Open 720: NOIR (GAME OVER)

[ceejayvinoya]

He's an unashamed troll and he's beautiful.

He is literally unreadable, literally naked lolhammers at will as either alignment, etc., etc. I'm also jealous because I'm not as cool as him so yeah

At what point does playing with someone who basically never posts become fun?

They have played with N_M before. Maybe he was less of a lurker then?

[the worst]

Depends what you get a kick out of, he's unreadable but often hilarious. c:
We should policy lynch if things go south and a vig should shoot him

Ftr Korina PR hunting is gross I missed that earlier

IRO townreads I agree. Though I would argue if a townblock is forming and you disagreed with one of them (we have established he was scumleaning me and just didn't realise he shoule have said that) I can see a townie asking people they townread to help them reevaluate how they reached a different conclusion. I do this myself when I feel like I could be anti town cohesiveness

[ceejayvinoya]

Ummm what is IRO?

[the worst]

In respect of

[Iconeum]

VOTE: mutant

[Sando]

Oh shit, they're multiplying

[the worst]

ICONEUM SAY SOMETHING

He's not a troll just an occasional minimalist. It's NAI unfortately. He's busy irl.

[Sando]

He's not a troll just an occasional minimalist.

This has gotta be one of my favourite descriptors ever

[Iconeum]

He's not a troll just an occasional minimalist.

This has gotta be one of my favourite descriptors ever

I hope, one day, this becomes my Title on this site.

'Occasional minimalist'.

Absolutely beautiful.

[Iconeum]

Also, that's not a naked vote. It's a pressure vote on mutant to explain my question on the previous page.

[the worst]

He'll do it.

Your naked pressurevotes are scary as shit. Lemme find Earthbound's

[Sando]

Also, that's not a naked vote. It's a pressure vote on mutant to explain my question on the previous page.

Fair, to give him credit he was pretty good with responding to me, so we'll see.

[the worst]

He does respond generally yeah

[the worst]

Spoiler: not relevant but I hope Ico enjoys this memory

Subject: Mini 1993 - Earthbound Mafia: Giygas' Curse - GAME OVER

I love being scumread as any alignment

Inferno do you agree that some players have meta that makes them seem scummy regardless of alignment?

What is the goal of this question?

If a player made like 75% scummy sounding posts and 25% Townie sounding posts how would you define them?

What is the goal of this question?

Inferno:

I would define them as "not very good at playing mafia."

l0l

You are actually probably scum.

That's a pretty sure statement you make here. IB has posted quite a bit already. Make a case on him?

Subject: Mini 1993 - Earthbound Mafia: Giygas' Curse - GAME OVER

@Ico some of that I can answer, some of it I can't yet. I'll get back to you asap.

Subject: Mini 1993 - Earthbound Mafia: Giygas' Curse - GAME OVER

actually eeehhh

Subject: Mini 1993 - Earthbound Mafia: Giygas' Curse - GAME OVER

You seem nervous

Subject: Mini 1993 - Earthbound Mafia: Giygas' Curse - GAME OVER

ur a vry scary dragon Ico

Subject: Mini 1993 - Earthbound Mafia: Giygas' Curse - GAME OVER

VOTE: the worst

Subject: Mini 1993 - Earthbound Mafia: Giygas' Curse - GAME OVER

VOTE: the worst

Actually freaked me tf out

[Iconeum]

Are you guys worried I caught your scumbuddy?

Also, lol

[the worst]

Are you guys worried I caught your scumbuddy?

Pls, that would imply you've actually done something

[Korina]

Motherfuck, you guys have a lot to say. I skimmed through thread.
I'll

hopefully

have something worthwhile within the next week, assuming EOC review doesn't kill me.

In post 346, the worst wrote:
I always forget about night phases. vig should 100% shoot NM up


What do you mean by this? Are you implying you know for a fact there is a vigi in the game?

Do you think this is a slip? Why?

I'm not sure what I'm making of this post. I get the thought process behind it, (there being a 50/50 shot of it being vigi), however, I don't understand the context/meaning behind it.

[the worst]

In post 387, the worst wrote:
In post 372, Korina wrote:
In post 346, the worst wrote:
I always forget about night phases. vig should 100% shoot NM up


What do you mean by this? Are you implying you know for a fact there is a vigi in the game?

Do you think this is a slip? Why?


I'm not sure what I'm making of this post. I get the thought process behind it, (there being a 50/50 shot of it being vigi), however, I don't understand the context/meaning behind it.

Whaaaaat

[Iconeum]

Are you guys worried I caught your scumbuddy?

