Large Normal 211: Scientific Mafia

[Pine]

its 2018 and people still fall for daykill gambits on page 7 omg

Right?

To be fair, it's just people new to the meta. I wouldn't have tried that on you. I wanted to pick someone from the neighborhood to try it on, and inferno was the only one new enough not to immediately call bullshit.

Like I said, though, maintaining claim is NAI. Even newscum have a good chance of calling the bluff, and may be coached if they have daychat.

[Firebringer]

BRING IT ON FIREBRINGER!

Don’t know what ur expecting here

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: Pine
since his kill was fake I see no reason to not vote him because the gambit legit does jack shit to make him look towny

Yeah, it's not about me. It's about provoking a hard-to-read newbie into maybe making a newbie mistake. Only scum worries about looking Townie.

Come on, Gamma. You're smart enough to know this stuff.

It's not that you wanted to look towny, it's that your gambit doesn't make me feel any better about you. I'm basically saying "my read has changed 0%".

[Gamma Emerald]

Why do you think scum would drop a neighbor claim after a dayvig? That's just nonsense.

[Pine]

Why do you think scum would drop a neighbor claim after a dayvig? That's just nonsense.

The neighbor claim is irrelevant. Some scum, when they get hammered or dayvigged, just gg and fess up to being scum. That's what I was looking for.

Seriously. You've been around enough to know this. Quit being obtuse.

[Theta Alpine]

Why do you think scum would drop a neighbor claim after a dayvig? That's just nonsense.

The neighbor claim is irrelevant. Some scum, when they get hammered or dayvigged, just gg and fess up to being scum. That's what I was looking for.

Seriously. You've been around enough to know this. Quit being obtuse.

this is a thing

and i will give pine a slight town read
though i probably would have waited longer before outing it

[Gamma Emerald]

Why do you think scum would drop a neighbor claim after a dayvig? That's just nonsense.

The neighbor claim is irrelevant. Some scum, when they get hammered or dayvigged, just gg and fess up to being scum. That's what I was looking for.

Seriously. You've been around enough to know this. Quit being obtuse.

Okay I read it wrong then.

[Gamma Emerald]

Hey Theta
You gonna give any thoughts on anything else Pine has posted
or are you just going to say "yeah Pine is right"

[Theta Alpine]

later
once i have time to look at it

[Theta Alpine]

okay now that i look at it

pine called inferno town
and then two posts [iso wise] later he does the fake day kill
which does undermine the effect of the gambit

[Firebringer]

I think pine is town.
People who disagree r dumb

[Gamma Emerald]

I think pine is scum.
People who disagree r dumb

[Theta Alpine]

if you two could have an argument and actually make statements supporting your conclusions that would be nice and helpful and alignment indicative

[Gamma Emerald]

I have already stated which posts of Pine's I am scumreading and why

[Theta Alpine]

i was actually speaking to both of you
not every part of that statement applied to both people that statement targeted

[Firebringer]

if you two could have an argument and actually make statements supporting your conclusions that would be nice and helpful and alignment indicative

Mafia isn’t science

[Theta Alpine]

it can be treated as one

[Nosferatu]

if you two could have an argument and actually make statements supporting your conclusions that would be nice and helpful and alignment indicative

you're a riot

how do you feel about the fact that neither party wants to do that.

[Theta Alpine]

that is also alignment indicative
though i am not sure how specifically
depends on if multiball is actually true this game or not

[Pine]

okay now that i look at it

pine called inferno town
and then two posts [iso wise] later he does the fake day kill
which does undermine the effect of the gambit

Actually, what I said was that he was being too obvscum to be scum. The inherent uncertainty makes him a perfect target for a fakevig gambit. Or, frankly, a real vig. Never vig/cop people you have solid SRs on, lynch them. Cop or vig the people you're unsure of and have contradictory evidence on.

that is also alignment indicative
though i am not sure how specifically
depends on if multiball is actually true this game or not

My gut says multiball, though singleball is possible.

To be perfectly honest, my crystal ball says 13/3/3/1, with solid scum power probably consisting of a weak investigate and weak protective on either side, a 1-shot BP SK, and middling Town power that includes a Vig.

[Flubbernugget]

TIAM is probably town

Not if there's daytalk

[Flubbernugget]

Actually, the context of the game I'm thinking about probabaly isn't applicable here

[Firebringer]

it can be treated as one

Only if ur a moron

[Flubbernugget]

Nah I’m not feeling Boon.

I think y’all just annoyed because you can’t trust him until he’s been copped by confirmed town.

?? We can't trust him then either

[Firebringer]

Flubber I’m still waiting for a hi.

The longer this takes the more I assume ur scum