Mini Normal 2005: Fun With Decimals(game over)

[Mumble]

Why are you voting the second towniest player in the game...

2nd towniest...really?

Why?

[Mumble]

And it's impossible for people to not have a firm opinion as to whether your claim is real or not?

No.

I'm not saying the read shouldn't be fluid as we progress, but there should be one.

[Something_Smart]

Why are you voting the second towniest player in the game...

2nd towniest...really?

Why?

Because you are the towniest

[Mumble]

Great.

Why is he 2nd?

[Something_Smart]

Because his analysis is really good.

[Mumble]

Which analysis is really good? Or, are you talking overall?

[Something_Smart]

Overall, yeah.

[Mumble]

Why aren't you voting?

[Zoronos]

Why are you asking for feedback on this? You asked for non-directed, open ended feedback on your "reasoning" for not taking a stance. Why not just say "Here's where I'm at" and take a stance, instead of presenting two possibilities and asking for feedback? That comes across as you positing a stance and seeing which one you should solidify.

Why am I asking for feedback? Because talking to other players is more effective than just shouting my opinions into the void.
Also, you are completely mischaracterizing that post. I very much took a stance in it.
Do you need me to make that stance more explicit?

[Mumble]

Why am I asking for feedback? Because talking to other players is more effective than just shouting my opinions into the void.
Also, you are completely mischaracterizing that post. I very much took a stance in it.
Do you need me to make that stance more explicit?

Just tell me why Smart, specifically.

[Zoronos]

Just tell me why Smart, specifically.

Oh, that's easy.
Based on his earlier statements about town players making contradictory statements, he seems like the sort of mafia player that would understand a read based on behavioral patterns and cognitive biases and what those biases suggest about alignments, and have a good opinion on whether or not this specific read fit the facts.

[Mr Moisto]

Hey gang sorry i havent been posting, i got alot more work this week then I originally thought i would get. Tonight when i get home im gonna review everything and make some swanky posts
.

[Mumble]

UNVOTE:

For now.

I like Ruby...I don't like where her vote sits...and sits. Re-examine tomorrow.

[Kokichi Oma]

Mumble claimed miller?

How would you miss that, there was a discussion about it.

[Kokichi Oma]

except kokichi that is

No idea why you refuse to reevaluate me.

[Kokichi Oma]

eat a rope

VOTE: Zoronos

This is an awful vote. Like, I want to see your reasoning to see if it's even plausible to come up with a reason to vote him there.

[Kokichi Oma]

*Kokichi gets scumread (as always when I see them play), and I feel like they mostly get it because of their style of posting, rather than what they post. I'll try to sort them tomorrow too, but I think that D1-reads on them tend to be wrong anyway.

Whenever I get scumread, I'm town. Whenever I get townread, I'm scum. It's what I've noticed.

Maybe I should just play every game like I'm scum.

[Kokichi Oma]

@Maria in 285- I mean I could see that but it feels like the effort was repeated and it seemed like you were actively trying to discredit instead of just asking "why is Ausuka town?" once like I'd expect town to do in that scenario? idk.

I guess it's definitely possible for Zoronos to be scum, but I'm not really seeing it. I was expecting him to do more with the question about my scumreads, though; he kinda just asked me and then ignored my answer. I agree that there's scum in the lurkers, but then again, there's always scum in the lurkers.

330 looks towny at first glance but I'll probably get a better read on unabombah once he posts whatever he's planning to w/ the reread.

There are 1-2 scum in {Espeonage, Mr Moisto, Arcangel9}

Koki wagon is going nowhere, so I want to try this.
VOTE: Mr Moisto

I thought you said Maria was scum?

[Kokichi Oma]

Something Smart's post there struck me as not-alignment-indicating - a fluffy post of a basic mafia truism; that early reads tend to be low quality. What struck you as scummy about it?

Zoronos read I follow and agree with. Seems to be genuinely solving and analyzing.

zero votes

abundance of townreads

filler questions

You quote none of the actual substance he's posted at all.

[Mumble]

eat a rope

VOTE: Zoronos

This is an awful vote. Like, I want to see your reasoning to see if it's even plausible to come up with a reason to vote him there.

Why was this awful, and mine not?

[Kokichi Oma]

Ruby why do you still scumread me even though it was a misunderstanding

what are you saying was a misunderstanding?

I didn't realize the post you made was a joke when you said Unabomb was wolfy, which is why I had that reaction.

[Kokichi Oma]

VOTE: Zoronos

I am either a town read or a scum read. For you to have me as null is horrible. Your entire post now reads as fake.

I missed this, but at least you give a solid reason as to why you think this. His "eat rope" and vote him randomly, and then bad explanation stands out to me.

[Dunnstral]

I didn't realize the post you made was a joke

It wasn't a joke

[Kokichi Oma]

Then why did Zoro say it was?

Either way, I like Ruby's posts but I don't like how he's tunneling over a page 2 post that is just initial reads.

[Dunnstral]

Read from 175 for the talk about that post being a joke