Pls, that would imply you've actually done something

So you are saying that you are not worried that I caught your scumbuddy?

[Iconeum]

the worst, did you try to pocket me with quoting that from Earthbound? Because it worked.

[the worst]

Lmfao. Nah. You should do something though.

[mutantdevle]

Please keep in mind for my next few posts (and my posts for the entirety of Friday) that I woke up at 10 AM on Thursday and haven't slept since. I'm currently at the point where my brain is only functioning because the daylight is tricking it into working. I still post when I'm tired in mafia but I do have a tendency to interpret things wrong and make several logical fallacies. So please just calmly explain to me that I'm wrong if that happens instead of going full-blown "YOU MIS REPPING SCUMMY BASTARD!!" on my ass like has happened in previous games.

So I'm just catching up on everything that happened last night but I'd rather summarise my thoughts on it in 1 post rather than fill up half a page:


"The game is long, and I'll get to different slots as I get to them." -Oxy
Ehh, in my opinion there's no reason why you can't be simultaneously trying to sort everyone at once but you do you I guess.

Sando I disagree that scum wouldn't have strong town reads at the start of the game, especially if they are familiar with the player list (I'm uncertain if anyone here is mostly familiar with this player list though).

On one hand, I do think Sando shouldn't be too critical of Oxy for something he isn't criticising the worst for but on the other I can see why Sando would give the worst a free pass on it given his confidence in town reading him. However, I do think it's good to criticise one's own town reads when they need criticising because that's how you keep your reads solid IMO.

I agree with a fair bit of Oxy's 427 but I'm thinking that just maybe shows Sando's slightly outdated scum tells?

Honestly, I can see Oxy's logic behind his Fumuki read, not so sure that's something to place too much confidence in though.

the worst I at you describing something as concern vs topic, Oxy then asking you what you meant by that, and then you replying by asking him what his interpretation of it was... That just makes no sense to me. Can you not just answer what concern vs topic means? Like genuinely though, could you elaborate what it means because I genuinely have no idea and the wiki yielded no results.

the worst's 437 I can somewhat agree with but only about specific reads of his. Like, some reads he does appear to have confidence in whereas others he still considers the possibility that he is completely wrong. Reminds me of myself tbh (and I've been criticised for it before so I can understand you criticising it in Oxy).

About the worst's helpfulness not being AI, didn't the worst straight up admit that he is helpful as either alignment earlier in the game? I don't get why there's an argument over this.

-Damn those 3 AM posts of mine are embarrassing-

Sando, I do think scum are able to reasonably backtrack on their strong town reads. Usually, this can be done over a period of time, however, sometimes it can look natural to suddenly 180 your read on someone based on single posts since this is a natural thing that some townies do. As scum, you just gotta find a post of theirs that looks kinda scummy and blow that up so that everyone else either finds it scummy too or, at the very least, understands why you'd find it scummy. Of course, naturally everyone takes a bit of heat for sudden read changes, but this can easily be brushed off if you know what you're doing.


Meh, so I think the Sando/the worst/Oxy squabbling is entirely town arguing amongst themselves. At most, I can see there being 1 scum in those 3, but no more than that. I liked some of the interjections within this by Quick and ceejay bit I still feel like they were taking the sideline a bit. The argument was mostly the worst and Sando vs Oxy but I could tell that Quick was more on Oxy's side and somewhat defended him but I can't help but feel like his attitude was to not get too associated with it all. It also concerns me that Quick would be kinda quiet during this considering his earlier eager posting.

[Spartan117]

I know it's rude, but if you think you can't make up time to be here in a near future, maybe it's better to replace than doing anti-prod posts...

I agree, I'm really sorry guys, and Alonzo :/ I am just unable to keep up with the pace of the game with everything going on irl right now, so I think it would be better if i did place out and you got someone who is able to properly contribute as its not fair on you guys.

Mod can you replace me out please, sorry this is a pace I am just really not used to, best of luck everyone

[mutantdevle]

Oh cool so Quick got more active and critical of the argument the next page (20)

[Mathdino]

I know it's rude, but if you think you can't make up time to be here in a near future, maybe it's better to replace than doing anti-prod posts...

I agree, I'm really sorry guys, and Alonzo :/ I am just unable to keep up with the pace of the game with everything going on irl right now, so I think it would be better if i did place out and you got someone who is able to properly contribute as its not fair on you guys.

Mod can you replace me out please, sorry this is a pace I am just really not used to, best of luck everyone

Thanks for letting me know.

Searching for replacement for Spartan117.