Spyfall - Pilot (Game Over - Spy Win)

[BuJaber]

For the purposes of my earlier sheeping comment these votes don't count unless they don't change after aro and NM answer.

Though of course deadline could arrive but if aro doesn't post withim 11 hours or so I'll take it as scumclaim.

[Katyusha]

beef btw if random didn't pick up his role pm you can delete it from your inbox and he'll never see it

[Beefster]

Official Vote Count 2 (will fill in later?)
Aronis (4): ...
...

Sorry. Don't have my vote counter...

Deadline: (expired on 2018-03-13 21:00:00)

[Katyusha]

Bless omfg

[the worst]

Dat extension tho<3

You're the best Beef

[Aronis]

When you've gotta, you've gotta. I avoided it for as long as I could though

@

Aronis

Felissan

could you please call a (lift/elevator) for me?

Nobody in their right mind would even think about making an elevator shaft here.

@Iconeum

When's the last time you came to another one of these?

Never been here before, luckily, and I hope it takes a while before I have to come here again.

Aronis

, did you have any trouble getting here?

Suspicions post coming up

It was a bit confusing to get here at first, but I've gotten more familiar now.

Seylenee, what color is the floor?

[Selynee]

A shade of earthy brown.

And to be fair, I am in no way sure who the spy is. I'm not voting Aronis, I really do think this is a mistake.

vote Ico

Fellisan gave some answers that I think would be more difficult to fake, I think Katyusha would have had to be very lucky.

[BuJaber]

Katy is never the spy lol.

Ask a question Sely?

[Selynee]

Ehh, I was actually inclined not to ask any other question, but at this point I doubt this would cause any more possible damage:

Ico

Should I bring my pet with me?

[BuJaber]

Everybody please vote for aro or NM I guess ... I'm not real happy yet but seems necessary.

Keeping mine on NM

[Katyusha]

selynee you should look over my last few posts to see why i townread ico

[Iconeum]

Like seriously, why would/should we come to a majority if nobody is happy with the choices? Town is divided bigtime, so I don't see how it's beneficial.

[gigabyteTroubadour]

i think adding a deadline was kind of a bad idea now reading the actual rules for spyfall, in the long run the best plan for us was to not ask questions in the first place and have force the spy to guess blind

no deadline forces a side to make a move

[Katyusha]

i think adding a deadline was kind of a bad idea now reading the actual rules for spyfall, in the long run the best plan for us was to not ask questions in the first place and have force the spy to guess blind

no deadline forces a side to make a move

AND IW AS

DOING SO WELL

[Iconeum]

Ehh, I was actually inclined not to ask any other question, but at this point I doubt this would cause any more possible damage:

Ico

Should I bring my pet with me?

Depends on the pet, but you should probably not bring a dog.

Aronis,

if you had the money, would you build a place like this?



Guys, if Aronis is the spy, and he sees he is being run up for a lynch, would he not be taking a guess?

[Katyusha]

doesnt that apply to anyone in a vacuum

[BuJaber]

The benefit is town consensus is a strong indicator. Wisdom of crowds and all that. While yes there isn't just one person that everyone agrees is the spy, more questions and answers will not give us a definite answer while giving more clues to spy. Especially if we agreed. Like if an answer or questions makes some of us go "okay it's definitely X" spy would have an easier time narrowing it down and he could easily guess before everyone has a chance to vote.

So no I think if we haven't agreed by now we just won't agree without exposing our location. So whataver wagon is winning we go with that.

If people confirm they're keeping their votes on aro that's already 4 people and I'll sheep. I assume Katy is so that's 1 vote on NM
1 vote on Aro
1 vote on Icon

[BuJaber]

Adding a deadline balances the game. Otherwise spy is screwed.

I think it should be deadline and if it is reached everyone is forced to vote without further questions. If they lynch spy they win. If they lynch wrong spy gets a guess.

While the game is going on voting and lynching can happen at any time and the spy can guess too. If during the game they lynch wrong spy wins without having to guess.

[Katyusha]

Yeah I see very little reason to move my vote atp

pedit: that's a good alternative as well

[Iconeum]

Only those aren't the rules for THIS game. If we take a wrong guess, it's game over. And I think we are too divided to take a chance, but that's personal opinion and all. If majority goes Aronis, I can dig that. Nobody else earns my vote, however.

[Katyusha]

maybe what we should do is read everyone in isolation and see if they figured out the location if spy

[the worst]

i think adding a deadline was kind of a bad idea now reading the actual rules for spyfall, in the long run the best plan for us was to not ask questions in the first place and have force the spy to guess blind

no deadline forces a side to make a move

AND IW AS

DOING SO WELL

WAS THIS AN ALT SLIP
BECAUSE
IF SO YOU ARE NOW TWO PEOPLE I LIKE

[Katyusha]

that way we know if we can risk voting

since if there are people who could reasonably not figure it out, then there's no point in risking it

i dont think this is the case however

pedit: how the FUCK do you already know me

[Katyusha]

and yes i was stalking the speakeasy for telephone pictionary related reasons, that's me

[the worst]

We met in discord 1 time you seemed chilled