In post 147, Kookoobird wrote:This game is deliciously delightful so far, I'm glad people are participating enough to actually have strong reads!
My statement of "Lexa and TWIM are lock town. Lovebird is very probably scum." remains true. Lexa had a very townie entrance. A simple meta dive dictates that Lexa is a strategic and reserved player, and as far as I'm aware has not completed a town game on this site. At the least, hasn't on this alt. The page 1 posturing is extremely townie. Her continued light-hearted rhetoric is not resemblant of her scum game as far as I can tell either.
TWIM is less strong, but I firmly believe he is town. He is demonstrably incapable of being competent or "pro-town" as either alignment, this is true. However, his confidence, attitude, and stances this game all ring very hard town. I have not meta-dived TWIM and do not have time for the entire playerlist - Lexa specifically earned one for the entrance. His pushes seem logical and alright - for example, in isolation Lexa's entrance would look scummy (I thought so too which is why I did some research!) and that comment is fine. I believe him to be genuine. Also, RB is a good vote.
Lovebird's a tank of doggy doodoo. As far as I can remember, virtually all of their posts have been quite bad. Their #26 is a bad reaction to a statement that has no indication of my alignment, however I doubt they know who I am so that's not really alignment indicative for Lovebird either. Their #30, however, makes it much worse. Any confidence I am scum from that post is not realistic nor genuine, and indicates to me they are fabricating a push on what is seemingly a new player. Their #58 is scummy, but it is not pro-town to state why so either you figure it out on your own or tough titties. Their #138 is posturing, but unlike Lexa it is scummy as heck this time. Overall, I have not liked a single post from this iso and have strongly disliked the majority. Lovebird can be the lynch of the day.
RB and Screenplay are scummy.
Tchill and MortFeld are townie.
Heyoka is hard null, but if they're town RB, Pisskop, Screenplay, Tchill contains 2 scum.
Pisskop, eth0s, Not Known 15, and Mohab have no tangible content.
VOTE: lovebird
This is a really important post. One thing to note is that this post reserves basically no content and makes no sense. It seems like something, but after rereading, I don't actually understand this. The reasons don't make sense either, it seems like a lot of words that are basically worthless. However, it can be alignment indicative, so let's break this down.
My statement of "Lexa and TWIM are lock town. Lovebird is very probably scum." remains true. Lexa had a very townie entrance. A simple meta dive dictates that Lexa is a strategic and reserved player, and as far as I'm aware has not completed a town game on this site. At the least, hasn't on this alt. The page 1 posturing is extremely townie. Her continued light-hearted rhetoric is not resemblant of her scum game as far as I can tell either.
During the night phase, I believed Lexa to be town, mainly on tone. I scumread TWIM, mainly on tone aswell.
Turns out Lexa is a townie, which made it tough for me to check through TWIM and lovebird. I don't believe scum would start a wagon on his ally so early in the game, so I don't particualary think his scumreads will make much use.
TWIM is less strong, but I firmly believe he is town. He is demonstrably incapable of being competent or "pro-town" as either alignment, this is true. However, his confidence, attitude, and stances this game all ring very hard town. I have not meta-dived TWIM and do not have time for the entire playerlist - Lexa specifically earned one for the entrance. His pushes seem logical and alright - for example, in isolation Lexa's entrance would look scummy (I thought so too which is why I did some research!) and that comment is fine. I believe him to be genuine. Also, RB is a good vote.
I am incapable of really understanding the reasoning here, because I am too stupid to understand the wording? (again). But what we know is that TWIM was townread by kookoo.
Lovebird's a tank of doggy doodoo. As far as I can remember, virtually all of their posts have been quite bad. Their #26 is a bad reaction to a statement that has no indication of my alignment, however I doubt they know who I am so that's not really alignment indicative for Lovebird either. Their #30, however, makes it much worse. Any confidence I am scum from that post is not realistic nor genuine, and indicates to me they are fabricating a push on what is seemingly a new player. Their #58 is scummy, but it is not pro-town to state why so either you figure it out on your own or tough titties. Their #138 is posturing, but unlike Lexa it is scummy as heck this time. Overall, I have not liked a single post from this iso and have strongly disliked the majority. Lovebird can be the lynch of the day.
I am not sure I understand why he's scumreading Lovebird, but from what I see from the ISO's, both lovebird and TWIM have similar playstyles. You'd think a genuine player would townread players of similar playstyles atleast to a similar degree. This makes me feel like either TWIM and lovebird are both town or both scum. The reads are reeking random bullshit though, which is an issue.
RB and Screenplay are scummy.
Tchill and MortFeld are townie.
I believe one player from these 4 is scum, I'd think the townread players are more likely to be scum here.
Heyoka is hard null, but if they're town RB, Pisskop, Screenplay, Tchill contains 2 scum.
Kookoo knows Heyoka is town, which makes me feel he won't really put an ally on that list. But then again, I scumread Screenplay earlier, and wasn't really liking Tchill, so I am not sure.
Pisskop, eth0s, Not Known 15, and Mohab have no tangible content.
I was quite Null on all of these (except myself ofcourse), but I believe the last scum has to be from here if we're going by POE.
