Countdown of the Illuminati GAME OVER

[Miztef]

just briefly reread guardian..
main points were that he thought neko was town and that samruc was scum
something we should consider when lynching

agreed, we should try to protect those who the masons protected. I doubt the scum will attempt daykilling anymore (at least soon) and it's doubtful the serial killer won't already research into who guardian protected or not.

Not sure how likely samruc is to be anti-town, but he doesn't contribute too much anyway.

[neko2086]

I want to point out ABR's overwhelming conviction that DBG was scum as false, however, I think it points him out as more town then scum.

This is extremely troubling for me. ABR was after DG so much the entire game, but their behaviors are quite similar. At one point someone said they looked like two townies arguing, and now, I'm inclined to agree.

Flameaxe and Samruc bother me the most so far. DG pointed out that flameaxe has been active in other games but very silent in this one. Samruc also seems to have been pretty quiet, only popping in to defend himself. Guardian wanted him lynched, but didn't specify very well why.

[Max]

I'm back but I'll be reading and posting comments later

[Max]

P.S. that means tommorow

[Albert B. Rampage]

Flameaxe is always online but never posts here.

Vote: Flameaxe

Lurking for the win.....how pathetic

[Albert B. Rampage]

He's online right now, posting with me on other threads. Flameaaaxe...oooooh Flameaaaaaaaaaaxe ?

[Albert B. Rampage]

Come out and plaaaaaaaaaaay

[dahill1]

red rover red rover i call flameaxe over
i agree he should post and not lurk, but it seems to like you're just trying to dig up a reason to bumrush him

I think DGB town suggests ABR scum, so..

have we forgot about this?

Vote: ABR

bumrush

[Albert B. Rampage]

Mmmmmm.......except I'm not trying to lynch him, I'm trying to get him to post. Hence your vote makes little sense to me.

[Albert B. Rampage]

I've re-read your posts dahill. This stuck out to me:

we are voting flameaxe because as neko said, Flameaxe has contributed literally nothing to the game.

well, that is true...
so to put pressure on him vote: flameaxe

^^ This post is very skummy ^^

context (before dahill voted) :

vote: Flameaxe

7 more.

vote : Flameaxe

6 more.

I agree with this wagon. Flameaxe has contributed hardly anything of substance.

vote: Flameaxe

5 more

Does this look like a pressure wagon to you ? I consider this a massive slip that shows what dahill really wanted to do: pressure mafia into snapping and killing some masons before dying.

[dahill1]

my vote on you isnt because of flameaxe

[Albert B. Rampage]

You bandwagonned a player, put him close to lynch but suspiciously claimed that you wanted to "pressure" him.

[dahill1]

i wanted to pressure him into posting...
just like you do now...

[Albert B. Rampage]

You are lying. You don't pressure a player with a 4th vote, after 3 consecutive votes on that player saying "5 votes left, 4 votes left".

Don't lie dahill.

[dahill1]

You don't pressure a player with a 4th vote, after 3 consecutive votes on that player saying "5 votes left, 4 votes left".

i do

[Albert B. Rampage]

unvote, vote dahill

[Max]

Since my last proper post I think Flame axe has been lurking, he has to be trying to save himself here. Me thinking last Mafioso with ABR being SK, I'm starting to wonder is SK going to use his risk kill or has he already used it. I'm presuming he's saving it but i'm not too sure anymore. That run of unknown reasons must have given the remaining mafia. If we presume the mafia say when they are about to daykill the remaining Mafiate is just waiting for the last few uncertainties to die, wither finding the Mason or failing to do so.

If the SK is good at this skill he may have found out who's who in this obscure epic. And that also means a bad mafia would not have this skill. I am going to vote Albert, FlameAxe or Neko later in the day but first I want to hear something, no anything from flameaxe.

[Miztef]

I'm starting to agree with ABR here, it seems like dahill is lying. I haven't liked dahill's plays for most of the game, but I attributed it mostly to newbishness not scumminess.

Right now, I like max and neko, overall, I just don't think they are scum.

Samruc is a bit of a doozy, because he lurks (maybe unintentionally?), and isn't too helpful, but he hasn't actually done much openly scummy things.

ABR is risky, because I don't like how he wanted DGB dead, she dies, and it turns out she's not anti-town. That looks really bad on ABR, even if it is "pro-town" to push the town forward.

Flameaxe is a big lurker and posts almost uselessly. He does this in most games though, so I have no idea if he is actually scum or not. I don't know if it's worth the risk of to lynch him.

[dahill1]

I'm starting to agree with ABR here, it seems like dahill is lying. I haven't liked dahill's plays for most of the game, but I attributed it mostly to newbishness not scumminess.

Right now, I like max and neko, overall, I just don't think they are scum.

Samruc is a bit of a doozy, because he lurks (maybe unintentionally?), and isn't too helpful, but he hasn't actually done much openly scummy things.

ABR is risky, because I don't like how he wanted DGB dead, she dies, and it turns out she's not anti-town. That looks really bad on ABR, even if it is "pro-town" to push the town forward.

Flameaxe is a big lurker and posts almost uselessly. He does this in most games though, so I have no idea if he is actually scum or not. I don't know if it's worth the risk of to lynch him.

that is why i'm voting ABR.
i agree with you about max and neko (still a little sus about him), and samruc i'm not sure if he's lurking on purpose or not. flameaxe is

definitely

active in other games, scumchat, etc. he seems to be just avoiding this game

[neko2086]

Does flameaxe not realize that we need to lynch in like, 2 days?

Also, where is samruc? He has been active on the site as well.

mod:

can we get prods on flameaxe and samruc?

I'm still in favor of lynching one of these two. I don't think we can afford to keep anyone who is being intentionally useless. At the moment, I'm leaning toward flameaxe, since he's posted less content, imo. I'd really like to hear from them both first, though.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I've prodded both players.

[Max]

Vote: Flameaxe

(A little more pressure) I want answers to the following.

Do you have a reasonable explaination for not posting?
If yes what?
If no why should we not vote you?

[Samruc]

Apologies for the infrequent posting.

To say that I haven't had time to post here would be a lie, but my overall time for Mafia has been somewhat limited (school's back again), and I've tried to prioritize modding over playing.

From what I remember, my suspicions pointed to Max, but what I'd really need now is a read-through. This game is kind of difficult though, as everyone has incentive to downplay their respective roles.

If anyone could, like, ask me some specific questions, just to get me into the game again...

[neko2086]

I have one--who do you think is scum?

[Samruc]

Probably one of these guys:

Miztef
dahill1
Max
Albert B. Rampage
Flameaxe
neko2086

***

No, seriously, I'll try to take a look at the early days and get some thought into this game.