[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Undefined array key 9247877 [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Trying to access array offset on value of type null Micro 715: Friendly Neighbor 6 (Game Over) - Mafiascum.net
Micro Games (9 players or fewer). Archived during the 2023 queue overhaul.
97 posts
• Page 1 of 1
Vedith
Vedith
Survivor
Vedith
Survivor
Survivor
Posts: 21212
Joined: June 18, 2015
Location: Surrey
Post
Post #543 (isolation #0) » Tue Jun 20, 2017 8:42 am
Postby Vedith »
Never fear, Vedith is here.
I won't be posting until later tonight / early morning, really busy.
Anything I should need to know, lay it on me, I can handle it!
Post
Post #560 (isolation #7) » Wed Jun 21, 2017 12:17 am
Postby Vedith »
Okay I don't like Raya either.
Changing their opinion to suit the situation. The reasoning for having Gamma (me) as town from the start was trash, and looked like hoping for a Gamma lynch credit or trying to buddy?
From there, any town reads look like they may have been favoured by others but I'll check that.
I didn't really come out of understanding what Raya's stance or opinion is on the game
@Raya - Tell me your understanding to what has happened in the game so far.
Because I know BTD town. This is that.
I have more content from reading his ISO that yours or Raya's so far. Considering he has 25 posts...
Although I find your ISO productive and pushing for game progression (something scum don't want) I prefer BTD's scum hunting, even when he's questioning Mario's alignment when it's a generic town view. I can't see BTD doing that as scum.
Post
Post #569 (isolation #12) » Wed Jun 21, 2017 12:51 am
Postby Vedith »
In post 568, Draynth wrote:Considering this exact same thing was said in a micro I recently played, and he flipped scum, you'll excuse me for not taking you at your word.
I'm not sure I did say that? In what game exactly?
You don't need to take my word, you can either check his ISO and see he's town or not check his ISO and try to call him scum where I'll disagree with you the entire way.
Post
Post #576 (isolation #15) » Wed Jun 21, 2017 1:24 am
Postby Vedith »
In post 575, Draynth wrote:Like, saying 'I prefer BTD's scum hunting' is not helpful in the slightest.
It doesn't matter if you prefer his method to someone else's.
Saying you prefer it doesn't say why you like it at all.
So why did you not question me with asking for an example? If you had an issue with what I said, of course.
I'll tell you why, because you wasn't interest in my reasons.
I like it because he's actually scum hunting. It's not that there's a method, it's that Raya's in non existent.
Post
Post #577 (isolation #16) » Wed Jun 21, 2017 1:27 am
Postby Vedith »
In post 574, Draynth wrote:I genuinely can't tell if you're purposely manipulating quotes or not
Did you honestly just say what I said because I called you out on it?
In post 574, Draynth wrote:My response to 'I prefer BTD's scum hunting, even when he's questioning Mario's alignment when it's a generic town view. I can't see BTD doing that as scum.' is the line below it.
The part of my post you quoted is referring to 'I have more content from reading his ISO that yours or Raya's so far. Considering he has 25 posts...'
I think you mis understand. I wasn't quoting post 572 in regards to my comment, I was quoting it to respond to.
I am assuming that you mean that post that I quoted from you, because otherwise your comment makes no sense.
Post
Post #582 (isolation #18) » Wed Jun 21, 2017 1:50 am
Postby Vedith »
In post 578, Draynth wrote:This whole back and forth between us has been me trying to get some specific reasons as to why you townread BTD so strongly.
Why would I bother discussing this with you if ultimately I didn't care about your reasoning? The minute you said he was town I asked you why you thought so.
The fact you ignored me saying he's scum hunting, and just said I gave no reason but meta tells me otehrwise.
In post 578, Draynth wrote:Why do you keep comparing his scum hunting to Raya's lack of scum hunting.
They have nothing to do with each other
Because I their the 2 ISO's I read in full.
Tell me, what do you not like about me comparing the 2 players?
Right, lets get this clear, because you obviously lack something somewhere to understand.
This is a comment purely about BTD scum hunting. It doesn't take a smart person to understand what this is, and even if they don't, you made no attempt to question where or why until I said about it.
In post 581, Draynth wrote:All I've asked you to do is give some examples of posts that lead you to believe that BTD is town.
In post 320, Something_Smart wrote:ok I'm feeling more town on Alchemist and I don't like to sheep but I'm pretty sure this is like the perfect time to sheep so VOTE: iDanyBoy
You vote me for sheeping while sheeping?
I agree with a lot of what Alchemist is posting (280) and didn't have much to add onto that, this is also making me see him as a townie.
I'd like to know what changed your vote from Alchemist to me?
In post 302, Something_Smart wrote:Because Mario seemed like an easy lynch and easy lynches that are town are prime places for scum to vote, especially when the overall state of the game is slow.
