In post 1521, Oxy wrote:This is not true. That was a quickly put together synopsis of my reads, but even here I have draynth listed before Scioness. I gave a much larger read list not much earlier where I explained I was reading scioness more townie than draynth.
I apologize, I forgot that earlier post existed, and only remembered
1375. I need to relook at your interactions with the draynth wagon and thus re-evaluate the draynth wagon in general, but it's going to have to wait till I'm not running on like two hours of sleep.
--
Probably town.
How are you reading scioness?
--
In post 1520, Mathdino wrote:Skitter in what universe is Draynth an easier lynch when literally no one is defending scioness
I think that scioness is fairly capable of defending herself and making herself difficult to lynch when she's here.
--
Maybe I'm just really tired but I read this like six times and I can't figure out what it's trying to say, or why it lead to an unvote.
--
In post 1534, Mathdino wrote:your options are draynth and scioness, and
if you want to have shit reads, oxy
So things like the bolded are why I'm having trouble parsing your oxy read, because it seems like you have a fairly decent townread on him, which doesn't really add up with other things I brought up earlier:
In post 1361, skitter30 wrote:You're kinda vague about oxy and you say things like 'he's dropping in [your] townlist (1065); and say scum!him would be buddying you (533) - when ruru points out that he *does* seem to be buddying, you say you'll just re-check his ISO but never really followed through; 'oxy could be the scumread that slipped by you but you want to check {scioness/ud} first' (885)
Your read on him feels kinda malleable and hasn't been consistent. Like you say you're willing to consider scum!oxy when other people are, but keep on townbinning him despite that. I feel like your actions (consistently trying to drive people away from the oxy wagon) doesn't match what you're saying (you're open to considering scum!oxy), and that your reasons for townreading him don't match what he's actually done.
I really, really dislike the quote that says your townread on him dropped as people were voting him.
I'm low-key beginning to wonder if I've read the oxy/math dynamic wrong, and that it isn't scum!oxy buddying town!math, but scum!math pocketing town!oxy.
--
In post 1550, Scioness Sajj wrote:skitter - meh I think MD has already engaged her about it. she would lynch me because I have not good enough content but I don't really have that much content to begin with? it feels like she wants to have that scumread on me since I have engaged her on giving me a townlean that I didn't deserve.
What I was basically looking for was a post like
1533 - it's nuanced, and by that I mean it picks up on a small number of fairly subtle details of ofrhz's behavior that I don't think scum would notice in the first place, and uses those details to explain a consistent scumread. That's pretty much the kind of post that I townread you for last time, the one explaining your ruru townread early on. The ofrhz read is also kinda contrary, like you don't really care what other people think about this read and you're going to pursue it cuz you believe in it even if that's not what the gamestate is supporting right now.
This post feels very, very, very similar to me to a lot of posts from last game.
It's enough to take you out of my lynchpool for today, actually.
--
this is actually a pretty gross reaction to that :/
a) You're not really defending yourself, but indicating that you still find her (and thus her case) scummy enough to vote her over
B) Why is your primary concern after she cased you whether or not she'll have time to claim in the next three days? It almost feels like you want to wagon her *to get her claim*, and not necessarily to like lynch scum.
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile"){kind=icon}
