Large Normal 211: Scientific Mafia

[Quick]

UNVOTE:

[Quick]

Oh, yeah, Gamma seems a bit wooden to me.

[Gamma Emerald]

can someone tell me what the fuck they find suspicious about beef because I think he's town and no one has given a solid read other than like nsg and even then I didn't get much out of it

[Archwing]

your vote is/was on Profii. probably worth iso-ing him.. slightly controversial slot. highly townread by some, yet holds the current wagon.

[Inferno390]

Definitely agreeing on Red. The fact that he's gone so quiet bothers me.

[Egg]

Anyone wanna help me Lynch TwoInAMillion? I really don't like either of the top two wagons.

[Quick]

can someone tell me what the fuck they find suspicious about beef because I think he's town and no one has given a solid read other than like nsg and even then I didn't get much out of it

Some of the things he has said has been a big "wut?" to me. I can try and fish out quotes but I think he said somethings that just don't make any Goddamn sense.

[Gamma Emerald]

can someone tell me what the fuck they find suspicious about beef because I think he's town and no one has given a solid read other than like nsg and even then I didn't get much out of it

Some of the things he has said has been a big "wut?" to me. I can try and fish out quotes but I think he said somethings that just don't make any Goddamn sense.

Idk I feel like what he's said is sensible and also feels natural

[Inferno390]

We should be lynching in either of the Flavors, Profii, TIAM, and to a lesser extent Mulch and Beef unless something drastic happens, I doubt I'll be voting anywhere else today. I'm not going to be placing a vote at this point however. I want to see what else develops.
I also agree with Quick that Gamma feels wooden, but it doesn't feel "scum" wooden. Just odd.

[profii]

Sorry busy at work. Will be catching up over the course of the weekend

Can someone summarise why I am the wagon right now

If it’s the UCV thing I just wanted him to play, now that’s mulch(?) and he is posting, I’m good to move on. I am sure there is plenty for me to look at now so I’ll get a vote /read sorted in the next 24 hours

[profii]

We should be lynching in either of the Flavors, Profii, TIAM, and to a lesser extent Mulch and Beef unless something drastic happens, I doubt I'll be voting anywhere else today. I'm not going to be placing a vote at this point however. I want to see what else develops.
I also agree with Quick that Gamma feels wooden, but it doesn't feel "scum" wooden. Just odd.

How will things develop if you don’t vote?

[Gamma Emerald]

can someone tell me what wooden even means
also profii why did you let UCV go just because he flaked, I thought you'd brought something up about him not liking scum

[profii]

I said he doesn’t like RVS so wondered if he was lurking through it and my vote was a signal of right that’s passed now come play otherwise lurking is poop

[TwoInAMillion]

I disagree with most of Inferno's read list.

VOTE: Inferno

[Gamma Emerald]

I disagree with most of Inferno's read list.

VOTE: Inferno

And that's a reason to lynch him? Also I feel like Inferno's kinda been obvtown

[TwoInAMillion]

I disagree with most of Inferno's read list.

VOTE: Inferno

And that's a reason to lynch him? Also I feel like Inferno's kinda been obvtown

Yeah, I don't feel he's obvtown, and a bad read list can lead to lynching town.

[Gamma Emerald]

I disagree with most of Inferno's read list.

VOTE: Inferno

And that's a reason to lynch him? Also I feel like Inferno's kinda been obvtown

Yeah, I don't feel he's obvtown, and a bad read list can lead to lynching town.

Again: bad reads are not scummy

[Quick]

I disagree with most of Inferno's read list.

VOTE: Inferno

This is gross.

[TwoInAMillion]

I disagree with most of Inferno's read list.

VOTE: Inferno

And that's a reason to lynch him? Also I feel like Inferno's kinda been obvtown

Yeah, I don't feel he's obvtown, and a bad read list can lead to lynching town.

Again: bad reads are not scummy

They can be. If I'm scum and I purposefully list all town as my reads how is that not scummy?

[TwoInAMillion]

I disagree with most of Inferno's read list.

VOTE: Inferno

This is gross.

Explain.

[Gamma Emerald]

I disagree with most of Inferno's read list.

VOTE: Inferno

And that's a reason to lynch him? Also I feel like Inferno's kinda been obvtown

Yeah, I don't feel he's obvtown, and a bad read list can lead to lynching town.

Again: bad reads are not scummy

They can be. If I'm scum and I purposefully list all town as my reads how is that not scummy?

it's not scummy because there isn't any malice shown in the reads yet. Show me how Inferno is pushing mislynches as scum vs just being wrong town.

[profii]

I feel like this point about bad reads applies to TIAM so I’m not intending on lynching there

[Gamma Emerald]

depends on how he carries on from here

[Mulch]

VOTE: pine

[Quick]

I disagree with most of Inferno's read list.

VOTE: Inferno

This is gross.

Explain.

Even SRing someone for having a Reads list that is different than yours is pushing it pretty hard. Definitely not vote worthy. Like, in order for you to know that their reads are wrong in the first place either you have to be Scum or have perfect reads and it's fucking D1, so someone having a readslist you don't agree with and voting them for that is such garbage it's not even funny.

Plus you are being really results oriented and assuming your reads are correct for your read to have any merit whatsoever and both are not a good way to get a read. It's also an extremely shallow read considering you would first have to know the players reasons for each of their reads in their readslist and then have to refute their reasoning for each one which you are not doing at all.