Grand Idea Mafia Overdrive - Werewolf + NicoRobin wins

[Radical Rat]

Giving nero two kills kills 3 townies

[Nero Cain]

Why is it more likely that Mulch is scum than Vax?
Why is wanting to know who shot Town (and apparently wants to hide it) before nearly any actual content scummy?

I don't feel like knowing who shot Maria is going to be all that helpful in the long run. OTH, I could kinda see scum wanting to know more about their surroundings.

Sure, it's not impossible that Vax was told to shoot his scumbuddy but I don't think its very likely that Vax is scum.

If I were scum I'd want this plan to happen, just not with me as the hammer.

what if I were right and I had you and your scumbuddies listed as possible kills, would you still want it?

[Nero Cain]

Then maybe ya'll should try to convince me to kill other ppl but its not like Mulch is a pro-town player even if town and you're just scum hiding behind his fat ant-town ass.

[Mulch]

I LITERALLY TOLD A DAYVIG TO SHOOT SCUM

how more pro town can you get

[Nero Cain]

you could easily do that for town cred. Its not this impossibility you are claiming it is.

[Mulch]

Even if I’m scum that was pro town lol

Stop (although I admit this has the potential to be a pointless request) being suing

[Radical Rat]

Based on your interactions this game and your apparent history, I don't think convincing you not to shoot Mulch is possible.

[Nero Cain]

Like I was trying to get an Arc wagon together and you were busy budding Koki and you didn't give 2 shits about the wagon on you. Even if all the town that was voting you was wrong you should atleast look in the mirror and say "hry, ppl dislike me enough to wagon me. I need to work on myself." but I doubt thats something you'd be able to do.

[Mulch]

Wat

[Radical Rat]

Like.
Yes, it's possible that given the opportunity to have any player killed, scum!Mulch chose to kill his partner for towncred, even with several other lurksacks to choose from that probably wouldn't have gotten him in much trouble.

It is also possible that Vax was scum and was content to kill anybody with Mulch as a scapegoat for town shots or free towncred for scum shots.

It is also possible that they're both just really lucky Town.

It is also possible that they're both Scum and planned to share in the towncred from killing their buddy.

Regardless of the situation leading up to it, dead scum is a pro-town result, and that's just a fact. Killing three town with one lynch is anti-town.

[Mulch]

Honestly I might do the dunker strategy on Nero’s reads

[Radical Rat]

What's the dunker strategy?

[Nero Cain]

Why are Dave, Taly and Eddie town?

[Radical Rat]

Why are Dave, Taly and Eddie town?

I don't actually know whether they are or not. All three slots need to post more.
But if any of them are scum, they won't be hammering you, so it doesn't matter what I read them as now.

[Mulch]

What's the dunker strategy?

Reverse readslist

[Radical Rat]

If I were scum I'd want this plan to happen, just not with me as the hammer.

what if I were right and I had you and your scumbuddies listed as possible kills, would you still want it?

Depends on how big the scumteam is.
In a small team, no probably not.
In a larger team, say 5 or so, it might be worth it to take two town for one scum.

[ActionDan]

Is anyone seriously reading Vax as scum? or even non-mafia scum?

[Nero Cain]

RR is and Mulch might?

[GuyInFreezer]

VC 1.03

Nero Cain (1):

Taly

Mulch (4):

TheGoldenParadox, Iconeum, Kokichi Oma, Dunnstral

Taly (1):

BBmolla

TheGoldenParadox (3):

Vaxkiller, davesaz, Radical Rat

Nero Cain (2):

Nero Cain, McMenno

Not Voting:

EddieFenix, Mulch, ActionDan

With

14

alive,

8

to lynch

Deadline:

(expired on 2018-04-28 15:28:30)

[Mulch]

VOTE: bbmolla

[Kokichi Oma]

Get mulch.

[Mulch]

VOTE: kokichu

Policy vote

[Radical Rat]

reroll

VOTE: McMenno

[Radical Rat]

VOTE: kokichu

Policy vote

Okay, NOW you're being anti-town

[Nero Cain]

*sigh*

vote: Mulch

lets get rid of the distraction/maybe scum and then power lynch Dave and RR.