Your game would be a lot easier if you actually fucking addressed my points instead of doing the asshole move of "OH I SEE SO EVERY POST YOU MAKE IS SCUM MOTIVATED"In post 221, MagnaofIllusion wrote:So is the point here you are more worried about not being perceived as playing to your scum meta?
As a theory this works fine as long as we can get consensus enough to get the selected two to pull the trigger.In post 187, CultOfAthena wrote:On an unrelated note, I've been thinking about it, and I think the best play is to always have two people who we think are either the scummiest or who we think are scum together be the ones to sacrifice. If they're both scum, neither will be able to sacrifice and we'll essentially have two guilties, and in the other situations (one town and one scum or two town), I don't think we're any worse off than if just one person was set to sacrifice.
FYI having done a quick game history dive on Chicka I’m just letting you know I acknowledge this point and am rethinking my earlier “Both can’t be partners” stance.In post 194, CultOfAthena wrote:I think this is a dangerous line of thinking to go down. Both Math and Chickadee herself have framed Chickadee as being lynchbait in response to my thinking she's scum, but I think a question that Chickadee has let go unanswered is a pretty important response to that idea:
Frankly it puts him under no pressure at all. In his shoes regardless of alignment I’d link you to the “My Topics” link for me and say “Have at it champ”. Which is what I would have done instead of asking him to do it if I were you and really interested in the answer. Takes time and patience but is honest meta-diving.In post 192, Mathdino wrote:Not all mods put the name of the user that filled the slot. Some games have replacement queues. I've filled slots before they go up on replacement requests.
Plus the question implicitly puts him under pressure and forces self-consciousness. Or, rather, it did before I got dogged for asking the question 3 times.
95-99% of what people consider “tells” are absolutely useless junk unless you are talking about VI level of play. And I don’t think Panther is a VI so, yeah, I find it a particularly useless exercise. I suspect you are going to find this a personal affront to your Mafia credibility but that’s where I stand.In post 192, Mathdino wrote:Some tells are useless altogether. Some tells vary from player to player. I think this COULD be alignment indicative, but I'd need to see how he replaces into games in general. It was a one off question, not the basis of my entire scumhunting.
Hey I’m on board with this plan as long as the lynched player is not the one to determine the list.In post 208, Mathdino wrote:Here's an example. If you lynch me, I will shoot Creature if and only if I see {Cult, Chick} and one of Bujaber/implosion.
If Creature dies in the morning, you know that Cult/Chick must contain scum. If one of them is town, you know Bujaber/implosion must contain scum.
If Creature DOESN'T die in the morning, you know that I did NOT see Cult/Chick/Buplosion, meaning that group must contain at least 2 town. This makes it optimal to lynch outside of that group, and force scummy people inside that group to sacrifice.
To put it delicately as I can regarding my thoughts on your opinion –In post 224, Mathdino wrote:e's terrible as vig, and doesn't really give a shit as town in my experience. My point is I don't think you really have the ability to read Not_Mafia
Listen I understand that you think you are the next big thing Math. I’ve seen at least 15 of you before over the years. I address posts as they come through the page-count.In post 225, Mathdino wrote:Your game would be a lot easier if you actually fucking addressed my points instead of doing the asshole move of "OH I SEE SO EVERY POST YOU MAKE IS SCUM MOTIVATED"
WHY WOULD YOU NOT LET THE SHOOTER DECIDE HOLY SHITIn post 230, MagnaofIllusion wrote:Hey I’m on board with this plan as long as the lynched player is not the one to determine the list.
This is absolutely ridiculous and if you think you can force me to go along with YOUR list after having reads so bad that I'm you're top scumread next to my top townreadIn post 230, MagnaofIllusion wrote:Creature – Not Mafia – Buj – Math / Chicka (whoever we don’t lynch).
In post 232, Not_Mafia wrote:Maybe you two should stop interacting cos no one wants to read this
Can you plainly and clearly go into those reads that you have? I can understand where you'd be coming from on MoI being town, but the rest not so much. Through some vague and mysterious process you arrived at NM being town and seem unwaveringly confident in that. I can't understand that, and it seems as if you expect me to, and I'm not sure why.In post 229, Mathdino wrote:Christ am I gonna have to play dumb or scum with the entire town
I am actually ashamed that the only townread I have that has good reads is Not_Mafia
Thor is good at scumhunting and has better than random reads
This is not thor