Large Normal 211: Scientific Mafia

[Theta Alpine]

by the way, do none of you read mafia discussion

Ascetic Miller

Boonskiies came up with this idea, and it struck me as so amusing I asked and received permission to share it here.

did you notice that boonskiies was the one who claimed it

what? i don't understand your implication here. i said this because people seemed to be assuming that the claim was anything but a joke / fakeclaim.

oh

i said that because i thought you were implying that it was not a joke / fakeclaim

[northsidegal]

I’m applying meta from a 20 player game actually, nice try to pretend I’m using different games tho lol

If you're talking about anything upick, i played an incredibly lurky, surface level game there – i don't know where your comparison is coming from then.

Why do you assume that i'm "pretending" that you're using meta from other games? From my pov that's the most reasonable assumption, because if you were going off of anything upick then i don't think what you're saying makes sense.

[Firebringer]

I’m applying meta from a 20 player game actually, nice try to pretend I’m using different games tho lol

If you're talking about anything upick, i played an incredibly lurky, surface level game there – i don't know where your comparison is coming from then.

Why do you assume that i'm "pretending" that you're using meta from other games? From my pov that's the most reasonable assumption, because if you were going off of anything upick then i don't think what you're saying makes sense.

That was surface level?

[Firebringer]

And I assume u pretend that because you basically seemed to try to discredit my meta read by applying a standard to it that didn’t apply, which then you did again by saying that other game was surface level like ur game here which is odd to me tbh

[Firebringer]

I’m applying meta from a 20 player game actually, nice try to pretend I’m using different games tho lol

If you're talking about anything upick, i played an incredibly lurky, surface level game there – i don't know where your comparison is coming from then.

Why do you assume that i'm "pretending" that you're using meta from other games? From my pov that's the most reasonable assumption, because if you were going off of anything upick then i don't think what you're saying makes sense.

This is kind of townie from you tho

[northsidegal]

I assume even if this is just catch up you would have questions for gamma since u scumread, did I miss something or is this incorrect assessment?

i scumread gamma for

how

he's playing this game, not necessarily for any sort of logical inconsistencies or things that don't make sense as is the basis for many
of my scumreads in other games. also, again – i was focused more on catching up than responding to things specifically. i planned to form reads and then go from here as a starting point keeping up with the thread. you jumping in and voting me for not having questions yet seems incredibly premature.

I’m applying meta from a 20 player game actually, nice try to pretend I’m using different games tho lol

If you're talking about anything upick, i played an incredibly lurky, surface level game there – i don't know where your comparison is coming from then.

Why do you assume that i'm "pretending" that you're using meta from other games? From my pov that's the most reasonable assumption, because if you were going off of anything upick then i don't think what you're saying makes sense.

That was surface level?

i mean, i consider it one of my worst town games. i don't think i played very well there at all. i spent too much time trying to be cute with my role and not enough actually doing anything in-thread.

[northsidegal]

And I assume u pretend that because you basically seemed to try to discredit my meta read by applying a standard to it that didn’t apply, which then you did again by saying that other game was surface level like ur game here which is odd to me tbh

i assumed you weren't using anything upick as meta because i would assume that nobody would ever use that game as meta for a scumread on me.

[Firebringer]

i scumread gamma for how he's playing this game, not necessarily for any sort of logical inconsistencies or things that don't make sense as is the basis for many
of my scumreads in other games. also, again – i was focused more on catching up than responding to things specifically. i planned to form reads and then go from here as a starting point keeping up with the thread. you jumping in and voting me for not having questions yet seems incredibly premature.

I am also scumreading you for specific phrases and things I don’t think ur conscious and I’m not really going to go into those so ur aware of them.

My read is still scum on you but I’m not 100

[Firebringer]

I need to redo a meta dive to see if I’m full of my own shit too tbh

[Theta Alpine]

huh

this honestly feels rehearsed and like scum theatre
so i am going to go ahead and scum-read northsidegal and firebringer

of the two i do not have a preference and since i just noticed the rules do not forbid this

if 1 i will vote northsidegal
if 2 i will vote firebringer

Original Roll String: 1d2

1 2-Sided Dice: (1) = 1

[i look forward to this being used as an example of why provable randomness should/should not be allowed]

[Gamma Emerald]

scumleaning pine for 128

scumreading gamma for 161

inferno can be town for 166

if you want explanations just ask, focused more on catching up than typing all my thoughts out

You're gonna have to explain what makes you scumread me. Just referring to that post isn't helpful because there's a lot there.

