In post 65, Morning Tweet wrote:i've read through it now. Amazing what just a couple of respected players finding another player *really* scummy early on can accomplish, apparently
I feel that Ahsoka tended to blow things out of proportion to put it lightly, first with Hop early (which is expected, since that's mega early game), but then also in a more deadly manner with Infinity.
237 by Ahsoka - i could see Infinity's vote combined with lacking knowledge of Ahsoka's interactions causing a town!Ahsoka to become tunneled, sure. It's weird that he gives no thought to the scenario where Infinity simply didn't interpret the situation the same way he did (Hopkirk discrediting him). Reading this again, it's pretty clear that Infinity saw what FL was talking about but was asking for clarification. sigh
263 by Ahsoka - While "doesn't mean it's not readable" sounds good on the surface level, I think a lot of FL's points are just kinda invalidated if Hopkirk isn't being serious. Like he thinks
Hop essentially calling FL 'chicken' is Hop trying to push a narrative that he's afraid? Stuff like that. I think trying to draw information out of the fact he's being jokey itself is possible, although I seriously doubt anything from Hop was scummy really, it's what im used to seeing
264 by Ahsoka - It sucks now that it's fairly obvious Infinity (as either alignment) wasn't missing anything and simply interpreted the situation differently from FL
Whatever that's enough of that. I don't know what FL would do as either alignment, but i get the feeling I'm going to disagree with his pushes constantly just by heavy clash of playstyle
Kanna feels a tad stiff in
282, it feels like things I would think of saying rather than things i would actually say, so if Kanna is like me, then it's a bit off looking. Don't know how to explain beyond how it just looks like reading off a script where you're trying to hit a bunch of points: Give a read -> be uncertain about self -> ask someone for reads -> be uncertain about self (say you'll get mocked -> be sad about something minor -> ask a question -> make slightly awkward joke about being scum. Admittedly i wouldnt add the part about secret scumreads but maybe that's a Kanna exclusive part of the script. Is this too much of a stretch?
295 by clidd - This is generally in the same vein of thinking i was abt infinity -- he was very explainy for whatever reason. Clidd's point that Infinity was more interested in clarifying himself than he was in actually getting an interaction is probably faintly where i was going with that. Obviously looking at FL's points themselves i can see why Infinity did this now in hindsight >.> so oh well. Possibly a good look from clidd but need more. Clidd kind of loses me after this part so idrk
314 by Ahsoka - so again going back to Ahsoka against Infinity: this makes FL's case sound pretty good and i bought into this while skimming but it's not really true since the representation that FL thinks Infinity is missing was just FL's own personal interpretation. I would say that im surprised FL didn't think of how other people can see things differently from him, but a lot of ppl thought the way FL did, apparently so i guess not? I mean including me cause I still really hadn't played. But still, he is basically getting away with making this case sound solid af when this point isn't really true.
Earlier FL replied to the post where Infinity clarified that he saw the situation differently -- so what is FL even claiming that Infinity had inaccurate here..?
318 by Hopkirk - I love that Hop reveals his intention with the 1v1 was basically just to poke a player who is showing ego, thats believable enough to me
320 by Hopkirk - Yeah i agree infinity's speculation of FL!town doesnt seem quite right, i also think Hopkirk finding it weird Infinity only focuses on Ahsoka is believable
322 by Ahsoka - We're entering straight-up lying territory, FL is accusing Infinity of not having known the content his posts -- but again, the only part where I see FL claim this is when Infinity said "Who has been discrediting you? Hopkirk?". FL interprets that as Infinity missing a section, when in reality, Infinity was being like "What, are you talking about that Hopkirk part?" I have no idea if this was as obvious back then as it is to me now knowing Infinity's alignment now, as i gave wayy less thought during the day phase. would appreciate feedback on this bit
327 by Hopkirk - Hopkirk is not even using the reasoning FL keeps bringing up -- good. He's my biggest pick so far for the "conf-biased townie on Infinity" guess ive been making
344 by Pooky - I do see why Pooky would find it odd that FL puts time into analyzing Jesse for reasons outside of the lover thing (although FL clarified he didnt see it ofc)
347 by Pooky - ik that it makes no sense for Pooky to be randomly concerned about getting NKed, but i've seen it from him before in the past so i dont think it's AI
I think Hoppy's sheer confidence on a scumread so early is a good look for him since it's not something i would think to do to emulate my townplay as scum so if he's like me, then he wouldn't think to do it as scum. Not certain yet cause like FL adding on all the extra reasons would have made it easier, but ill award town points to Hop where they've been earned
382 by Infinity - Yeah so obviously Infinity was fully aware of how FL was misconstruing that post of his like ive been saying here but obviously it's easy for me to say now so whatever
Idk wtf Hop is trying to say to me end of day but i want to theorize he was getting confirm biased on Infinity scum and already starting to see me as being possibly with him, so i think thats lean town too. Good acting job if scum though i think
