Gunner Mafia [Endgame]

[Panopticon]

Hi:

Lmao well we basically have the game solved so I don't mind being sacrificed.

Does scum!Cheeky act like this?

If cheeky defended himself, he'd be scum.
So cheeky doesn't defend himself so he's town
But if cheeky was scum cheeky would know this, so he wouldn't defend himself
But if cheeky knows that we know this cheeky would defend himself so that he doesn't look like scum who knows that scum cheeky wouldn't defend himself
...

The best solution is always to offer a better lynch candidate. Who do you think we should lynch? I'm partial to a Tchill wagon meself.

Cheeky is a she last I heard.

[Brian Skies]

I was more negative about Pan until Hopkirk pointed out Srceen's limp wrist attack.

I'm not really interested in the limp wrist attack because I feel like both were being pressured pretty heavily up to that point and felt like a good time for one or both of them to distance or bus if they're buddies.

I think it's interesting to not that when I pushed them for calling me out as cheerleading, they took a snipe at me for voting srceen (who I had been scumreading at the time, and they were pushing TChill at the time, so them having a gripe over me voting srceen over Hopkirk was very ??? to me).

The second time I pushed them, they took a shot at me for not voting srceen (I was voting Maria at the time). And then it was followed up by this weird 'Maria or Elli is scum' which was just very :/ to me.

I still think they were trying to fan the flames with either me/Spiffeh or me/Hopkirk. And I still didn't like the way they tried to defend against Gork with 'how dare you scumread me for something my other head did.'

[Panopticon]

>was voting srceen despite not scumreading him

>when you scumread srceen you weren't voting him

[Panopticon]

I forgot you got a scum role pm this game, thanks for reminding me.

VOTE: Brian Skies

[Brian Skies]

There was a progression to my votes in that I moved my vote to Srceen because I thought he was scummy in his interactions with Thor. Thor wasn't even voting him and there were a lot of people voting TChill (and a lot of people weren't even paying attention to Srceen, which remained true all the way until we lynched him), so I pushed the TChill wagon to push the game along. I unvoted TChill because the wagon blew up and I didn't really think he was that scummy. I moved to Maria because Cheeky was like, 'come vote Maria with us' and I was like, sure, that looks like a decent avenue to pursue, and I stayed on Maria because her responses to me were very underwhelming and I didn't like them.

[Creature]

Also, I think randomidget should be town, but should leave someone better at reading randomidget to determine that.

[GreyICE]

Scum who never puts in a fail card is functionally equivilent to an extra town.
Town who put in a fail card are breaking core game rules.

Screen claimed it was possible to do something it's not possible to do in game to attack Pan, likely hoping nobody would realize it couldn't be done.

It's possible he could have said 'oh, I meant I was playing online and I'd look at the role after a couple of nights'. I would have doubted that because:
- I checked on site, and he wasn't playing there.
- It sounded like he meant playing irl.
- Checking your role card irl would be a lot trickier than online due to the fact you can see people/body language and stuff.
- Talking about people getting annoyed d1 is different to not checking d1/intent to check later.

-He didn't say that when I asked him, he dodged the question (or gave an answer that didn't explain things).

Hopkirk is town by the by. And it's not like I haven't beaten the drum of a Hopkirk lynch, so this is some crow eating.

This is not only an accurate summary of the game, it's an accurate summary of why Lynch All Liars (no matter how irrelevant the lie seems) is great play.

[Spiffeh]

TCHILL IS CURRENTLY ONLINE, AND VOTING FOR GREYICE

TCHILL PLEASE HAMMER

What's the followup on this, friends?

Because I might want to lynch Tchill as well. I know, I know, it was kind of a drum I beat day 1, but I have yet to be convinced it's a bad one.

To be fair the hammer occurred a minute after I said this so I don't think it's that big of a deal

[CheekyTeeky]

Creature why is the worst town?

Were you present at the time he was hyperposting?

No?

[Brian Skies]

>was voting srceen despite not scumreading him

Slight Scumlean
Srceen - My gut says otherwise, but I feel like this post is unnecessarily nitpicky (and I feel like that's more of something scum might do). I'm also not getting good vibes from his hardtunnel on the Quick slot. So it's probably more appropriate to put him here even though

VOTE: srceenplay

Let me know whether or not 603 comes before 1006.

