Mini Normal 2005: Fun With Decimals(game over)

[MariaR]

Before I go to bed I still think Una is town for reasons I'll explain in the am
If I was to have my cake and eat it too after my lynch lynch mumble track una (for you guys) otherwise look at Dunn/nsg but dunn slot figures itself out so don't lynch that

[northsidegal]

i don't understand how you could possibly think i'm scum.

[Zoronos]

I actually had a similar feeling about Koki early d1 which is another part of why I want Una lynched after Maria. I'm sheeping my mason buddy a little wrt actually deciding to shoot Koki. He is always lynchable but it took me a while to go "yeah ok this is scum motivated lynchbait"

Koki was also Una's strongest read so far d1. I'd be surprised if he swung in to hard defend lynchbait who he knew was scum then went quieter again.

Someone who knows Una better may have a better take than me here but it doesn't *feel* quite so good.

So, one thing I see scum frequently do is say 'Yeah, X and Y are scummy' then vote Y, where X is their scum buddy. And every time Y changes or gets lynched, a new Y is found. They somehow never vote X. Scum will shade other scum or put them into their lynch pools, but I find it's much rarer that they'll call their scum buddies town.
That's why I asked the question - I think what I wrote is a more general case and doesn't always apply to all players. So I'm trying to get some perspective here. I might be wrong about Una, I think he's likely the best lynch here, but I want to talk it through rather than sit on 'being ahead' and make fast choices.

[Zoronos]

Before I go to bed I still think Una is town for reasons I'll explain in the am
If I was to have my cake and eat it too after my lynch lynch mumble track una (for you guys) otherwise look at Dunn/nsg but dunn slot figures itself out so don't lynch that

I think the chance of NSG being scum is very low.
Kokichi and NSG would have had to be cross-bussing almost all of D1.

[the worst]

I think NSG is about as likely to be scum as the mod here

[UnaBombaH]

I just feel very "outside" of this game, thats all.
I missed with my Koki read AGAIN, I missed D2 completely, and I misinterpreted Ruby 100%.
Ever since it has been NSG, I've had no scumvibes from there.
Only thing I'm really OK with, is that I didn't blindly fall into Boons pocket..and thats about that.

[Espeonage]

Yeah I didn't get to post yesterday either.

At least I am 50% correct this game.

[Something_Smart]

is there a world in which morality told him to bus via tracker fakeclaim so he could claim friendly sk and try to get through?

No.

They had no daytalk and the vig would have disrupted any plans they made overnight.

[TwoInAMillion]

Vote Count 3.01
MariaR[2]: Northsidegal, the worst[L-3]
UnabombaH[1]: Mumble
Zoronos[1]: Espeonage
Not Voting[5]: UnabombaH, MariaR, Zoronos, Dunnstral, Something_Smart
With 9 alive, it requires 5 to lynch
Day ends in (expired on 2018-05-14 19:50:18) or when a lynch occurs.

[northsidegal]

you missed espeonage's vote

[Dunnstral]

Well I tracked unabombah and was told he didn't go anywhere, I'm not sure how much that is worth as there was no night kill

If I was to have my cake and eat it too after my lynch lynch mumble track una (for you guys) otherwise look at Dunn/nsg but dunn slot figures itself out so don't lynch that

You've been wrong all game

[UnaBombaH]

Well I tracked unabombah and was told he didn't go anywhere

Must've been boring to watch me sleep all night...you creep.

[the worst]

do you snore?

[UnaBombaH]

I might sleeptalk.

[the worst]

to your scumbuddies eh?

[UnaBombaH]

Well, if I say something like "Kill Kill Kill" in my sleep, it's definitely not towards my fellow townsfolk..

[Zoronos]

I'm not scum.
Maria likely is.
I've been busy.
GJ on Morality people - shame that I wasn't around for D2 at all.
Boon thinking I was an easy pocket for early game, and a mislynch for late makes a lot of sense.
Am willing to claim at any time if asked to, but it probably won't help solving the game.

Why Maria? Explain your reasoning.
You thought Mumble was scum on D1 and basically weren't around for D2 - has your read changed and why? A one shot cop flipped. Do you feel that makes sense with a Miller?

Una you didn't answer any of my questions.

[UnaBombaH]

You thought Mumble was scum on D1 and basically weren't around for D2 - has your read changed and why? A one shot cop flipped. Do you feel that makes sense with a Miller?

All I can say here is that I don't think a 1-shot Cop in itself "fits" a Miller.
Then again, setup spec. might not quite be my forte.
I also want to clarify, that I think the way Mumble claimed Miller, was the biggest reason it pinged me.
So far on this site, noticing bullshit in the form of fakeclaims HAS been one of my stronger suits, but I've been rather off with all of my reads the past few weeks..

[Mumble]

What was wrong with the way that I claimed Miller? I literally said “I’m Town Miller.”

[UnaBombaH]

Not sure what the difference is, but the one that appears as guilty in all cop investigations.

I mean, people seemed to think this didn't matter, but it pinged me.
I think I also asked whether your role-PM specifically said "all cop investigations".

[Mumble]

I don’t know what the difference between universal Miller and Miller is. I paraphrased my role pm. It’s says all cop investigations.

You latching on to that for three days and not doing anything else is why you are scum. And, don’t give me that “you were busy” because you’ve been active elsewhere on site plenty.

[Zoronos]

You thought Mumble was scum on D1 and basically weren't around for D2 - has your read changed and why? A one shot cop flipped. Do you feel that makes sense with a Miller?

All I can say here is that I don't think a 1-shot Cop in itself "fits" a Miller.
Then again, setup spec. might not quite be my forte.
I also want to clarify, that I think the way Mumble claimed Miller, was the biggest reason it pinged me.
So far on this site, noticing bullshit in the form of fakeclaims HAS been one of my stronger suits, but I've been rather off with all of my reads the past few weeks..

So, did your read change on him?
Also, you ignored the part about why you thought Maria was scum, and given your earlier-today preference for lynching her, that seems the most relevant part of the questions.

tl;dr - Your D1 lynch preference was mumble, where did that read go and why did it go away, and now your D3 lynch preference is Maria, why do you think that?

[the worst]

You thought Mumble was scum on D1 and basically weren't around for D2 - has your read changed and why? A one shot cop flipped. Do you feel that makes sense with a Miller?

All I can say here is that I don't think a 1-shot Cop in itself "fits" a Miller.
Then again, setup spec. might not quite be my forte.
I also want to clarify, that I think the way Mumble claimed Miller, was the biggest reason it pinged me.
So far on this site, noticing bullshit in the form of fakeclaims HAS been one of my stronger suits, but I've been rather off with all of my reads the past few weeks..

Do you think Mumble is scum?

[MariaR]

Hi so I don't think mort/una is scum v scum via interactions I don't like how people are lock townreading Nsg I think the only thing that looks up for her is the kokichi vote. Wouldn't lynch people like zora or S_S over her I think lynching mumble rnsg after me wins the game

[northsidegal]

i literally don't think i've ever cast a vote against a scumbuddy.