventing me from putting him as stronger scum is 1774, which I find to be the kind of interesting post that would only come from town. Otherwise, it really seems like he could be scum to me. His posting has been minimal, but not controversial and I think it's possible he's just purposely flying under the radar. However, another thing I question is whether he would be more pro-town if scum.

I have my reasons. Also, regarding meta, I was never scum in any of my games. (I completed 15 games total; I keep track in my wiki) Therefore, unfortunately there are no data I could bring as evidence to support that I am town from any of my games.

[FakeGod]

V/LA for tomorrow. Going shooting a film again for class final project.

[FakeGod]

Wow, LLD was Godfather???

Didn't think she would be scum.

Agreed with Hez and SC. Also agreeing with DLG and andrew that TML should claim.

VOTE: Benmage

[FakeGod]

That's my point - serial killers are usually NK immune, he's claiming a shot for last night but none of the other nights. I know he replaced scooby, is he going to claim scooby just didn't shoot on either night prior? Do I need to spell this out any more? The claim stinks in a big way and I'm completely willing to take the fall on this if he's town. If you guys want to play direct the SK you can try that but I don't think that sort of strategy works well, ever, especially not at this stage in the game.

This is straightforward then. If Andrew is not the vig, the vig can shoot him, and if Andrew turns out NK immune the vig can out tomorrow and its instalynch.

I am not sure whether andrew is indeed the vig, but I agree that we should give the vig, if there is one and andrew's lying, a chance to shoot andrew.

[FakeGod]

Prod received. However,

V/LA until Friday

. Finals week.

[FakeGod]

@DV: how does that makes sense?

[FakeGod]

@DLG: People are yelling at me because I didn't post very much, but I see DV telling someone that he is town and he shouldn't post.

I didn't know what to make of it.

[FakeGod]

@DLG: My vote is fine where it is. I don't care about whether Benmage is or isn't a "cool place to be".

[FakeGod]

Are we massclaiming?

[FakeGod]

@FAKEGOD

out of the act of self preservation.

VOTE OGML, otherwise I will be very very,---- fuckit. I'll vote you if you don't vote OGML in your next post.

UNVOTE:

VOTE: OhGoDMyLife

Did as requested.

[FakeGod]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Benmage

[FakeGod]

I claim

Weak Doctor

.

First of all, I apologize if I made glaring mistakes in this game as Weak Doctor. I never played Weak Doctor before, and I had not the slightest idea what is the optimal play for Weak Doctor.

My breadcrumbs:

My thoughts:

1. Psyche Merry or Pippin
2. Kublai Khan Boromir
3. scooby Angry Smeagol
4. FakeGod poor me
5. OhGodMyLife Theoden
6. The Mini-Librarian Denethor
8. DeasVail Legolas
9. kdowns Samwise
10. Code_X Merry or Pippin
11. Benmage either Gandalf the grey or Saruman
12. Pine Gollum
13. drmyshottyizsik Bilbo Baggins
14. HezLucky Merry or Pippin
15. drmyshotgun Frodo Baggins
16. Nero Cain

F

aramir or

S

auron
17. redFF

E

omer or

U

ruk-hai captain
19. mastin2 Either Elrond or Balrog
20. Lady Lambdadelta Galadriel
21. Junpei Either Aragorn or Ringwraith
22. Maxous Gimli
24. StrangerCoug Either Gandalf the white or Treebeard

I would vote pine over Junpei.

Only two players in this list that I listed two characters for, that I did not use "Merry or Pippin", or "either or", are #16 and #17.
#16 says "F" and "S", which stands for "Flip Side", which, when #17's "E" and "U" are flipped sideways, spell "W" and "D" (U was best I could do there)


As I figured that as weak doctor, I should pick a target, hope that the target was town, and stick with him entire way.
I randomly chose Junpei for my N1 target, and stuck with him. That's why I didn't want him lynched.
This is where I outright say my night result.

Junpei is town.

Pretty sure this guy is scum.

VOTE: Nero Cain

@

Junpei

: asdfjkl

n

;as;dlkfjas;ldkfja;slkfjsal;dkfj

1

asdfjl;kjla;sdfk;l

Also, Junpei replacing out might make him a bad sport, but not a scum. Since when did replacing out become a scum tell?

In the post above, the 8 letters your fingers rest on when you type are "asdfjkl;". Only letters not included in it are "n" and "1". I saved Junpei on since N1.

Here's my softclaim:

FakeGod-

What's been preventing me from putting him as stronger scum is 1774, which I find to be the kind of interesting post that would only come from town. Otherwise, it really seems like he could be scum to me. His posting has been minimal, but not controversial and I think it's possible he's just purposely flying under the radar. However, another thing I question is whether he would be more pro-town if scum.

I have my reasons.

Also, regarding meta, I was never scum in any of my games. (I completed 15 games total; I keep track in my wiki) Therefore, unfortunately there are no data I could bring as evidence to support that I am town from any of my games.

Now that Junpei was dead, I decided to save my strongest town read, LLD.

W

ow,

LLD

was Godfather???

D

idn't think she would be scum.

Agreed with Hez and SC. Also agreeing with DLG and andrew that TML should claim.

VOTE: Benmage

Here, I express few things.

One, obvious breadcrumbing for my role.

Two, my N3 target, who was LLD.

Three, LLD died. Someone broke through my protection and killed her.

Four, my surprise that I'm still alive. I picked a scum for my target..... doesn't that mean I should be dead?

I came to conclusion that I was probably roleblocked during Night 3.

[FakeGod]

Also,

@Benmage: I am not going to negotiate with terrorists.

[FakeGod]

If I protect an anti-town player, then I die.

Wiki:
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Doc

[FakeGod]

@DV: I saved Junpei N1 and N2.

[FakeGod]

As the Weak Doctor, I take a chance of death every time I pick a new target.

I took that chance Night 1, and I didn't die.

I saw no reason to switch target and risk death again. Plus, Junpei was confirmed town to me at that point, so I chose him again for N2.

[FakeGod]

BAH

[FakeGod]

I was useless.

Q.Q