Post
Post #1545 (isolation #205) » Fri May 21, 2021 9:40 am
Postby Infinity 324 »
In post 1529, Infinity 324 wrote:Did you think I was gonna say that and then not use the opportunity of comprehensible isis posts to sort you? I don't really get it
And it's possible your alignment is different I'm trying to figure it out
Post
Post #1549 (isolation #206) » Fri May 21, 2021 10:02 am
Postby Infinity 324 »
Huh, that's an interesting point
I think there's a way to meet in the middle, but yes there's always some artificiality there
With you posting so much that you seemed to believe I thought it would help a lot to check the actual content to make sure you're not just making up bullshit
I accept your response
PEdit: your posts around when I wrote the hall monitor post were all written in isis thought language and I don't speak that language
In post 1553, Infinity 324 wrote:Is the 1 scum in isis/infinity thing because of interactions or PoE or some other reason
Isis was trying to come up with ideas on how to combat Koba's idea on how to approach the setup, failed miserably, admitted that our plan was better, and still tried to come up with something to compete.
You piggybacked on said idea in away that did not feel like scum v scum
Post
Post #1682 (isolation #219) » Fri May 21, 2021 5:59 pm
Postby Infinity 324 »
You asked for everyone to ISO isis and tell you that her ydrasse read isn't weird; I don't need to ISO isis to do so. She could be scum but that's not why
Post
Post #1695 (isolation #220) » Fri May 21, 2021 6:12 pm
Postby Infinity 324 »
@koba I liked the energy around the mech plan early on
Ali made a post to me about me recognizing town!ali which felt town. At first I didn't think too much of it but it really feels like a towny appeal.
I didn't like your interactions with isis. In retrospect I'm not quite sure why scum!you was arguing so much with isis, but your tone reminded me a lot of your scumgames and you didn't feel to me like you were trying to sort her. Then you TRed her for having nuanced thoughts which she'd been having all game and I don't see town!you giving out townreads like that very much. This part I still think is scummy but it's not enough to outweigh other things
You posting today has been towny to me, especially the part where you tried to compare the situation you're in now to the situation I was in in black flag. I don't think the comparison is apt but the outreach is towny because I don't think scum!you cares much at all about me SRing you here. I think there were other towny posts today, I'll find quotes tomorrow
Post
Post #1738 (isolation #222) » Fri May 21, 2021 7:31 pm
Postby Infinity 324 »
In post 1733, srckz wrote:I haven't properly addressed Dunn/Emily or given my thoughts on them, so they got more attention. I hadn't explained why I think Anya/Johnny make sense to me right now either. It all follows a structure; You would've gotten more but I'm not gonna get into it.
Post
Post #1741 (isolation #223) » Fri May 21, 2021 7:37 pm
Postby Infinity 324 »
The "it all follows a structure" is good because scum's thoughts don't follow a structure and they need to type more words to make it seem like they do. Unwnd doesn't care about that. Emotionally, I felt similarly interacting with you and others; it's kind of exhausting to keep having to explain myself
I may be weighting it too highly; I know unwnd is good at replicating emotional states like this
Post
Post #1747 (isolation #225) » Fri May 21, 2021 7:41 pm
Postby Infinity 324 »
In post 1744, Chromium wrote:the whole post fits the descriptor you put for scum - I'm not getting what you're saying here.
Basically I think scum would feel compelled to explain their reads more when pressed. It's a bit more nuanced than that but I don't think I can explain it better
i mainly see you out reads that are one extreme or the other. no in between.
Atm emily, isis, and srckz are in between reads.
You're right to some extent and this is probably a weakness in my play. If I set out to sort someone I want to come to a firm conclusion, even when I don't really have the tools as a scumhunter to do so. I try to focus my energy on the people I can sort the best and sometimes even ignore the others, but most of this plist is tough to sort.
Post
Post #1786 (isolation #230) » Sat May 22, 2021 4:46 am
Postby Infinity 324 »
@tweet I voted to end the day because I didn't think there was much more to discuss, ydrasse had already laid out the plan and johnny said he was ready. I forgot you weren't caught up sorry
In post 1787, Infinity 324 wrote:I think if srckz is scum it's going to have to be someone else who catches them. They would have to be putting a lot of effort into pocketing me
way to discred everything emily put out
This is not what I'm doing, in fact emily has some good points and this was my way of processing that. It's possible emily will be the one to catch them.
Post
Post #1799 (isolation #233) » Sat May 22, 2021 5:12 am
Postby Infinity 324 »
Chromium wrote:its a discred and i'm gonna call it what it is.
either say the case is something you agree with or tell us what you disagree with.
I agree with the case but the arguments aren't strong enough for a full scumread. Emily doesn't full scumread the slot either so idk what you're on about
Post
Post #2004 (isolation #241) » Mon May 24, 2021 9:17 am
Postby Infinity 324 »
T -> S at the training camp: Ydrasse, chrom, dunn, emily, isis
VOTE: srckz I feel like my reasons for townreading this slot mostly involve me liking unwnd and/or being pocketed. And the idea of 2 scum being at the camp seems tough to swallow.
Post
Post #2209 (isolation #248) » Mon May 24, 2021 3:14 pm
Postby Infinity 324 »
In post 2198, Dunnstral wrote:I think it could easily be a case where 1 of them is scum, and johnny was killed because their flip would otherwise clear the dungeon-goers + guillo prepper (because someone died at night), or/and as MT said keep the pool of 5 wide if there's 1 outside who is looking to play the deep wolf
Post
Post #2236 (isolation #249) » Mon May 24, 2021 3:35 pm
Postby Infinity 324 »
In post 2226, Morning Tweet wrote:Chrome's tinfoil on Ydrasse came across as believable to me, this hop on did not make as much sense. I suppose my question would be what was shady about the switch
This was my original thing that made me consider Emily as a possibility so it is worthwhile to talk about just for a moment i promise
Post
Post #2308 (isolation #253) » Tue May 25, 2021 3:54 pm
Postby Infinity 324 »
In post 2306, Dunnstral wrote:The monty-hall thing is: If we eliminate Infinity and they flip scum, you'd be more likely to be scum because other possibilities would close and it becomes a situation where either it was 1-1, or it was 0-2; 2-0 would no longer be an option, mechanically
I don't think this is the same as Monty hall because 1-1 becomes more likely too
In post 2301, srckz wrote:then why are you stuck on it? you should understand that it was not something everyone was thinking about then.
-cake
?
i already SR you and infinity. why would I not think this is what happened?
I think this is a scumpost. Scum think a lot more than town about how their posts are perceived, and this feels like emily thought that her position of a me/srckz scumteam would seem logical and is surprised that sircakez disagrees. Town would more likely jump to a "here was my thought process" explanation.
Post
Post #2314 (isolation #256) » Tue May 25, 2021 6:46 pm
Postby Infinity 324 »
In post 2311, Infinity 324 wrote:I think this is a scumpost. Scum think a lot more than town about how their posts are perceived, and this feels like emily thought that her position of a me/srckz scumteam would
logically follow from her stated reads
and is surprised that sircakez disagrees. Town would more likely jump to a "here was my thought process" explanation.