Mini Normal 1996: Floral Mafia [Endgame!]

[Creature]

I like the reasoning but I wouldn't nail Katherine as scum based solely on that yet.

it was a joke then?

This and katherine's previous posts look like shy scum.

[Creature]

Page 3

brassherald can be town

[Creature]

maria's reasoning is solid. Also dislike tchill's 41. Also skeptical of cedrick's opening.

I guess this was the post that made my vote on implosion become serious.

[Creature]

My vote on implosion is now serious.

i'd vote there if mumble wasn't almost certainly a wolf.

creature strong villa btw

Tell me about Mumble.

[Creature]

Cedrick
Tchill13
Creature

Ausuka
Gamma Emerald

brassherald
Havo

Mumble

Killthestory

katherine
MariaR
Luca Blight
implosion

[Ausuka]

Alright, Creature can be town.

[Cedrick]

What does drama mean in this context? I think anything that would be called drama is usually helpful in mafia

This little 1 v 1 with tchill. Really drama is helpful. Staged drama not so much. Kts is faking reads imo to stir things up. I’m not entirely convinced tchill isn’t in on it.

[Cedrick]

I townread Cedrick

Based off what?

[Ausuka]

gut

[Cedrick]

VOTE: creature

Scum slipped. Town know how to vote properly

-_-

Oh come on. It was a joke. Do people not have fun anymore?

[Cedrick]

Alright, Creature can be town.

Maybe but I dislike him thinking both kts and chill are town.

[Luca Blight]

Catching up...

I'm far from enamoured with Tchill's opening. To use a few examples...

I like the reasoning but I wouldn't nail Katherine as scum based solely on that yet.

I dislike every word of this. Maria's reasoning was shit, and who's naiing anyone as scum on page two?

Awful tippy-tappy post.

I'll participate...

Whats wolfy about me saying it's pretty aggressive seeing how you haven't explained why "this has got to die"?

Surely the natural respinse would be to question why he made that comment?

Tchill's mindset is

'am I making a wolfy comment right now'

instead of

'why is this guy thinking this'

- i.e. survivalism over curiosity.

Man we've got some people jumping at the chance to push others EARLY.

This was Tchill's reponse to Kill's explanation for scumreading him. He's making out there's something wrong with people pushing other early, when that is the essence what makes the game advance out of RVS.

Yeah. You're the type of player where if I flip town I'm bad town but you're not gonna let up till I flip. You're gonna use anything I say to reinforce your case from one perspective or another.

Go ahead though it's all amusement for me.

Terrible.

A bit of early pressure and he's already dismissing every argument, present and future, that may be used against him by Kill. The fact Tchill hasn't actually answered anything against him yet compounds this issue even more.

Yeah. You're the type of player where if I flip town I'm bad town but you're not gonna let up till I flip. You're gonna use anything I say to reinforce your case from one perspective or another.

Go ahead though it's all amusement for me.

After I stop replying to KTS this is my stance on him throughout the game. I will ignore him after a point in order to play the game and focus on helping town. I'm not getting myself involved in a 1v1 that hurts town.

I hard TR KTS and that's that.

Hard townreading him based on what? It's almost like a defensive measure:

'I townread you so leave me alone'

.

Tchill has succummed to the first bit of pressure, and looks terribly scummy already. I also dislike Maria's vote on Katherine. I'm still only on page three but I like my vote here for now.

VOTE: Tchill

[MariaR]

Hello Hello Hello.

Before I RVS vote, let me introduce myself.

I’m a mediocre mafia player at best who really dislikes Day 1s.
I’ve been known to quick hammer peeps on Day 1 if it’s just a day or two
Into the game to get the game moving.

I’m generally quite active and polite. But I have been called terrible town, an idiot and a Liar.
As recently as my last game.

But I’m looking forward to a great game with this player list.

I guess I townread Havo because of this.

I don't really think Havo should be townread for this post alone. Maybe the stuff he posted after explaining but I feel a post like that alone is on the edge of NAI (it's why I asked a few questions about it)

VOTE: katherine
Too many already.
btw I'm super excited about this playerlist

This being Gamma's only post so far looks terrible.

Why?

[MariaR]

Alright, Creature can be town.

Maybe but I dislike him thinking both kts and chill are town.

Because you disagree or?

[MariaR]

Fudgepops I should've popped on earlier but breakfast had me calling.
Creature Havo town so far
don't really understand the Tchi scumreads? Or at least the reasons brought up for why he's scum they feel rather weak.

[Gamma Emerald]

Hello Hello Hello.

Before I RVS vote, let me introduce myself.

I’m a mediocre mafia player at best who really dislikes Day 1s.
I’ve been known to quick hammer peeps on Day 1 if it’s just a day or two
Into the game to get the game moving.

I’m generally quite active and polite. But I have been called terrible town, an idiot and a Liar.
As recently as my last game.

But I’m looking forward to a great game with this player list.

Can we not excuse d1 quickhammers

Just because you're terrible doesn't mean you get to bring everyone else down

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: MariaR

A naked RVS vote? Why?
Also no one got my reference...

[Gamma Emerald]

Feeling like Harry Potter mash MS version.

Oh man what happened there

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: tchill

this has got to die. i rolled village btw glgl me

Well that's a bit aggressive.

this response by TChill kinda feels like he's confused but doesn't want to be like "whymefryme"

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: Maria

If you were a flower, you’d be a DAMNdelion

@havo why did you change your disclaimer from the last game?

Found my mason partner

Awesome post on page one man.

Elaborate?

VOTE: Katherine
Serious vote I feel like this was an obv joke/being sassy and from what i've seen scum are more then likely to take posts more seriusly because scum know people are town so there posts are legit...I prob could've explained this a bit better but yeah

Mhm, I think this seems very fair, but I have a question to ask
Katherine, how much mafia experience do you have?

[Gamma Emerald]

Oh. I signed up with a few mafia genuises lol.

Oh really? What makes you say that?

[Luca Blight]

I hard TR KTS and that's that.

Why?

Tell me exactly why scum start such a thing day 1? There's no reason for it. The most efficient way for scum to play that helps them in the long run is minimal stances day 1.

This is obviously BS, although I feel like he genuinely believes this.

Maybe so.

He's got a hard TR from me at the moment. That's really not anything to worry about seeing how it's not lylo atm.

I don't like how settled Tchill is on this read - Kill even admitted he plays like that as either alignment, but Tchill maintains his hard townread on these shaky grounds.

I'd say hard-townreading someone based on faulty reasoning is a cause for concern no matter how far into the game we are.

[Cedrick]

Alright, Creature can be town.

Maybe but I dislike him thinking both kts and chill are town.

Because you disagree or?

Yes. I’m leaning scum on kts and null on tchill. I’m not excluding this being scum theater either but I don’t know if I’m ready to commit to that theory so early.

[Cedrick]

Can we not excuse d1 quickhammers

I won’t be. Disclaimer or not I’ll be pushing a lynch on anyone who quick hammers without a claim. Unless it’s a scum flip, I’ll reward bad play if it benefits town.

[Gamma Emerald]

You're only voting mumble off meta aren't you?

Why are you voting with him then?