What makes you think he was an easy lynch? He only had two votes on him at that time and I unvoted shortly after.
VOTE: SS
He switches his votes from people to people with very little reasoning and his responses' to Alchemist seem like scum.
You have shown in the past that you do indeed have some reasoning, yet you seem to simply sheep MM. If you agree with MM's case, you should be able to give reasons why apart from simply "MM is confTown", as that doesn't make their reads more likely to be correct.
Why are you sheeping when you have reads of your own?
Post
Post #590 (isolation #23) » Wed Jun 21, 2017 2:20 am
Postby Vedith »
In post 587, Something_Smart wrote:Also Vedith don't be an asshole. Neither of you are stupid and actually the person who made a comprehension error was you.
Being an asshole is what I do best.
If I feel someone is being stupid, I'll make it clear.
Post
Post #591 (isolation #24) » Wed Jun 21, 2017 2:26 am
Postby Vedith »
In post 585, Draynth wrote:You said you gave reasoning PRIOR to this post. THEREFORE, " It's not forced, his opinions are set." is irrelevant to the point I am making. Besides the fact that it's ridiculously vague and wishy washy, it came after you said you had already given reasoning.
THIS is the only specific thing you had mentioned.
"I prefer BTD's scum hunting, even when he's questioning Mario's alignment when it's a generic town view. I can't see BTD doing that as scum."
I asked you for another example, you then spouted nonsense for an entire page.
Not once did I say I disagreed with you about your read on him, so why would I question the one 'reason' you gave. I'm trying to make sure you're not just blindly calling people town and expecting to get away with it.
Also, if you make another personal remark like that either I'm replacing out or I'm asking for you to be force replaced.
I'm trying to look through this shit, and while I'm doing this you are being extremly stupid.
I can quote the series of events if you like, since this is what you're failing to do. At no point do you question me on the reasons given. You originally skipped me saying about BTD scum hunting and said reasons were only meta. Even when I say scum hunting and knowing his stance (or whatever it was) you still ignore that section. If you had any interest, you would have asked where he's scum hunting, or what points made me think that, not just say "I need more reasons" or what ever it is you're trying to day.
Scum do not scum hunt, town do. This gives a reason in itself regardless if it's worded "I prefer his scum hunting" or "He's scum hunting". You are acting stupid here (I hope) because you missed my comment. So your entire argument here is the way I worded it, knowing full well that scum aren't scum hunting.
Post
Post #594 (isolation #25) » Wed Jun 21, 2017 2:30 am
Postby Vedith »
In post 592, Something_Smart wrote:I never said you said he wasn't. I had no read on him before that interaction. So in that regard, thanks. (Unless he's scum...)
If you are the one who wants to show that BTD6 is town using meta, the burden of proof is on you to provide the meta.
And I don't care if you're good at insulting people, leave it out of Mafia games. This is a cooperative game and saying things like "you are not very smart, I can tell" does nothing but make people pissed at you.
I never said you said I said he wasn't.
I'm not concerned on showing you why BTD is town, I'm concerned on showing why scum are scum. If you wish to see me being right, you either look at my games with BTD, or give me a case to think otherwise.
I'll insult where needed. I'm not here to be Dray's friend, I'm here to find scum. So I'm not worried if I piss him, or you off during that time.
Post
Post #595 (isolation #26) » Wed Jun 21, 2017 2:31 am
Postby Vedith »
In post 593, Something_Smart wrote:Re: 591, I think the issue is that saying "I like BTD6's scumhunting" isn't a reason. That's like saying "their posts are town motivated"; what Draynth wants to know is why.
Please show me what post Dray asked to see where BTD is scum hunting.
I missed it.
Post
Post #596 (isolation #27) » Wed Jun 21, 2017 2:34 am
Postby Vedith »
So going by Mario being killed and his ISO, he was killed because town had shit reads, not because he had good reads.
Otherwise scum would have aimed to kill the Jailor or Tracker.
So, lets look at who had shit reads out of you guys.
Post
Post #598 (isolation #28) » Wed Jun 21, 2017 2:49 am
Postby Vedith »
222 - BTD is showing that he's keeping an eye on Flubber, pulling up for an unexplained vote.
This post he's showing that he's paying attention, and aiming his focus onto his scum reads. 226 - His comment shows that he's trying to work out Mario, as scum don't want the attention. 301 - Not only setting on the same people, he's pressing into SS's comments here. 339 - Pushing SS for a change of play 371 - Pushing the motive 488 - Another solid stance on the game. Pushing Danny with reasons 529 - Push an un answered question
This is what scum hunting is. Unless you want to challenge me that BTD wasn't scum hunting or constantly pushing his reads while making it known where he stands?
Post
Post #604 (isolation #30) » Wed Jun 21, 2017 1:03 pm
Postby Vedith »
In post 602, Alchemist21 wrote:What are these posts for? I'm guessing the first 2 are to have all the votes in your ISO to run VCA or something? And I can't really tell what the 3rd post is supposed to be.