[Theta Alpine]

VOTE: firebringer

[Inferno390]

What about PeregrineV, Theta? What do you think about his lack of activity?

P-edit: My gut reaction says that this wall is either SvT or SvS.

[Pine]

Okay yeah northside is scum lol

Yarp. Took the words right out of my mouth. "Surface level" is an excellent way to describe it.

VOTE: northsidegal

Stay on Target, Red Five. BoonFlavor is the lynch today. We can string NSG up tomorrow.

[Pine]

huh

this honestly feels rehearsed and like scum theatre

No it does not. Scum theatre isn't usually this petty or simple.

[Gamma Emerald]

by the way, do none of you read mafia discussion

Ascetic Miller

Boonskiies came up with this idea, and it struck me as so amusing I asked and received permission to share it here.

*raises hand*

[Inferno390]

I could lynch NSG on meta here. Like, I know the only game I've been in with her was Newbie, but compared to that game, this just seems off for her.

[Gamma Emerald]

oh lol i pulled a gamma and responded to something before reading like two posts down

Well

thanks

I'm trying to fix that you know

[Inferno390]

VOTE: NSG
Probably going to move my vote if the lynch is impeding, but I'm comfortable with this for now.

Anyone got a vote count?

[Gamma Emerald]

Rather than doing her typical probing for an understanding of the players all these posts from nsg is doing is very surface level.
Not Townnsg at all.

Even her “I can go into more if requested” doesn’t sound Town her.
I understand ur doing catchup but you usually have questions for people you scumread.
Where’s the questions for gamma?

I think this is a fair analysis, her SR on me feels so bare-bones and honestly kinda forced

[Firebringer]

huh

this honestly feels rehearsed and like scum theatre
so i am going to go ahead and scum-read northsidegal and firebringer

of the two i do not have a preference and since i just noticed the rules do not forbid this

if 1 i will vote northsidegal
if 2 i will vote firebringer

Original Roll String: 1d2 (STATIC)

1 2-Sided Dice: (2) = 2

[i look forward to this being used as an example of why provable randomness should/should not be allowed]

Ummm I don’t know if I should just tell u ur dumb or what.

But what about me makes you assume that I would reverse anything with a teammate.

Unless you think it went like this:
Nsg: hey let’s do some distancing
Firebringer: sure

[Theta Alpine]

What about PeregrineV, Theta? What do you think about his lack of activity?

P-edit: My gut reaction says that this wall is either SvT or SvS.

if they have not posted in the game yet then i have no thoughts
it could be svt but i still lean towards svs

huh

this honestly feels rehearsed and like scum theatre

No it does not. Scum theatre isn't usually this petty or simple.

i never said they were doing it correctly
just that from the timing and general feel it felt rehearsed and that they had more than one thread to talk in

[Firebringer]

But what about me makes you assume that I would reverse anything with a teammate.

This is supposed to say rehearsal

[Theta Alpine]

huh

this honestly feels rehearsed and like scum theatre
so i am going to go ahead and scum-read northsidegal and firebringer

of the two i do not have a preference and since i just noticed the rules do not forbid this

if 1 i will vote northsidegal
if 2 i will vote firebringer

Original Roll String: 1d2 (STATIC)

1 2-Sided Dice: (2) = 2

[i look forward to this being used as an example of why provable randomness should/should not be allowed]

Ummm I don’t know if I should just tell u ur dumb or what.

But what about me makes you assume that I would rehearse anything with a teammate.

Unless you think it went like this:
Nsg: hey let’s do some distancing
Firebringer: sure

it probably went more like
north said that they had been lurking and that someone could get a good town read off of a push on him
and you agreed

[TwoInAMillion]

I agree with Pine.