[Brian Skies]

This is not only an accurate summary of the game, it's an accurate summary of why Lynch All Liars (no matter how irrelevant the lie seems) is great play.

Except he didn't even do this?

[CheekyTeeky]

Tbh I don't even know what Hopkirk is talking about lol.

[Panopticon]

>was voting srceen despite not scumreading him

Slight Scumlean
Srceen - My gut says otherwise, but I feel like this post is unnecessarily nitpicky (and I feel like that's more of something scum might do). I'm also not getting good vibes from his hardtunnel on the Quick slot. So it's probably more appropriate to put him here even though

VOTE: srceenplay

Let me know whether or not 603 comes before 1006.

Ignoring the part where you sat him back to null in the meantime.

[Brian Skies]

>was voting srceen despite not scumreading him

Slight Scumlean
Srceen - My gut says otherwise, but I feel like this post is unnecessarily nitpicky (and I feel like that's more of something scum might do). I'm also not getting good vibes from his hardtunnel on the Quick slot. So it's probably more appropriate to put him here even though

VOTE: srceenplay

Let me know whether or not 603 comes before 1006.

Ignoring the part where you sat him back to null in the meantime.

When did this ever happen? Quote it.

[Brian Skies]

Neutrals
15. Spiffeh (Liked a few of your posts but I'd like to see you consider voting someone besides Brian, at least for day 1. Even if he is cheerleading atm.)
6. Ausuka [Scumlean -> Neutral]
11. GreyICE [Scumread -> Neutral] (I'll admit this one stings my pride)
14. Srceenplay [Townlean -> Neutral]
20. Brian Skies [Townlean -> Neutral] (You're cheerleading, not scumhunting)

You know who did sit him down as a nullread? You two did.

[Nero Cain]

I still don't really think that Grey is town just b/c Screen flipped scum.

@Thor

, Why are you town reading the chick slot?

but I can get behind a Cheely wagon.

vote:Cheeky

[Creature]

I still don't really think that Grey is town just b/c Screen flipped scum.

nor do I. Srceenplay was bus material and almost a cop guilty.

[northsidegal]

Votecount 2.64 MANUAL

CheekyTeeky

(4) ~ Hopkirk, Gorkington, Brigand Vvulf, Nero Cain

Hopkirk

(1) ~ CheekyTeeky

Brian Skies

(1) ~ Panopticon

Players dead: MariaR,Ausuka,Srceenplay

Not Voting (14): Town Gunner, Mafia Gunner, randomidget, Beeboy, Thor665, Bins, Chickadee, GreyICE, The Worst, Spiffeh, Tchill13, Centipede Syndrome, Brian Skies, Creature

With 18 alive it takes 10 to lynch.

Day 2 deadline is in (expired on 2018-05-07 12:19:59)

[GreyICE]

I still don't really think that Grey is town just b/c Screen flipped scum.

nor do I. Srceenplay was bus material and almost a cop guilty.

How'd you manage to miss voting for him then?

[Creature]

I still don't really think that Grey is town just b/c Screen flipped scum.

nor do I. Srceenplay was bus material and almost a cop guilty.

How'd you manage to miss voting for him then?

I wanted to lynch some scum that could actually get to endgame unlike Srceenplay.

[GreyICE]

I really hope that's not your actual reasoning for voting town over scum. Power roles exist y'know, no one is good enough not to run afoul of them. But that's probably a discussion in the postgame, once I know your alignment.

Tchill's Ausuka case makes me feel slightly better about him. Not much, but slightly.

Northsidegal: I assume Gorkington isn't actually a player dead and that's a vote count error

[northsidegal]

I really hope that's not your actual reasoning for voting town over scum. Power roles exist y'know, no one is good enough not to run afoul of them. But that's probably a discussion in the postgame, once I know your alignment.

Tchill's Ausuka case makes me feel slightly better about him. Not much, but slightly.

Northsidegal: I assume Gorkington isn't actually a player dead and that's a vote count error

Fixed, thanks.

[the worst]

Hopkirk you should play Resistance with us in the Mish Mash!

(3 pages behind brt)

[the worst]

UNVOTE:

I'm sorta tempted to strike out Brian and Brigand too.

Was Ausuka's push on Brian really not w/w?

Why Brian actually Creature?

He's a very lukewarm town for me.

[the worst]

Given the resurrection mechanic seems to be pro town (scum resurrection mechanic would be cooked as) we might have like 6 or even 7 scum maybe?