In post 851, Ruby Red wrote:no, it goes deeper than that
morality apparently has experience with una, enough that he can confidently sort him. if i trust him on this, then this means there's never a world in which una is a wolf while morality is villa. there are only worlds in which they're both villa or morality is wolf with either a una wolfbuddy or hard defending una villa. if you think una is a wolf, it mechanically makes more sense to lynch morality. on morality's villa flip if we trust his read then we can also take it as confirmation that una is villa. if morality flips wolf, then proceed from there.
4 permutations of two people being wolf or villager, remove the "una w morality v" permutation, there are two permutations of morality wolf and one of una wolf, and a morality villa flip can confirm una villa.
1) I have no reason to trust that he can make that sort correctly. Morality flipping green doesn't automatically mean Una is also green.
2) I appreciate the mechanical reasoning there. I really do. But there also exists the scenario where Una and Morality are friends, Morality is just trying to defend una blindly, and is wrong.
I totally understand where you're coming from, I've been worried about a scum-white-knights-town scenario ever since Morality jumped in with the hard defense. But at the end of the day, I have direct evidence of una being scum and only circumstancial / associative evidence for Morality.
I'd lynch Morality before anyone in my town buckets, which, well, I'm not super happy with either wagon currently under consideration since as noted we've got two lynches from my town reads, but I'd rather active scum over maybe scum.