I actually see it as Towny that SS stepped in as the voice of reason to try to get Vedith and Draynth to understand each other. I think scum would have been happy to just let that conversation go on as it was.
And Vedith, even if you think someone is stupid, don't call them that or say you're treating them as a joke. It's toxic, and this game was thoroughly enjoyable before you started the personal attacks.
Read-wise Vedith on first glance leaves a bad taste in my mouth because of his BTD read going unexplained, and it's hard to tell if he's being difficult on purpose or if his meta read on BTD is something he has genuine faith in. His frustration from the Draynth supposedly distracting him from re-reading things looks Town to me, but I'm going to need an explanation for these 3 posts I quoted before I can really solidify that thought.
It's for my reference while i read stuff. That's all.
Okay Alch, I won't. Sorry Dray.
On a side note, I don't give a shit on your read with me. And my read is explained. You can try and say how my read is wrong, but don't skip my posts and say I haven't explained anything. I won't allow that bullshit.
Because the other PR is what will actually find them/disrupt them, not a neighbour.
I wasn't originally sure if that was a serious question and gave you the benefit of the doubt that it wasn't a serious question.
For now on, I'll take your questions as 100% serious.
Post
Post #622 (isolation #37) » Thu Jun 22, 2017 4:53 am
Postby Vedith »
In post 621, BTD6_maker wrote:I don't. I am trying to see what Sergtacos' reads are. It was essentially "This is what Raya thought. What do you think?" rather than presuming that the reads will be similar. This will also generate content from this slot and give a new perspective.
Post
Post #624 (isolation #38) » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:58 am
Postby Vedith »
In post 623, Alchemist21 wrote:I still don't understand how the whole reads thing factors into this. What you're saying about going for the disruptive PR makes sense, and I would get it if you were saying Mario was killed first because of his reads, but you're saying Mario was killed first because of everyone else's reads rather than his own which makes no sense.
No, you mis understand. I'm still working things out.
Post
Post #634 (isolation #40) » Thu Jun 22, 2017 9:45 pm
Postby Vedith »
In post 632, Alchemist21 wrote:I guess I can see where you're coming from here. I just disagree that scum would play the guessing game over killing the hardclaim and doubt anyone's reads were involved in that decision.
This plus others suggest you're not scum together then.
So if Alch is scum, it's with BTD or Danny.
There's pros and cons to both, Alch making people aware of BTD on L1, bad voting, never actually engaging with or about Danny.
I forget if Alch is a distancer as scum or not.
Post
Post #681 (isolation #53) » Mon Jun 26, 2017 8:17 am
Postby Vedith »
In post 488, BTD6_maker wrote:I mostly agree with this. Dany has been rather inconsistent. For the first point, I can see why they think that not giving reasoning is scummy but if they believe that, they should agree. They believe that stating reasons is pro-Town therefore it will benefit Town if they state reasons therefore they should state reasons. Their justification for not stating reasons does not make sense. Reaction tests are also generally ineffective and if, in doing so, you contradict something you claim to believe, it can easily be picked up on.
The second quote exemplifies this. If you have certain standards, you are expected to follow them. It is not different if you do something.
The third and fourth quotes are fine. It is possible for Townies to have gut reads that you cannot pin down reasons for. However, when your read is strong enough to warrant a vote, reasoning is expected.
Currently, I scumread Dany as well as SS.
In post 529, BTD6_maker wrote:You have given some answers, but they are unsatisfactory. You are essentially denying the argument without actually refuting it. You are also using misrep in these posts. For example, when Draynth clearly has multiple reasons for voting you and pushes the fact that you flip-flopped, you claim that Draynth is changing reasons in short succession, with the implication that they are just making them up on the spot, which I doubt.
You still haven't answered this one:
"Why would you do what you scumread someone for, if you are just trying to see whether you will be scumread? Would someone scumreading you for not giving reasons (when you scumread others for the same) be indicative of Town or scum?"
I'm not sure how to think of these. BTD is voting SS but not pushing, while having more focus on Dany but not voting.
Post
Post #684 (isolation #55) » Mon Jun 26, 2017 8:21 am
Postby Vedith »
In post 683, Something_Smart wrote:But that interaction goes both ways. I gave significant reasoning against BTD6.
I agree, and I have you're combo as currently the weakest...
I just don't understand why BTD never votes Dany when he looks to have his strongest case there... But that could be BTD being BTD.
Post
Post #687 (isolation #57) » Mon Jun 26, 2017 8:24 am
Postby Vedith »
In post 686, Something_Smart wrote:Why in 669 did you assume that I am scum and BTD6 town, yet now a page later your possible teams have BTD6 as second most likely scum and me as least likely?
Because I ended the day with thinking you were scum and BTD was town.