Product Placement Mafia (Game over!)

[Brian Skies]

Wait a second...

[Brian Skies]

*counts on feet*

[Brian Skies]

Can we wagon Hiplop for breaking our hearts again?

[Firebringer]

Can we wagon Hiplop for breaking our hearts again?

Yes

VOTE: hiplop

[Gammagooey]

Can we wagon Hiplop for breaking our hearts again?

Yes

VOTE: hiplop

I mean we can I guess

I don't think he's particularly more or less likely than arc to be scum (maybe a tiny bit more even) but I'd feel a lot worse about it if he were town

I guess I see it as the difference between a likely genuine attempt to read the game and participate against arc's self delusion that she'll be caught up eventually despite never reading enough posts that aren't centered on herself to have a read on a single player in the game

[Alisae]

Reading it tonight! WIll be the most active player in the game mark my words

HIPPY THIS WAS TWO DAYS AGO

[CheekyTeeky]

If all the scum are low posters that would be funny. Feel better about Arc over Hip.

Low posters: AA9, Hiplop, Hyung, PP
Intermittent posters: Vecna, NSG, Vaxkiller

Whichever of you isn't scum, you're letting the team down.

[Untrod Tripod]

PP and NSG have been prodded

[Pine]

Blah blah blah

You're all underestimating the difficulty of catching up to a 73-page game. I have difficulty catching up when I'm even ten pages behind.

Lurking through D1 is not a valid reason for suspicion. It's condescension towards people with lives.

[CheekyTeeky]

Hey scummies... Give me a day. Will catch up!!

Just got back and i am going to catch up in a bit. So will join the party

Except that she's been trying to catch up from page 11. If she struggled with 11....I don't see it getting better. A town player would've replaced out by now imo.

It's worth noting that AA9 being a potential mislynch is the only thing Pine seems to care about today. Surely his energy would be better spent convincing us Mutant is scum to which he still hasn't provided a reason beyond AA9 being a mislynch as a counterwagon to mutant. This change in Pine caring about the game started around the time LLD entered so I'm not sure if the coincidence is significant or not yet.

[mutantdevle]

those posts make no sense

Can you not see how what I've quoted would be their answer to your question?

"the day ends faster if i waste our VCs" isn't a compelling or logical argument

I agree. But that’s what they were going for. Now it’s your job to judge their allignment based on that motivation and fallacy.

[Pine]

Hey scummies... Give me a day. Will catch up!!

Just got back and i am going to catch up in a bit. So will join the party

Except that she's been trying to catch up from page 11. If she struggled with 11....I don't see it getting better.

A town player would've replaced out by now imo

.

It's worth noting that AA9 being a potential mislynch is the only thing Pine seems to care about today. Surely his energy would be better spent convincing us Mutant is scum to which he still hasn't provided a reason beyond AA9 being a mislynch as a counterwagon to mutant. This change in Pine caring about the game started around the time LLD entered so I'm not sure if the coincidence is significant or not yet.

Bullshit to the bolded. People aren't perfect and noble; they stay in games they want to play in.

Again, this sort of thing happens ALL THE TIME. You fucks shitpost all day while the adults have work, school, children, and real lives, and then you condescend to us as if we're lazy for not having the time to catch up to a 70+ page game.

The AA9 lynch is LAZY, and ignores people who have actually been scummy.

[northsidegal]

Hey scummies... Give me a day. Will catch up!!

Just got back and i am going to catch up in a bit. So will join the party

Except that she's been trying to catch up from page 11. If she struggled with 11....I don't see it getting better.

A town player would've replaced out by now imo

.

It's worth noting that AA9 being a potential mislynch is the only thing Pine seems to care about today. Surely his energy would be better spent convincing us Mutant is scum to which he still hasn't provided a reason beyond AA9 being a mislynch as a counterwagon to mutant. This change in Pine caring about the game started around the time LLD entered so I'm not sure if the coincidence is significant or not yet.

Bullshit to the bolded. People aren't perfect and noble; they stay in games they want to play in.

Again, this sort of thing happens ALL THE TIME. You fucks shitpost all day while the adults have work, school, children, and real lives, and then you condescend to us as if we're lazy for not having the time to catch up to a 70+ page game.

The AA9 lynch is LAZY, and ignores people who have actually been scummy.

pine is completely right here, i think. it doesn't necessarily make him town, but he's completely right.

