Only reason I'm not voting Tchill right now is that Katherine/Tchill looks basically impossible, so I want to try and work out if I'm missing something.
The votecounts in 350/400 don't happen with a Tchill/Kat/Mumble scumteam.
Tchill shouldn't push a newbie as much as he did Kat D1.
Now possible scum bussing in order to most likely to least likely would be
Creature/mumble/havo/gamma/hopkirk
Why is mumble lock town? The claim? He hasn't said specific players he tracked has he? He's lacked detail on his night actions.
Creature has been laughably defended (don't start gamma lol)
Of my lock town I'm most skeptical about havo/gamma
Hopkirk is lock lock town for me. He's a candidate for my tinfoil hat theory that's always wrong. Basically he seen he could pick up my initial push on day 2 to lynch Luca and keep me around for scum to lynch layer. Like I said I believe hopkirk is town though.
@Gamma: what are your thoughts on the following two votecount points:
The 5 votes on Katherine changing to 5 on Implosion
Ausuka staying at 3 votes just short of the tipping point for a long time
In post 2422, Tchill13 wrote:So yes it's stupid to say scum didn't bus we simply don't know. They COULD have but I think it's stupid if they did, that doesn't matter though.
I think it's completely logical to say if one scum did bus then one probably contributed to the counter wagon. I have a hard time believing 2 scum bussed.
So out of the players that didn't bus my list is flavor/ausuka/(cedrick/kookoo) in most to least likely scum.
One of them HAVE TO BE SCUM.
Out of those that did bus creature would be my guess.
: Cedrick is V/LA until Monday.
Luca Blight is V/LA until Wednesday
Now possible scum bussing in order to most likely to least likely would be
Creature/mumble/havo/gamma/hopkirk
Why is mumble lock town? The claim? He hasn't said specific players he tracked has he? He's lacked detail on his night actions.
Creature has been laughably defended (don't start gamma lol)
Of my lock town I'm most skeptical about havo/gamma
Hopkirk is lock lock town for me. He's a candidate for my tinfoil hat theory that's always wrong. Basically he seen he could pick up my initial push on day 2 to lynch Luca and keep me around for scum to lynch layer. Like I said I believe hopkirk is town though.
I think your logic on whether scum bussed is fine. As for your suspects Your suspect list also looks pretty okay, I'm honestly just going to stop defending Creature because he seems to have given up on the game himself. I won't put him in the scumpool because his prior efforts were okay but I don't like locktowning someone who won't obvtown.
<Embrace The Void>
“A flipped coin doesn't always land heads or tails. Sometimes it may never land at all...”
In post 2446, Hopkirk wrote:@Gamma: what are your thoughts on the following two votecount points:
The 5 votes on Katherine changing to 5 on Implosion
Ausuka staying at 3 votes just short of the tipping point for a long time
quotes pls
<Embrace The Void>
“A flipped coin doesn't always land heads or tails. Sometimes it may never land at all...”