UNVOTE:

[northsidegal]

People i'd vote (in no particular order):

Gamma
hyung
Firebringer
brassherald
Brian Skies


VOTE: brian skies

Fuck it's hard to ask these questions when it's so long ago but

you listed 5 names. Why would you vote each of these people at that time, and why did you choose to vote Brian over the others?

it's been a while so i might not completely remember everything. gamma you presumably already read my reasoning for. hyung i knew had a meta of lurking as scum, and going under the assumption that he was marquis i would've supported a wagon on him to see how he reacted (also i didn't want to make the same mistake i did in team mafia white flag). firebringer i kind of forget. he was probably messing around enough for me to consider it scummy. brassherald had a terrible intro i think and had a weird vote on cheeky. i think alisae still has an okay chance to be scum based on brassherald (and just based on alisae's posting / pushing of t-bone). brian skies wasn't doing anything which i'm pretty sure is a scumtell for him. i forget why i chose him specifically.

and, on that note,

VOTE: brian skies

[northsidegal]

I havne't been following my own philosophy of voting the silently scummy people who just skate by. This vote is mainly for brian's case on t-bone.

[Brian Skies]

Again, this sort of thing happens ALL THE TIME. You fucks shitpost all day while the adults have work, school, children, and real lives, and then you condescend to us as if we're lazy for not having the time to catch up to a 70+ page game.

Says an admitted shitposter.

[Pine]

Again, this sort of thing happens ALL THE TIME. You fucks shitpost all day while the adults have work, school, children, and real lives, and then you condescend to us as if we're lazy for not having the time to catch up to a 70+ page game.

Says an admitted shitposter.

I very rarely shitpost. In this game I fucked around a bit because that was what a lot of us were doing, and I usually suck at sorting on D1. I skimmed a lot of the first half of the game because it was pretty devoid of useful content.

Don't pull out the "yeah but" argument. It's a very bad strategy to point out someone else's alleged flaws to distract from the weaknesses in your own case. Just because I dicked around a bit this game doesn't make AA9 scum for having a hard time keeping up.

[Brian Skies]

Again, this sort of thing happens ALL THE TIME. You fucks shitpost all day while the adults have work, school, children, and real lives, and then you condescend to us as if we're lazy for not having the time to catch up to a 70+ page game.

Says an admitted shitposter.

I very rarely shitpost. In this game I fucked around a bit because that was what a lot of us were doing, and I usually suck at sorting on D1. I skimmed a lot of the first half of the game because it was pretty devoid of useful content.

Don't pull out the "yeah but" argument. It's a very bad strategy to point out someone else's alleged flaws to distract from the weaknesses in your own case. Just because I dicked around a bit this game doesn't make AA9 scum for having a hard time keeping up.

I mean, you contributed to the problem. So of course I'm going to point out when you try to act like it's everyone else's fault but yours.

[Pine]

Yeah, and I stopped. You're focusing on the minutia, and ignoring the broader thrust of my point. That isn't a valid rhetorical tactic.

[Brian Skies]

The AA9 lynch is LAZY, and ignores people who have actually been scummy.

Who are all the people that have been scummy, then?

[Vecna]

Pine, I agree with your points, mostly, but at what point do we lynch a never contributing aa9? Because its not like the volume of posts is gonna decrease significantly.

Last game i played with that aa9 the exact same thing happened. extra effort was promised but never came, resulting in a later game lynch on the slot. It was done as town tmaa9 that game, but its not like that means its ai this game.

I have no faith whatsoever that contribution is ever gonna come. A lynch is gonna happen on the slot regardless.

[Pine]

Pine, I agree with your points, mostly, but at what point do we lynch a never contributing aa9?

Because its not like the volume of posts is gonna decrease significantly.

Last game i played with that aa9 the exact same thing happened. extra effort was promised but never came, resulting in a later game lynch on the slot. It was done as town tmaa9 that game, but its not like that means its ai this game.

I have no faith whatsoever that contribution is ever gonna come. A lynch is gonna happen on the slot regardless.

Not on D1. Probably not on D2. D1 is usually the toughest, and D2 is usually half the pace. D3 is often 1/3 the pace. At that point, there's no excuse, and it becomes suspicious.

When and if the lack of contribution actually manifests, we can talk about it. Until then, we have actual scummy players to investigate and lynch. On my agenda are Mutant and Vaxkiller, with Cheeky, LLD, Fire, and Reck previously dealt with. Also valid agendas would include sorting Alisae, Hyung and, frankly, you. I could also get behind pressuring hiplop, Penguin, and either Gamma, all of whom are similarly-low content slots which you seem to have no problem with. In fact, it's *really* suspicious that there's such an easy wagon on AA9, but no one wants to pressure any of those people. Personally, I find it to be tantamount to proof that she's Town.

[Alisae]

Wait Pine you have me as null/unsorted?
What’s up?

[Pine]

Something feels off about you, love. I haven't focused in on it to sort that concern, but you're tingling my spider sense.

[Alisae]

Meh I think I’m pretty ez to read and tbh I don’t have much to add to the gamestate atm so I’m kinda just being fairly quiet.